OSCAR BIE (continued 7)
E. E. (Ernest Edward) Kellett translation
It is noteworthy that in Schytte’s “Silhouettes,” or Variations on the same theme in the different styles of various Masters, he nowhere fails so badly as with Bach, who is marked by retardations in the middle voices, or with Beethoven, who is characterised by gloomy rhythm. The true path seems to have been lost. The line through Bach, Beethoven, Schumann, and Brahms, is the only safe line for the piano; and it is the line in music furthest removed from the opera. In those great natures, whether they knew it or not, was a strong repugnance to the opera; and Brahms, whose eulogists said he was the last of his race, will perhaps one day be viewed as the connecting link between the old and a new musical culture.
It is in chamber-music alone that we have the right to look for great triumphs in the immediate future; triumphs of which Klinger’s “Radierungen,” Brahms’s “Clarinet Quintet” or Smetana’s “Aus Meinem Leben,” are at once the anticipation and the guarantee.
It is for our children to see to it that the great traditions of the past are not forgotten; and that the building which it will fall to them to erect is not unworthy of its foundation.

Postscript
Prosniz’s “Handbuch der Klavier-litteratur,” which goes down to 1830, and the new edition of Weitzmann’s “History of Piano-playing and Piano-literature,” now in preparation, supply a complete apparatus of all the sources of information necessary to the student. Thus I have been able in this work, to the exclusion of all dryasdust references to authorities, to present the development of piano-literature from the point of view of culture and of human interest. For procuring the material which lies in the works themselves and contemporary writings, I am indebted to the labours of Dr Kopfermann, Director of The Royal Library of Music at Berlin. I am enabled to give the illustrations by the extreme kindness of Mr Otto Lessmann, the Baroness Wilhelm von Rothschild, Mr Nicolas Manskopf, Mr Edwin Bechstein, Mr de Wit, Madame Bülow, Madame Marie Fellinger, and others.
Errata
P. 43. The note on Agricola is a mistake. M. Agricola is of the early 16th century. Bach’s pupil was J. F. Agricola, for whom see p. 122, note.
P. 48. For “Tielman Sufato” read “Sufato Tielman.”
P. 63, line 2. For “brown” read “yellow.”
P. 63, line 2. For “dark grey” read “gris de Maure.”
P. 70, line 27. According to the latest investigations Scarlatti died in Naples in 1757; thus he must have returned from Spain to Italy. (Cf. “Gazette Musicale,” Napoli, 15th Sept. 1898.)
P. 114, line 19. For “Hezekiah’s” read “Gideon’s.”
Addendum
P. 16. Note. That one of the earliest indications of the 18th century suite is to be seen in the Elizabethan “Parthenia,” viz., in the association of Prelude, Pavan, Galliard.
Index of Names and Matters
Accompagnato—style, 95
Adam, L., 160, 186, 192
Agricola, M., 43 (see Erratum)
Alkan, 317
Ansorge, 301
Aria, 72
Arne, T. A., 38
Aston, 27
Attaignant, 42
Baake, 191
Bach, Friedemann, 138
Bach, John Christian, 94, 148, 159
Bach, John Sebastian, 91 ff.
Life, 93
His contrapuntal method, 94
Accompagnato, 95
Style of work, 96
Construction of his pieces, 96
Technique, 116
Clavier method, 118
Bach and the Hammer-clavier, 122
Original editions of, 102
Toccatas, 98
Symphonies and Inventions, 97
Fugues, 100
“Art of Fugue,” 103
Wohltemperiertes Klavier, 102, 112, 113, 116, 119
Chromatic Fantasia, 103
Other Fantasias, 109, 110
Partitas, 104
English Suites, 106
Overture in French Style, 120
Italian Concerto, 109
Preludes, 112
Programme-music, 114
Goldberg Variations, 117
Other mentions, 148, 163, 326
Bach, Philip Emanuel, 128 ff.
Life, 138
The “Versuch,” 139
“Manieren,” 140
Harmonies, 144
Melody, 144
Works, 143
Amalia-sonatas, 145
Barth, 306
“Bebung,” 20, 119
Bechstein, 310
Beethoven, 157 ff.
Reformer, 158
Tragedy in Music of, 169
Concertos, 170
Scherzi, 169
Forms, 171
Style of playing, 183
Sonatas in detail, 175 ff.
Bembo, Pietro, 77
Benedict, 191
Bennett, Sterndale, 268
Berger, Ludwig, 184, 191, 193
Berger, Wilhelm, 323
Bertini, 205
Besardus, 12
Bird, William, 27-31
Carman’s Whistle, 31
Bischoff, 307, 316
Blow, John, 38
Blüthner, 310
Böhner, 245
Bösendorfer, 310
Bononcini, 74
Borodin, 320
Borwick, 300
Brahms, 322
Brendel, Franz, 322
Breslaur, 304
Broadwood, 133, 169
Bülow, Hans von, 296
King’s Hunt, 35
Busoni, 301
Buxtehude, 92
Caccini, 75
Carissimi, 78
Carreño, Madame, 303
Cavalieri, 77
Cavalli, 75
Chabrier, 319
Chambonnières, 52
Chaminade, Cécile, 319
Chopin, 256 ff.
Etudes, 203, 263
Chopin and Hummel, 261
Life, 258
Works, 262
Playing, 257
Clavichord, the, 19, 20, 89, 91, 124
Clavicymbal, 23, 81
Clauss-Savardy, 293
Clementi, 190, 208
Group of his followers, 191, 193
Collard, 193
Compass of clavier, etc., 19-22, 24, 211
Concertos, 109, 151, 170, 319, etc.
Contests, musical, 91, 161, 163
Corelli, 78, 82
Counterpoint, 9, 79, 84, 85
Couperin, François, 53 ff.
Content of his pieces, 56
Forms, 55
L’art de toucher le clavécin, 63, 64
Couperin, Louise, 59
Couplet in Rondo, 55, 147 note
Cramer, 194, 210
Cristofori, 121, 122, 133
Cui, 320
Czerny, 190, 216
Da Capo, 84
D’Agoult, 276
D’Albert, Eugene, 307, 324
Dance
Old English, 18
First instrumental dances, 15, 42
French danseuses, 43 ff.
Oldest books of dances, 52
Old dance forms, 55
Allemand, etc.
Dandrieu, 49, 65
D’Anglebert, 40, 65
Dawson, 300
Diémer, 302, 309
D’Indy, Vincent, 319
Diruta, 24, 80
Döhler, 291, 293
Donizetti, 202
Dorn, H., 191
Dreyschock, 293
Dubois, 319
Dumont, 65
Dupont, 306
Durante, 89
Dussek, 159, 163 ff.
Duysen, 310
Eberl, 183, 190
Eckard, Joh., 48
Eckard (Paris), 160
Elizabeth, Queen, 3, 4
Elsner, 265
English relations to French music, 15, 41
Erard, 133
Ertmann, Baroness, 160
Essipoff, Madame, 293
Étude, 203 ff.
Fantasia, Italian, 80
Fantasia, free, 145 F. senza tempo, 143
Farnaby, 37
Farrenc, 52
Fauré, 319
Field, 159, 193, 265
Fingering, in old times, 26, 81, 116
Fischer, 303
Fleischer, Oskar, 41
Fortbien, 133
Franck, C., 319
French Characteristic Pieces, 132, 148
Frescobaldi, 73, 79, 80, 92
Freund, 306
Friederici, 133
Friedheim, 301
Froberger, 92
Gabrieli, 15, 26, 79, 92
Gabrilowitsch, 301
Gade, 321
Galilei, Vincenzio, 77
Gallot, 51
Galuppi, 89
Gasparini, 70
Gaultier, 41, 50
Gelinek, 161, 183
General Bass (see Thorough Bass), 284
Germer, 307
Gibbons, 7, 16, 37
Glasounow, 320
Gorlier, 15
Graf Pianos, 182
Gravicymbel, 133
Greulich, 191
Grieg, 321
Guicciardi, Julia, 160
Hackebrett (dulcimer), 121
Handel, 74, 138
Hässler, 159
Hammer-klavier, 121, 312
Hartvigson, 300
Hasler, 92
Hasse, 14
Hausmann, 309
Haydn, 149, 159
Hebenstreit, 121, 122
Heller, Stephen, 318, 319
Henselt, 318
Herz, 201
Heymann, 301
Hiller, Ferdinand, 191, 317
Hofmann, Jos., 301
Hüllmandel, 192
Hummel, 190, 193, 211, 212 ff.
Hünten, 201
Hurdy-gurdy, 21
Ibach, 310
Improvisation, 161, 162 (Mozart), 198
In Bach’s time, 130
In 1800, 161, 198, 211
Irmler, 310
Isaac, 92
Italian Forms, 78-80
Chamber Music, 78
Jadin, 192
Jaell, 293
Janko, 308
Jannequin, 48, 49, 50, 61
Jedliczka, 306
Jensen, Adolf, 322
Joseffy, 306
Judenkunig, 11
Kalkbrenner, 190, 192, 198, 218
Kaps, 310
Karr, 201
“Kenner und Liebhaber,” 143
Kienzl, 323, 324
Kirchner, 318
Kirnberger, 131
Kittl, 191
Kjerulf, 322
Klauwell, 304
Klavier (see Pianoforte), 18, 21, 23, 121
“Klavierlehrer,” paper, 305
Kleeberg, 293
Klengel, 193
Klindworth, 306
Knabe, 310
Koch, 315
Köhler, 189
Kontski, 190, 201
Kozeluch, 190, 210
Krebs, 145
Kuhnau, 92
“Quacksalver,” 129
“Biblical Stories,” 119
Kullak, Ad., 306
Kullak, Franz, 306
Kullak, Th., 191, 304, 306
Lacombe, 319
Lasso, Orlando, 26, 37
Le Begue, 65
Lebert, 306
Leschetizki, 308
Liadoff, 320
Lipawsky, 161
Liszt, 193, 264, 271, 287 ff.
Locatelli, 82
Loeilly, 65
Löschhorn, 191
Logier, 190
Louis Ferdinand, Prince, 164
Lully, 44
Lütschg, 301
Lute in Middle Ages, 11, 77
Marcello, 76
Marchand, 91
Marius, 122
Marpurg, 130
M’Dowell, 322
Mela, Domenico des, 314
Menter, Sophie, 293
Merulo, 79 and note
Meyerbeer, 194
Monteverde, 79
Moore, Graham, 322
Morley, Thomas, 37
Mortier de Fontaine, 293
Moscheles 152, 196, 198, 221
Moskowski, 306, 325 f.
Mozart, 151
Mozart and the piano, 135
Clavier concerts, 151
Sonatas, 153 ff.
Miscellaneous, 161
Müller, A. E., 190
Mulliner Book, 27
Munday, John, 36, 93
Mussorgsky, 320
Naprawnik, 320
Neitzel, 316
Opera, Italian, 13, 74 ff.
Operatic Fantasias, 200
Organ, in Middle Ages, 10 ff.
In Bull and Byrd, 29
Couperin, 57
Bach, 108
P. E. Bach, 140 ff.
End of 18th cent., 150
Oury, Madame, 191
Pachelbel, 92
Pachmann, 301
Paderewski, 301, 324
Paganini, 207, 282
Pape, 133
Paradies, 89
“Parthenia” (also see Addendum, p. 328), 16
Pasquini, 70, 81
Pauer, Ernst, 191
Paul, Oskar, 18
Pedal, 136, 188, (156, picture)
With Dussek, 164
Adam, 186
Hummel, 186
Pedal Clavier, 120
Penna, Lorenzo, 24
Peri, 75, 79
Periodicals, musical, 131
Phillipps, Peter, 37 and note
Pianoforte
Modern factories, 309 ff.
History of the instrument, 121, 122, 136
Viennese and English mechanism, 134, 136, 190
Socially, 134, 303
As furniture, 313 f.
Pianos de luxe, 315
Piano and Opera, 201, 326
Piano and Orchestra, 150, 199
Prices of pianos, 135, 137, 316
Piano instruction, 190, 304
Conservatoriums, 305
Hammerclavier, invention of, 121
“Cottage” Piano, 314 (156, 312, 313, pictures)
Pièce Croisée, 58, 61
Pixis, 187, 191
Plaidy, 189, 306
Planté, 301
Pleyel, 133, 159
Pleyel, Madame, 191
Pollini, 191
Porpora, 89
Pradher, 192
Programme-Music, old, 49, 92, 93, 132
Proksch, 191
Prosniz, 28, 328
Raff, 323
Raif, 306
Rameau, 65, 66, 86, 92
Reading, the Monk of, 15
Rebel, 45
Registers or “stops” of Clavier, 23
Reincke, 92
Reisenauer, 301
Repetition, principle of, 72
Rheinberger, 323
Richardson, Ferdinand, 37
Riemann, 307
Ries, 191
Rimsky-Korsakoff, 320
Risler, 190, 301
Romantic School, 224
In Philip Emm. Bach, 147
In Beethoven, 174
Rondo and Sonata, 145
Rosellen, 201
Rosenhain, 293
Rosenthal, 301
Rossi, Michael Angelo, 82
Rubinstein, Anton, 294 ff.
Rubinstein, Nicolas, 300
Ruckers, 23, 137, 314
Rudolf, Archduke, 191
Rudorff, 306
Rust, F. W., 163
Saint-Saëns, 319
Sand, George, 260
Sauer, 301
Scarlatti, Alessandro, 76, 88
Scarlatti, Domenico, 69 ff.
Sonatas, 86
Technique, 88, 89
Cat’s Fugue, 89
Scharwenka, Xaver and Philip, 306, 324
Schiedmayer, 310
Schmitt, Aloys, 191, 192
Schobert, 160
Scholz, Bernhard, 306
Schröter, 122
Schubert, 225
Miscellaneous, 226
“Wanderer” Fantasia, 226
Op. 78, 227
Impromptus and “Moments,” 228, 229
Schulhoff, 191
Schumann, 231
Schumann and Schubert, 229 ff.
Jean Paul, 232
Bach, 243
E. T. A. Hoffmann, 245
Life, 236
Clara, 236, 237
“Zeitschrift,” 238
Works, 231 ff., 238 ff.
Miscellaneous, 249
Schwarz, Max, 306
Schytte, 322, 326
Senfl, 92
Shakespeare and Music, 5, 6, 7
Silbermann, 122, 134, 137
Siloti, 301
Sinding, 322
Sonata
Old Italian, 86
Scarlatti, 86 and note
Kuhnau, 92
Sonata and Suite, 107
18th century, 110
Sonata and Rondo, 145
Philip Emm. Bach, 143 ff.
Haydn, 150
Mozart, 153
Beethoven, 170 ff.
Spath, 135
Spinet, 6, 24, 90
Spitta, 102, 116
Starck, 306
Stavenhagen, 301
Steibelt, 162
Stein, 137
Steinway, 310
Stenhammer, 322
Sterkel, 210
Strauss, Richard, 323
Streicher, 134
Streicher, Nanette, 160
Sucher, 303
Suite, (see Dance) 106, etc., and see Addendum
Suspensions in Couperin, 57
Sweelinck, virginal pieces, 26, 37
Swietens, Van, 163
Szalit, Paula, 301
Tadema, Alma, 315
Tallis, 27, 32
Taubert, 191
Tausig, 300, 306
Technique, (see under), 187-190, 209
Couperin, 64
Ph. Emm. Bach, 143
Fingering, 116
Keyboard, etc., 24, 26
Tedesco, 191
Thalberg, 197
Thilo, 307
Thoroughbass, 78, 79
Thumb, technique of, 139 ff.
Tielmann, Sufato, 48
Tinctoris, 14
Tischer, 128
Titles of drawing-room pieces, 59, 200
Titles (allegorical, etc.) of old pieces, 42, 51, 59 ff.
Tomaschek, 191
Tschaïkowski, 319
Türk, D. G., 185
Turini, the elder, 86
Turini, the younger, 89
Variations, Old English, 33, etc.
Venetian instrumental music, 13, 26
Viadana, 78
Viennese musical life, 160
Villoing, 190 (line 8; omitted)
Vinci, L., 76
Virdung, 20
Virgil, 307
Virginal, 6, 18, 81
Virginal Books, 15, 16, 27, 28
Virtuoso and Teacher, 64, 192, 305
Life of, 193.
Virtuosos playing together, 198
Virtuosos and Concerts, 299
Vivaldi, 82
Volkmann, 318
Volkslied in Masses and Motets, 8
Vollweiler, 191
Wagner (instruments), 137
Wallace, 299
Wanhal-Vanhall, 190
Weber, Dionysius, 191
Weber, C. M., 206, 218
Weitzmann, 28, 328
Wendling, 309
Westermayer, 310
Widor, 319
Willaert, 79
Wilmers, 191
Wölffl, 161, 183, 190
Wolfsohn, 300
Wüllner, 306
Zimmermann, 317
Zumpe, 133
List of Full-page Engravings
PAGE
Title-page. Portrait of Franz Liszt. Pastel by F. von Lenbach, of the year 1881, in the possession of Madame Cosima Wagner in Bayreuth Frontispiece
Young scholar and his wife. Painting by Gonzales (1614-1684), in the Royal Gallery at Cassel 8
Lady at the clavier. Painting by Dirk Hals, ✝ 1656, in the Rijksmuseum at Amsterdam 14
Le Maître de Musique, painting by Jan Steen, 1626-1679, in the National Gallery, London 44
Concert. Painting by Gerard Terborch, 1617-1681, in the Royal Museum at Berlin 56
J. Ph. Rameau. Engraving by J. G. Sturm (Nürnberg, 1742-1793) 62
A clavier lesson. Painting by an unknown Dutch Master, 17th century, in the Royal Gallery at Dresden 78
Domenico Scarlatti. Lithograph by Anon 86
J. S. Bach. Bust by Carl Seffner. Modelled on the actual skull. After His, J. S. Bach (Vogel, Leipsic) 100
Facsimile of title-page of Bach’s Manuscript of the Wohltemperiertes Klavier, in the Royal Musikbibliothek, Berlin 110
George Frederick Handel, engraved by Thomson 136
Joseph Haydn, engraved by Quenedey 148
W. A. Mozart, engraved in 1793 by C. Kohl (1754-1807) 150
Mozart at the age of seven with his father and sister. Engraved 1764, by J. B. Delafosse (b. 1721) after L. C. de Carmontelle (✝ about 1790) 154
L. van Beethoven. Lithograph by C. Fischer, after the original portrait of 1817, by A. Kloeber (1793-1864) 168
J. N. Hummel. Engraved by Fr. Wrenk (1766-1830), after the portrait by Catherine von Escherich (beginning of 19th century) 210
Franz Schubert. Lithograph of 1846, by J. Kriehuber (1801-1876) 228
Robert Schumann. Engraving by M. Lämmel 236
Chopin. Anonymous Lithograph, after portrait by Ary Scheffer (1795-1858) 256
Thalberg. Lithograph of 1835 by Staub 276
Liszt at Weimar, 1884, from a Photograph 290
Eugene d’Albert, portrait by H. Katsch 298
Johannes Brahms. Photograph from life by Marie Fellinger, Vienna 322
List of other Illustrations and Facsimiles
PAGE
Guido of Arezzo and his protector, Bishop Theodal, playing on a Monochord 1
Orlando Gibbons. After Grignon’s engraving in Hawkins 7
Title-page of the first English engraved Clavier Music, 1611 17
From the Weimar “Wunderbuch,” a Clavichord of about 1440 20
From the Weimar “Wunderbuch,” Primitive Spinet, of about 1440 21
A Concerted Performance 25
Page from “Parthenia,” the first English engraved Clavier Music, 1611 29
John Bull, at the age of 26 33
Henry Purcell, 1658-1695 36
The so-called “Hand” of Guido of Arezzo 38
D’Anglebert, Chamber Musician to Louis XIV., after Mignard 40
François Couperin, “Le Grand” 54
Portrait of Louis Marchand 66
Rameau, out walking 67
Old engraving after Wagniger’s design 68
Adrian Willaert, of Venice 72
Frescobaldi 73
Virginal in shape of a work-box 81
The same opened 81
The instrument taken out 81
Italian cembalo, from a monastery, of the 18th century 83
Old engraving representing Scarlatti playing a Harpsichord with two rows of keys 85
An Octave Spinet 90
German Clavichord, 17th century, “gebunden” 91
Konrad Pau(l)mann, the first German writer for keyed instruments 95
Skull of Sebastian Bach 98
The Fifteenth Sinfonia of John Sebastian Bach, from the Royal Musikbibliothek, Berlin 105
John Mattheson, at the age of 37 115
Pedal-clavichord 120
“Bundfrei” Clavichord 124
Philip Emanuel Bach 126
F. W. Marpurg, Theoretician and Clavier Teacher. 1718-1795 130
Streicher’s Pianoforte and Concert Saloon 135
Mary Coswey with the Orphica 146
Beginning of Mozart’s A minor Sonata 153
Upright Hammer-clavier, called the “Giraffe” 156
Beethoven at the age of 31 157
Dussek (portrait) 165
Cast of Beethoven’s living face, 1812 167
Specimen from Beethoven’s A flat major Sonata, Op. 26 173
Lyser’s Sketch of Beethoven 176
Beethoven’s last Grand Piano, by Graf, Vienna 182
Viennese pianoforte players about 1800. Eberl, Gelinek, Wölffl 183
The Brothers Pixis. 1800 187
Ludwig Berger. Pupil of Clementi 191
John Field, 1782-1837. Steel engraving by C. Mayer 193
Marcelline Czartoryska, née Princess Radziwill 194
Prince Louis Ferdinand 195
Marie Charlotte Antoine Josephe, Countess of Questenberg 197
Clementi (portrait) 208
Hummel in his later years 213
A Canonic Impromptu, by J. N. Hummel 215
Czerny. Lithograph by Kriehuber, 1833 217
Carl Maria von Weber. Lithograph by Eichens, after Vogel, 1825 219
Moscheles in his youth 220
Moscheles, later, 1859 221
Parisian and London Pianists at the beginning of the 19th century. L. Adam, Kalkbrenner, Cramer 223
Waltz by Schubert 224
Clara Schumann, née Wieck 239
Louis Böhner, the original of Hoffmann’s Kreisler 246
The last piece in Schumann’s “Kreisleriana,” main movement 247
Head of Mendelssohn, after Hildebrand 251
George Sand, in man’s dress 259
Chopin’s Hand. From a marble in the National Museum at Budapest 270
An afternoon with Liszt. Kriehuber, Berlioz, Czerny, Liszt, the violinist Ernst 271
Photograph of Liszt, taken in Budapest 271
Title-page of Hofmeister’s Edition of Liszt’s Op. 1. 273
Liszt in his youth 275
After Dantan’s Caricature of Thalberg 276
After Dantan’s Caricature of Liszt 277
Facsimile of Liszt’s Hungarian Storm-March 279
The “jeune école” of Parisian Pianists 280
Liszt in his youth 281
Cartoon representing Liszt and his Works. 1842 283
“General” Bass surprised and overcome in his fortress by Liszt 284
Liszt and Stavenhagen 285
Plaster Cast of Liszt’s Hand 287
Liszt lying in state 288
Music-room in the “Altenburg” at Weimar 289
Döhler. Lithograph by Mittag 291
Sophie Menter in her youth 292
Clotilde Kleeberg, 1888 292
Madame de Belleville 293
Carl Filtsch 293
Rubinstein at twelve 294
Hans von Bülow 295
Last Portrait of Rubinstein 296
Bülow on his deathbed 297
Reinecke in his youth 298
Carl Tausig 299
Paula Szalit 300
Eduard Risler 301
Josef Hofmann 302
Madame Carreño 303
Ferruscio B. Busoni 305
Hand of Eugene d’Albert 307
J. G. Paderewski 311
Upright Hammerclavier 312
Bechstein Cottage piano 313
Bechstein Grand Piano de luxe 315
Joachim Raff 317
Stephen Heller 318
Ferdinand Hiller 318
Adolf Henselt 318
Tschaïkowski 319
Richard Strauss 320
Philip Scharwenka 321
Dr Wilhelm Kienzl 323
Maurice Moskowski 325
TURNBULL AND SPEARS, PRINTERS, EDINBURGH.
Transcriber’s Note:
This book was written in a period when many words and names had not become standardized in their spelling. Words may have multiple spelling variations or inconsistent use of diacriticals and hyphenation in the text. These have been left unchanged. Dialect, obsolete and alternative spellings were left unchanged.
Obvious printing errors, such as letters in the wrong order, backwards, upside down, missing or partially printed, were corrected. Unprinted punctuation and final stops missing at the end of abbreviations and sentences were added.
Footnotes were numbered in order and moved to the end of the chapter in which the related anchors occur. Footnote [4] has two anchors.
Changes:
Phantasie to Fantasie
obligato to obbligato