← Table of contents
The Early Christians in Rome

Part 3 / Book 5 — INDEX

Reading edition

“Aboth,” treatise, 358 n. 1

Acilii Glabriones family, Crypt of, 265, 267, 268–9, 270–1;

was Pudens a member of?, 270

Acilius Glabrio, Consul, martyrdom of, 41–2, 230–1, 269

Acta Sincera, of Ruinart, on Martyrdom of Theban legion, 148 n. 1

Acts of the Apostles, Haggadic influence seen in, 379;

model of, 72;

on Christian assemblies, 107;

on S. Paul’s prison life at Rome, 22;

on status of women, 367 n. 1

Acts of S. Cecilia, in the light of catacomb discoveries, 289 et seq.

Acts of S. Hermes, 274

Acts of Martyrdom, or Acts and Passions of the Martyrs, archæological and literary corroboration of, 81, 82, 94 & n. 1

Critical estimates of, 81 & nn., 82, 258

Few in early days, 33, 35, 48, 53

Pagan contempt shewn in, 158

Value of, in exploring Catacombs, 226

on Numbers of Christians, 104

on Persecutions, 163

Acts of the Martyred Slaves, 136

Acts of the Passion of S. Felicitas, 299;

authenticity of, 300, 304

Acts of Pastor and Timotheus, tradition in, on Pudens and his family, 263–5

Acts of S. Valentinus, 276

Ælia Capitolina, site of, 77;

insults at, to Christians, 78;

results of building, 332, 335–6 et seq.

Ælius Verus, adopted by Hadrian, 83

Æneas, piety of, 87

Æneid, teaching of, 88

Africa (see Carthage, see also Egypt), Christian congregations in, mid-second century, 36

Agaunum (S. Maurice), Martyrdom legend concerning, 148 n. 1

Agrippa, builder of Pantheon portico, 280

Akiba, Rabbi, eminence of, and of his pupils, 337, 354–6

Fate of, 355 & n. 1

Supporter of Bar-cochab, 78, 336–7

on Massorah, 362 n. 1

Alcuin, 278

Aldus Manutius, supporting Pliny’s letter, 46

Alemanni, death of, 283

Alexander, son of S. Felicitas, tomb of, 259

Alexandria, Jewish revolts in, 330, 334–5, 346;

literary support from, of Petrine tradition, 10, 13;

plague of, 155 n. 2

Alexandrian-Jewish influences in Revelation of S. John, 72

Allard, —, on Acilius Glabrio, 269;

on Archæology as rehabilitating legend, 289;

on Jewish fecundity, first century, in Rome, 5 n. 1;

on the Jews in the Augustan age, 4;

on Nero’s persecution and popular disgust, 42 n. 2;

on the Martyrdom of the Theban legion, 148 n. 1;

on Pliny’s letter, 46;

on S. Peter’s arrival in Rome, 19 n. 1;

on Trajan’s personality, 48

Translation by, of the Epitaph of Pope Damasus, 215 n. 1

Almsgiving, in the early Church, 113, 119–22, 123, 130 et seq., 138, 139

America, Civil War of, cause of, 135 n. 1

Amoraim, the, 345, 358 n. 1, 359

Amphitheatre games, horrors of, 50;

Martyrdoms in, 110, 172, 175–6;

training of Christians for, 198

Ampliatus, Chapel or Crypt of, Domitilla Cemetery, 240

Tomb of, identification of, 241–2

Anacletus, Pope, cemetery of, 287;

discoveries in, seventeenth century, 280 et seq.

Memoriæ erected by, over tombs of SS. Peter and Paul, 233, 237, 281 et seq.

Ananias and Sapphira, gift of, voluntary, 120 n. 1

Anchor, as Christian Emblem, 310

Angels, Haggadic references to, 378, 379

Animals, wild, in amphitheatre games, exposure to, of Christians, &c., 175–6, 178, 183, 185, 187, 191, 203, 204, 269

Anniversaries of Martyrs, first celebrated, 35

Antioch (see also Ignatius), literary support from, of Petrine tradition, 9, 13

Antipas, martyr, 169

Antonines, the (see also Antoninus Pius and Marcus Aurelius), reigns of, 63;

characteristics of, 84 et seq.;

table of succession of, 83

Antonins, Les, by De Champagny, on Hadrian’s character, 77 n. 1;

on the number of Jews slain in the last wars, 338 & n. 2

Antoninus Pius, 186, 277;

adopted by, and successor to, Hadrian, 83;

family and character of, 83, 84, 85

Attitude of, to Christians, 158;

ignorance of their faith, 77

Coinage of, 87, 90

Persecutions by, and reasons for, 33, 80, 81, 84, 91–3, 95, 137, 163 n. 2, 194, 207

Relations of, with Hadrian, 83, 85

Apocalypse of S. John, 72;

place of, in early Christian thought, 156–7;

references in, to Persecution, 37, 157, 165, 167–70

Apologies, The, of Justin Martyr, 128, 184

on Assemblies, 108, 113–4

on Persecution, 185–6

Apology of Aristides, on Burial of the dead by Christians, 132, 133;

on Christian charity, 124 & n. 1, 126, 130, 138;

on Christians as civil judges, 148;

on Hospitality, 128;

on Slavery, 135

Apology, or Embassy, of Athenagoras, on Persecution, 188–9

Apology of Tertullian, and the Octavius of Minucius Felix, 186

Apostasy, encouraged by Roman rulers, 195, 197;

Hermas on, 181;

results of, 197, 203;

some causes, 201

Apostolical Constitutions, The, on Almsgiving, 122;

on Hospitality, 128

Apostolic Fathers, writings of, cast in Letter form, 73

Apostolic Fathers, by Lightfoot, cited on Pliny’s Letters, 46 n. 1;

on S. Hippolytus, 251

Apostolic remains, authors and form of, 73;

characteristics and special value of, ib., meant for publication, 74 & n. 1

Apronienus, catacomb of, 248

Aquila and Priscilla, associations of, with S. Paul, and with Pudens, 265–6;

burial-place of, 262, 266;

church founded by, 262

Arch of Titus, witness of, 333 & n. 1

Archæological Relics of S. Peter, Chair, and place of baptism, 12

Archæology, witness of, to literature and tradition (see also Catacombs), 17, 19 n. 1, 81, 82, 108, 147, 152 n. 1, 209 et seq., 289, 295, 298, 304

to Pagan and Christian views on Death, 154–5

to Social Status of many early Christians, 111–2

Arenaria, in Jordani catacomb, 260

Aristides, see Apology of, supra

Aristotle, works of, 146

Arles, Church of S. Hippolytus at, 255

Armellini, Prof., on Inscription concerning S. Agnes, 256–7;

Ubaldi’s memoranda published by, 281;

work of, in Catacomb exploration, 239

Army, Christians in, 148 & n. 1

Arnold, Matthew, on the Good Shepherd with the Kid, 320

Arsacius, Letter to, from Emperor Julian, on Christian characteristics, 123 n. 1, 128, 131

Arval Brotherhood, College of, 236;

M. Aurelius a member, 95 n. 1

Asia, Christian congregations in, mid-second century, 36

Asia Minor (see also Antioch, &c.), 71

Christianity in (see also Pliny’s Letter), founder, and effects on Paganism, and spread of, 51, 107

S. John’s prominence in, 9

Assemblies, Christian, composition of, 110–12, 113, 114, 240, 242

Importance of, 101;

evidenced in literary references, 107–9

Joy in, 155

Places where held (see also Catacombs), 139

Proceedings at, various writers cited, 113 et seq.

References to, in N.T. and later writers, Christian and Pagan, 107 et seq.

Sunday, 108;

observance of, Justin Martyr on, 113–4

Teaching, doctrines and ritual at, 101, 113 et seq., 124, 126, 128–30, 131–3, 138, 139

Astolphus, 293

Athenagoras, 319 n. 1;

on Persecutions, 188–9

Attire, Rigourist teaching on, 153–4

Aubé, on the Acts of S. Felicitas, 300;

on Domitian’s persecution, 42 n. 2;

on Trajan’s Rescript, 49

Augustus Cæsar, 91, 280;

attitude of, to Imperial cultus, 42;

favour shown by, to the Jews, 3;

and the source of Rome’s greatness, 88, 89

Ausonius, poems of, 64

Autolycus, letters or books to, from Theophilus of Antioch, 108–9, 189

Auvergne, 66

Aventine Hill, church on, 262;

house, &c., of Pudens on, 12, 15

Avitus, made Emperor, 65

Baba-Bathra treatise, in the Talmud, 343 n. 1

Babylon, mystic name for Rome, 8, 10, 14

Babylonia (see also Exile), Jews in, 346

Rabbinic Schools of, 326, 362–3, 368, 373

Chief, 358 n. 1

Mode of teaching in, 357, 358–60

Work of, 344, 345, 346, 372

Babylonian Gemara, the, 356 & n. 4

Talmud, the, 345,

Haggadic notices in, 358 n. 1

Baiæ, death at, of Hadrian, 83

Balaam and his ass, Haggadah on, 377, 378

Balbina, tomb of, 247

Baptisteries (see also Wells) in Catacombs of Pontianus, and S. Priscilla, 236

Baptistery of S. Peter, site of, identified by Marucchi, 12, 257, 267, 271–3

Barberini (Pope Urban VIII), epigram on, 280

Bar-cochab, false Messiah, cause of last war of the Jews, 336–7;

his Rabbinical supporters, 78, 336–7, 354, 355

Barnabas, Epistle of, see Epistles

Barnes, —, cited on Neronic burning of Christians, 285–6

on S. Peter’s tomb, 281 & n. et seq.

Baronius, Cardinal, 263;

present at finding of S. Cecilia’s body, 294 & n. 1, 297;

on S. Petronilla, 277

Basil of Cappadocian Cæsarea, 138

Basilicas:—

of S. Lawrence “ad Corpus,” Popes buried in, 250

Domitilla, 278

Prætextatus, 247

SS. Hermes and Basilissa, 274–5

in Cœmeterium Majus, subterranean, 258

in Rome, third century number and appointments of, 112

Ruined, crypts beneath, 228

of S. Agnes, 256–7

of S. Cecilia, 292, 293 et seq.

of S. Felicitas, 302

of S. Hippolytus, 251, 254

of S. Laurence, 250, 254

of S. Sylvester, burials in, 266 & n. 1, 272

When and why erected, 272

Benson, Archbishop, on S. Cyprian, 122 & n. 1, 127 n. 1

Bernini, Baldacchino by, in S. Peter’s, discoveries on erection of, 233 n. 1, 280 et seq.

Bethel, the old prophet of, 321

Bethia, Zealot headquarters, 336

“Billicum confessionis,” nature of, that of S. Peter, 237, 282

Bishops and Popes of Rome (see under Names), claim to be successors of S. Peter, undisputed, 16

Catalogues of, on date of Linus’s accession, 14;

to Eleutherius, 15

Early, buried around S. Peter, see Papal Crypt

Bithynia and Pontus, 57, 58, 62

Christians in (see also Pliny’s letter), 27, 32, 35 n. 1, 45 et seq., 50, 71, 75, 77, 103 & n. 2, 110, 177

Bliss, instant, after Death, Christian hope of, 156

“Book of Jubilees,” subject-matter of, 377, 378

Borghesi, Cardinal, 300;

re-interment by, of S. Sebastian, 244

Bosio, —, pioneer of Catacomb exploration, 223–4;

present at discovery of S. Cecilia’s body, 294 & n. 1, 297

Bourges, mention at, of S. Petronilla as S. Peter’s daughter, 278

Brescia, relics of S. Hippolytus at, 255

Brotherhood character of early Christianity, 38, 122–3, 270

Builders, of Basilicas, &c., injury done by, to Catacombs, 250, 257

Burial customs, Jewish, Christian, and Pagan, 4, 5, 131–3, 264

Bury St. Edmunds, cult of S. Petronilla in, 278

Cæcilian family, the, Christians and martyrs of, burial-place of, 245, 291, 296–7 & n. 1

Cæcilius, pagan interlocutor in Octavius of Minucius Felix, 146, 186;

arguments of, source of, 145;

contempt of, for Christians, 158;

on Christian love, 119, 129

C. Aurelius, Censor, 233

Caius, Bishop or Pope of Rome, burial-place of, identified, 231;

martyred relations of, 259 n. 1

Caius, Presbyter, 282;

on the Memoriæ of the Apostles in Rome, 11

Caligula, Emperor, and the Imperial cultus, 42 n. 1

Callistus, Bishop or Pope of Rome, and martyr, once a slave, 136 n. 1

Cemetery or Catacomb of, 234, 236–7, 239, 240, 242, 244–6, 251, 261

Inscription of Damasus once in, on numbers of martyrs, 215 & n. 1

Papal burial-place (q.v.), 231, 245–6, 273

Callistus group of Catacombs, 212

Carthage, Church of (see also S. Cyprian), aid from, to other Churches, 131

Literary support from, of Petrine tradition, 10–11, 13

Plague at, charity of S. Cyprian and his flock during, 123 n. 1, 127

“Catacombas, ad,” see S. Sebastian

Catacombs or Cemeteries, see also under Names of Saints, &c., and under Via, and see Inscriptions, Itineraries, and Translation

Decorations of, deductions from, 133, 147, 219, 220, 221

Exploration of—

beginning, 223 & n. 1

progress, 224 et seq.

results, 219, 220–1, 224, 225, 230 et seq.

Workers, see Bosio, De Rossi, Marchi, Marucchi

Extent and content of, 133 et seq., 220, 233 et seq.

Jewish burials in, 4

Literature bearing on, 209–14, 226–8

Number of, De Rossi on, 232

Origin of, in general, 38

Rediscovery of, 223 & n. 1, 244

Restorations of, by Pope Damasus, 152 n. 1

Teaching in, passim;

on Death, 309–11

Three oldest, 266

Tombs in, passim

Uses of, 133, 139, 220 et alibi;

for worship, 118, 253, 258

Witness of, to Acts of Martyrs, 81, 82

to Christ, 308, 310, 311, 316–20 & nn.

to Early Christian history and tradition, 105, 111–2, 133, 163 n. 1, 209 et seq., 219–21

Catalogues of Roman Bishops on date of Linus’s accession, 14

Celestinus, Pope, burial-place of, 272

Cemeteries (see also Catacombs), Christian names for, 155

Cerinthian heresy, 23 n. 1

Chair of S. Peter, long shown, 12

Charity among Jews in Rome, 4

Charlemagne, 278

Christ, Sayings of, 366

Teaching of, contrasted with Talmudic, 366–8

With a Kid, Tertullian on, 319;

M. Arnold’s verses on, 320

Witness to, of the Catacombs, 308, 310, 311, 316–20 & nn.

Christian Institutions, by Dean Stanley, on the Good Shepherd, 318 & n. 1, 319 n. 1

Christian, name treated as crime, 39, 189, 191

Relatives of Emperors, 110, 112, 148, 240, 241

Religion, powerful factor in spread of, 102–3

Testimony to spread of Christianity, in the New Testament and after, 107–9

Unity, its double bond of Doctrine and Love, 118–9

Writers, early, on Numbers of Christians, 101, 208;

words cited, 103–6

on Persecutions, &c., 36, 37, 81, 82, 163–5, 166–7, 177–91, 208;

words cited, 103–6

Christianity, see also Martyrs, Persecutions, &c.

Early, connection of, with Judaism, 325

Growth of, 37 et seq., 107, 150 & n. 1, 151

Importance to, of history of the Jews after the last Wars, 326 et seq.

of the Talmud, 326, 327, 348, 370 & n. 1

Influence on, of Rabbinical studies, 326–7

Menace of, to Judaism after the Dispersion, 355

Roman view of, after Jewish War of Extermination, 78, 79, 80

Christians, see Pliny’s Letter, see also Idol-worship, Incense, and Persecutions

Accused of burning Rome, 27;

and burned by Nero, 28–9

Classes composing, 101, 110–12, 148, 240, 241, 291, 296–7 & n. 1, 299, 307–8

Discriminated from Jews, 27, 30, 92, 164, 341

Expelled from Rome by Claudius, 25

Fanatics among, 97

Guerdon of the faith of, 154 et seq.

Jewish opposition to, in Rome, 18

Life of, in early days, 33–7, 101 et seq., 78–81, 140 et seq.

Numbers of, and of Martyrs (q.v.), 28, 46 n. 1, 53, 215;

witnesses to, 82 & n. 1, 101, 103–6

Schools of teaching among, two, 101

Christology of the Catacombs, 220;

of S. Paul, 23–4

Chronicles, Book of, Haggadic expansion of, 378

Church calendars, Martyrs first mentioned in, 208

Church, The, in the Empire, cited, see under Ramsay

Church of the Propaganda, S. Hyacinthus’s remains in, 275

Church of Rome (see also Rome, Christians in, &c.), early importance of, 16, 17

Cicero, the first great letter-writer, epistolary style of, 67, 71;

fashion set by, 56–7, 58, 64;

period of, 56;

popularity of, 69

on the Jews in Rome, 3;

on Slaves, 134

Circumcision forbidden to Jews in Rome, 335

Civil service, Christians in, 144, 145, 148–9

Civil War, U.S.A., causes of, 135 n. 1

Claudian, poems of, 64

Claudius, Emperor, 235;

expulsion by, of Jews, from Rome, 8, 18, 25;

S. Peter at Rome during reign of, 11, 12, 14

Claudius Gothicus, Emperor, martyrs in reign of, 262, 276

Clement of Alexandria, 179;

teaching of, 138;

writings by, see Pædagogus;

cited in support of Petrine tradition, 10, 13;

on Christians living in the world, 146;

on Christians of wealth, 111 & n. 1

Clement VIII, Pope, and the finding of S. Cecilia’s body, 294, 297;

and S. Peter’s tomb, 282

Clermont, Sidonius Apollinaris, bishop of, 66

Clitumnus fountain, Pliny’s description of, 60

“Clivium Cucumeris, ad,” Catacomb so called, 275

Codex Sinaiticus, The Shepherd of Hermas included in, 179–80

Cœlian Hill, church on, Saints buried in, 249

“Cœmeterium Majus,” chief interest of, and other names of, 255, 257–8;

subterranean church in, 258

Cœmeterium Ostrianum, 255, 257, 271

“Cognitiones,” the, 43, 50

Cologne, relics of S. Laurence at, 255

Colosseum, the, martyrdoms in, 172

Column of the Passion, at S. Zeno’s chapel, 263

Commentaries on the Gospels, &c., by Theophilus of Antioch, 189

Commodilla, catacomb of, 236, 238

Commodus, Emperor, 333 n. 2;

Apology of Athenagoras addressed to, 188

Attitude of, to Christians, 97, 147, 164, 208

Communion of Saints, early Christian view on, 307 et seq.

Communism and the early Church, 120 & n. 1, 130

Constantine the Great (see also Peace of the Church), 197, 369

Basilicas built by, to

S. Agnes, 256–7

S. Paul, 237, 238

S. Peter, 233, 237–8, 273, 279–80, 282–3

Edict of Milan issued by, 150

Memoria built by, to S. Laurence, 250

Corinth, Epistles to, of S. Clement, S. Ignatius, S. Paul, and Pope Soter, see under Epistles

Literary support from, of Petrine tradition, 10, 13

SS. Peter and Paul at, 10

Cornelius, Bishop or Pope, of Rome, and martyr, tomb of, 243;

discovery of, 246

on Almsgiving by the Roman Church, 105, 120;

on the number of the Christians at Rome, 105, 106

Council, the, of Jerusalem, 8

“Couples,” the, and the oral Law, 339, 340

Crassus, Consul, 56

Creation legends in “Book of Jubilees,” 377–8

Cremation, not practised by Jews, 4

Crescentius, martyr, tomb of, 266

Cross on S. Peter’s sarcophagus, 282–3

Cruelty, Pagan and Christian, Rutilius on, 159

Crusaders, Itineraries for, 210, 227

Crypts, famous, see Acilii Glabriones Lucina, Papal, Platonia, Prætextatus, SS. Cecilia, Januarius, Priscilla, Silanus, &c.

Age of, how determined, 267

Identification of, by De Rossi, 225, 230 & n. 1, 242

Local indications of presence of, 228–9

Cureton, Canon, and the Ignatian Epistles, 173 n. 1

Cyprus, Zealot revolt in, 334–5

Cyrene, Jews of, 346;

revolt of, 334–5

Cyrinus, martyr, tomb of, 243

Damasus, Pope, 263, 272, 301

Epistle of, honouring S. Felicitas, 259

Inscriptions of, aid of, to Catacomb explorers, 229–30;

one cited on many martyrs buried together, 215 & n. 1

and the Martyrs at tomb of SS. Chrysanthus and Daria, 261

Work of, in the Catacombs, decoration, inscriptions, and epitaphs, 152 n. 1, 215 & n. 1, 229–30, 249, 252, 275, 291–2, 296 n. 1, 297, 302, 305

Daniel, the prophet, and Idol-worship, 149

Book of, cited on Almsgiving, 121

David, King, 352

Dead, burying of, by Early Christians, 120, 131–3, 264

Death, Christian attitude to, 154–5, 309, 311

Pagan attitude to, 59 n. 1, 83, 313–4

De Boissier, —, on Pliny’s letter, 46;

on the School for Martyrdom, 198 n. 1

De Broglie, —, on Toleration shown by early Christian teachers, 142–3

De Champagny, —, on Hadrian’s character, 77 n. 1;

on number of Jews destroyed in the last wars, 338 & n. 2

Decius Aurelius, Emperor, persecutions under, 40, 97, 163 n. 2, 250, 254;

martyrs in, 236;

reason for, 194

Decoration of Catacombs, evidence from, and teaching of, 225, 267, 268, 269, 292, 301–2, 308 et seq.;

portraits among, 296;

value of, to explorers, 229

Deissmann, Prof., on the Epistles, as written for publication, 71

Deities associated with Rome, 87, 89

De Rossi, G., Archæological work of, 209, 239, 246, 260, 261, 267

Excavations and discoveries by, 12, 42, 224, 246, 247, 254, 266 n. 1, 274

Results, 225, 230 et seq.

Value to, of Itineraries, 226 et seq., 242, 243, 246, 247

on Acilius Glabrio, 269;

on the Acts of S. Felicitas, 300;

on Cœmeterium Majus as S. Peter’s Baptistery, 257;

on Common tombs of martyrs, 215 n. 1;

on Crypt of Lucina, 245;

on Epitaphs in the Catacombs, 310;

on the “Ostrian” Cemetery, 255, 257;

on the place of martyrdom of S. Chrysanthus, 260;

on Pudens, 265, 270;

on S. Cecilia’s burial-place, 289, 291, 292, 293 n. 1, 295–7, 298;

on scenes of S. Peter’s work, 12, 257, 267, 271;

on S. Petronilla, 277;

on S. Priscilla’s Catacomb, 261–2;

on the Tomb of Ampliatus, 241–2;

on the Tombs of Sons of S. Felicitas, 301–2

Despots, the malady of, 26, 82

Deuteronomy, Rabbinic claim for last verses of, 343, 364

“Devising new things,” a crime under Domitian, 269

Dialogue with the Jew Trypho, by Justin Martyr, 184;

on Persecution, 185–6

Diana, worship of, 195

Didaché, the, teachings of, 138;

on Almsgiving, 121, 123;

on Assemblies, 108;

on Hospitality, 128;

on Slaves and Masters, 135

Dill, Prof., cited on Roman wish for posthumous remembrance, 59 n. 1

Diocletian, Emperor, 75

Baths of, 302

Christian relations of, 148

Christians at Court of, 147

Persecutions under, 97, 163 n. 2, 236, 244, 246, 249, 266

Martyrs in, 234, 239, 259 n. 1, 260, 276;

official records of Roman martyrdoms destroyed in his reign, 225

Protracted, light on, from Catacombs, 231

Reasons for, 42 & n. 1, 194

Severity of, reaction after, 151

Diognetus, Letter to, by unknown writer, on Persecution, 177–8;

suggested date, 178 & n. 1

Dion Cassius, 75, 269;

on Domitian’s executions, 41;

on the last wars of the Jews, 338 n. 1;

on Nerva’s treatment of Christians, 171

Dionysius, Bishop of Alexandria, on Christians at Court, 147;

on Roman generosity to other Churches, 131

Dionysius of Corinth, cited on Alms to other Churches from Rome, 130–1;

in support of Petrine tradition, 10, 13

Dionysius, Pope, martyr, tomb of, 243

Docetic teaching, heresy of, 23 n. 1

“Domine quo vadis,” Church, and legend of, 239

Domitian, Emperor, Arch of Titus finished by, 333 n. 1

Christian relatives of, 110, 112;

burial-place of, 240, 241

Emperor-worship enforced by, 170

Fate of, 42 & n. 2, 43, 48, 171

Persecutions under, 32, 171, 172, 173, 174, 207, 255, 269;

reasons for, and severity of, 40–2, 194

Triumph of, 333

Domitilla, catacomb of, 261

Age, grandeur, and size of, 240, 266

Basilica in, 278

Builder of, 112

Discovery of, 230;

and discoveries in, 239, 240–2

Flavian tombs in, 277

S. Petronilla buried in, 279

Domitilla, two Princesses so named, martyred by Domitian, 41, 230

Doulcet,—, ref. to, 300

Dove, in Christian symbolism, 310

Drei, Benedetto, plan by, of Vatican Cemetery (ancient), 287–8

Dryden, John, poem by on S. Cecilia, 294 n. 1

Duchesne,—, on Christianity as equivalent to Martyrdom, 37;

on The Shepherd of Hermas, 179 & n. 1, 181;

on S. Cecilia’s burial-places, 293 n. 1;

term used by, for Church of Rome, 16 & n. 1

Eadburg, Queen, 279

Early Christian writers and teaching on Slavery, 135, 136–7

Ebert and others on relative dates of Tertullian and Minucius Felix, 186

Edict against Christians issued by Nero, 32, 54;

of Milan, 150

Education, difficulties concerning, of Early Christians, 141–2

Église, L’, Chrétienne, ref. by Renan, on Hermas’s Shepherd, 180

Église, L’, et l’Empire Romain, by De Broglie, on early Christian toleration, 142–3

Egypt, see Alexandria

Einsiedeln, Itinerary of, cited, 212;

date, 227

“Syllogæ” at, 230

Elders and Judges, and the Law, 339, 349

Elements of the Faith, by Theophilus of Antioch, 189

Eleutherius, Bishop or Pope of Rome, burial-place of, 287;

list of predecessors of, 15

Elisha, prophet, on Ceremonial idolatry, 149

Emblems used in the Catacombs, 310 et alibi

Emperor-worship, 42 & n. 1, 169, 170, 181, 194, 195

England, crusade of, against Slavery, Lecky on, 135 n. 1

Ephesians, Epistles to, see Epistles

Ephesus, the “highway of martyrs,” 173

Epistles or Letters, anonymous, see Diognetus, Hebrews, Polycarp

Apostolic, 73–4;

on Persecution, 165, 166–7

of New Testament writers, 70–2

Catholic, 71, 72

Pastoral, 72

Patristic, on Persecution, 165, 170–6

by Various writers, Christian and Pagan;

see also S. Cyprian

Barnabas, 74

on Assemblies, 108;

on Christ’s atonement, 116–7

tradition on, 73

Cicero, 56–7, 58, 64, 67, 69, 71

Dionysius of Corinth to the Roman Church, 130–1

Fronto, to M. Aurelius, 63–4 & n. 1, 85, 86–7

Horace, 69 n. 1

Julian, Emperor, to Arsacius, 123 n. 1, 128, 131

Ovid, 69 n. 1

Pliny the younger (q.v.), 57, 59–62

Polycarp, 73, 125

S. Clement of Rome,

to the Corinthians, 73

First, 37, 104 & n. 2, 126, 128, 165, 170–2;

teaching of, 138;

cited in support of Petrine tradition, 9

Second, so called, 104 n. 2, 121 & n. 1

S. Ignatius of Antioch, 73

Authenticity of, 165, 172–3 & n. 1

to Corinth, 108, 172–6

to Ephesus, 173

to Magnesians, 174

to Polycarp, 108

to Rome, 9, 37, 154, 173, 174–5, 199, 204–5

to Tralles, 173

S. James, meant for publication, 71;

on Assemblies, 107;

on wealthy Christians, 110;

on “pure religion,” 126

S. John,

First, meant for publication, 71, 72

Third, on Hospitality, 129

S. Jude, meant for publication, 71, 72

S. Paul, two classes of, 70–2

to Colossians, 23–4, 70

to Corinthians, 21

First, 134–5;

Haggadic influence in, 379

Second, 71

to Ephesians, nature of, 23, 70

to Galatians, 21, 135, 379

to Philemon, 71, 134

to Philippians, 23, 70, 154

to Romans, 17, 19 & n. 1, 21, 24, 107, 129;

Linus mentioned in, 283

to Thessalonians, 21

to Timothy, First and Second, 72, 379

to Titus, 72, 135

on the Church at Jerusalem, and its poverty, 120 n. 1, 130

S. Paulinus of Nola to Sulpicius Severus, on his slave, 136–7

S. Peter, First, 71, 129;

date and place of writing, 8 & n. 1, 16, 18, 19, 51, 107, 135, 165, 166 n. 1, 167;

to whom addressed, 107

Seneca, 57, 69, 71;

to Lucilius, 29

Sidonius Apollinaris, 64, 66–7

Soter, to Corinth, 104

Theophilus of Antioch, to Autolycus, 108–9, 189

Epitaphs (see also Inscriptions) in the Catacombs, Characteristics of, Christian, 154–5, 307–9;

Pagan, 154–5, 313–4

Equality without democracy among Early Christians, 38

Eschatologic trend of the Haggadah, 378

Esquiline Hill, church on, 262

Essenes, the, 330

Europe, Christian congregations in mid-second century, 36

Eusebian catalogue of Roman Bishops, value of, in support of Petrine tradition, 14, 15,

Armenian version of above, ib. ib.

Eusebius, Bishop or Pope of Rome, 128, 147, 187–8;

attempted exculpation by, of Trajan, 49;

burial-place of, 243;

identified, 243

cited in support of Petrine tradition, 10, 11–12, 14;

on Almsgiving, 120, 127;

on high offices filled by Christians, 149;

on the Plague, and on Christian charity, 127;

on Pliny’s correspondence with Trajan, 45;

on Theophilus of Antioch, 189

Evander, home of, 87

Évangiles, Les, by Renan, cited on Pliny’s letter, 46 n. 1;

on Trajan as persecutor, 49

Evaristus, Bishop or Pope of Rome, burial-place of, 287

Exhortatio ad Martyrum, by Origen, 199

Exile of the Jews, in Babylonia,

Effect of, on their character, 348, 361, 371

Return from,

Rise of the Scribes on, 343, 356

Talmud, origin of, coeval with, 348

Ezra, 342, 343

Fabius, Bishop of Antioch, 105

Faith, in Early Christian Church, 39

Fame, posthumous, Roman yearning for, 59 & n. 1, 65

Family life, early Christian difficulties in, 140–1

Fasting, early Church, 124 & n. 1;

Rigourist teaching on, 153

Filocalus, Furius Dionysius, inscriptions cut by, 230;

fame of, 301

Fire of Rome, the great, 25;

attributed to Nero, 26–7, 28, 31, 285;

consequence of, to Christians and to Jews, 27–30

Martyrdom by, 28–30, 256;

unusual, 275

Fish, mystic, explained, 310, 316–7 & n. 1

Flaccus, 3

Flavian Emperors, the (see also Domitian, Titus, and Vespasian), persecutions under, and reasons for, 39–42, 163 n. 1, 172, 173, 174;

tombs of, 277

Flavianus, Pope, martyr, tomb of, 243

Flavius Clemens, Consul, martyred by Domitian, 41

Florus, Procurator of Judea, 330

Forgiveness of Sin, consciousness of, joy from, 155–6

Formula for reply, of possible Martyrs, 199

Fortitude under Torture, Justin Martyr on, 185;

moral effect of, Lecky on, 193–4;

Roman view, 193, 205

Forum, the, 86, 89

Freedmen, in Rome, 137

Freeman, Prof., on S. Petronilla’s altar, at Gloucester, 279

Friedländer,—, views of, on Trajan’s Rescript, 49

Fronto, 95, 145;

contempt of, for Christians, 158;

correspondence with Marcus Aurelius and his colleague, 63–4;

letters of, on Antoninus Pius, 85, 86–7

Galatians, Epistle to, see Epistles

Galba, Emperor, 39, 331

Gallerius, Emperor, and the cemeteries, 237

Gallus, Cestius, siege by, of Jerusalem, 330

Gamaliel, the elder, 366

Gaul (see also Lyons, Vienne, &c.), Visigoth invasion of, 66

Gemara, the, 344–5 & n. 1, 346, 362, 370;

basis of, 358 n. 1, 360, 361;

exclusive spirit in, 366–8;

extravagances of, 347;

Rabbis of, 358 n. 1, 359;

study of, 362–3;

two versions of, 356 & n. 4

Generosa, catacomb of, 235, 236

Genesis, Book of, Haggadic commentary on, 377–8

Gentle School of Christian teaching, 101, 157

Gieseler,—, views of, on Trajan’s Rescript, 49

Ginsberg, Dr., work of, on Massoretic notes, 363–4

Gloucester Abbey, altar and chapel of S. Petronella at, 279

Gnosticism, rise of, concurrent with Rabbinism, 326

Teachers of, classes addressed by, 112 n. 1

Golden Age, The, of the Church (by author), cited, on Saints’ power over Animals, 176 n. 1

Good Shepherd, the, paintings of, in Catacombs, 248, 301, 308, 310, 317–20 & nn.

Gospel, the, at Rome, problem of its beginnings, tradition as to founder, 7;

literary quotations sustaining, 8, 9 et seq.

Gospels (see also under Names), Canonical, in circulation temp. Antonines, 96;

form of, 72;

power of, 103;

woman’s position in, 367 & n. 1

Government service, Christians in, difficulties of, 141, 144, 145, 147, 148–9

Graffiti in the Catacombs, 248, 251, 259

Great Synagogue, the Men of, 339, 340

Greece (see also Corinth), S. Paul’s missionary success in, 107

Gregory the Great, additions by, to Basilica of S. Paul, 238;

and the Monza labels, 214, 228, 303–4;

homily by, on S. Felicitas, 305;

prayer of, for Trajan, 49;

on the Acts of S. Felicitas, 300;

on reverence for tombs of great Saints, 283

Gregory IV, Pope, 275

Hadrian, Emperor, 104, 164, 182, 274;

accession and reign of, authorities on, 75;

buildings by, at Jerusalem, 77–8, 332, 335–6 et seq.;

character of, 75, 85;

cities founded by, 76 n. 1;

death, last days, and insanity of, 82–3, 84, 335

Persecutions by, and attitude towards Christianity, 77, 81–3, 163 n. 2, 247;

reason for, 194

Rescript of, 80;

effect of, 180

Villa of, 82

Wars of, 325

Zealot revolt under, 334

Haggadah, the, 343 & n. 2, 344;

detailed explanation of, 371 et seq., 377–9;

Divine inspiration claimed for, 365;

edited by R. Akiba, 356;

in the Exile, and after, 349–50, 351 & n. 1, 371 et seq.;

Talmud popularity largely due to, 371;

sources of, 372–3

Haggadic notices, nature of, 373;

where met with, 358 n. 1, 372, 373

Haggai, the prophet, and the oral Law, 339

Hagiographa, Divine inspiration ascribed to, 365

Halachah, the, 343 & n. 2, 344, 349, 350;

developments of, 376–7;

discussions on, 360;

editions of, by R. Akiba, 354–6,

by “Rabbi,” 358 n. 1;

reduced to writing by “Rabbi,” 372 & n. 1

Harnack, A., on authorship of 2nd Epistle of Clement of Rome, 104 n. 2;

on The Shepherd of Hermas, its date, 179 & n. 1;

and various classes in the Church, 124–5;

on the Martyrdom of Theban legion, 148 n. 1;

on numbers of early Christians, inference from size of Catacombs, 105–6 & n. 1;

on the Pædagogus of Clement of Alexandria, 111 n. 1

Hebrews, Epistle to the, 71, 72;

Haggadic influence seen in, 379;

on Christian Assemblies, 107;

on Charity, 130;

on Hospitality, 128–9;

on Persecution, 165, 166

Hegesippus, list by, of Roman Bishops, 15

Heracleon, Gnostic teacher, 112 n. 1

Heresies and Heretics, first century, at Rome, 22, 23 & n. 1

Heretical teachers, second century, successful contentions of Christians with, 37

Hermas, author of The Shepherd (Pastor) (q.v.), 136 n. 1, 178;

teaching of, 138, 179, 182–3

Herod Antipas, and S. Peter, 19 n. 1

Herod family, 3, 329

Herod the Great, 340

Herodians, 329

Hilary of Poitiers, on persecuting Roman Emperors, 40 & n. 3

Hillel, 356;

attempt of, to edit Mishnah material, 351;

codification work of, 356 n. 1;

and Shammai, 339,

debt to, of Rabbinism, 340

Histoire Ancienne de l’Église, by Duchesne, cited, 16 & n. 1, 179 & n. 1, 181, 293 n. 1

Histoire des Persécutions, by Allard (q.v.), cited, 19 n. 1, 42 n. 1, 48

Histoire des Persécutions, by Aubé, cited, on Domitian, 42 n. 2

Historia Monasterii S. Petri Gloucestriæ, on Royal burials near S. Petronilla’s altar, 279

Histories of Tacitus (q.v.), the Lost, passage from (alleged) on destruction of the Temple, 331 & n. 1, 332

History of European Morals, by Lecky, on Christian charity, 137–8;

on Christian fortitude and its effects, 193–4;

on Christianity, causes of its spread, 150 & n. 2;

on Slavery, 134, 135 & n. 1, 136 n. 1

Honorius, Emperor, 56, 252–3;

and the Basilica of S. Paul, 238

Honorius I, Pope, 276;

and the Basilica of S. Pancras, 235

Honorius III, Pope, additions by, to S. Paul’s Basilica, 238;

and the Basilicas to S. Laurence, 250

Honorius IV, Pope, the Talmud condemned by, 366

Hope, Christian, for the joy of the Future Life, 156–8, 311;

evidence of Catacombs on, 268

Horace, poetic epistles of, 69 n. 1

Horatius and the bridge, 87

Hospitality, in the early Church, 128–9;

in provision of graves, 38

Hyginus, Pope, burial-place of, 287

Ichthus, meaning of, 310, 316–7 & n. 1

Idol-worship (see also Incense), Ceremonial, attitude to, of Rigourist and opposite schools, 144–5, 147, 148;

Old Testament attitude to, 149;

Tertullian on, 203

Ignatius and Polycarp, by Lightfoot, cited, 40 n. 3

Immortality, Christian ideas on, 156–8

Imperial cultus, see Emperor-worship

Families, Christian members of, 110, 112, 148, 240, 241

Household, Christians in, 147

Incense, offering of (see also Idol-worship), test for Christians, 52, 53, 181, 194–6

Insanity of despots, see Hadrian and Nero

Inscriptions in the Catacombs (see also Damasus), 237, 251, 267, 268, 271, 285, 296–7, 301

Greek, 256–7;

age witnessed by, 267, 268

“Graffiti,” later, 229

Teaching of, 219, 220, 225, 307

Value of, to explorers, 229

Inspiration, claimed for Haggadah, 365;

of Jewish Scriptures, Talmud view on, 364–5;

of New Testament writings, 70;

voice of, cessation of, 73

Invocation of Saints, not generally taught in Catacombs, 312

Irenæus, teacher of S. Hippolytus, 14, 138, 170, 251, 315, 319 n. 1;

list of Roman Bishops by, 15;

writings addressed by, to cultured classes, 111 n. 1

cited in support of Petrine tradition, 10, 14

on Christians at Court, 147;

on the founding of the Roman Church by SS. Peter and Paul and on Linus, 15;

on numbers of Christians at Rome, 104, 106, 107;

on Polycarp and his memories of S. John, 73

Isaiah, the prophet, 365;

book of, 53rd chapter of, use made of, by early Christian writers, 117 & n. 1

cited on Forgiveness of Sins, 155

Israel, Glorification of, the object of the Talmud, 345

Itineraries, Pilgrim (see also Names), value of, to explorers of Catacombs, &c., 209 et seq., 227–8, 242, 243, 246, 247

Jamnia, Rabbinic School at, 326, 353, 357, 358 n. 1

Jannes and Jambres, source of names of, 379

Jerusalem, Ælia Capitolina built on site of, 332, 335–6;

result, 336–8;

Hadrian’s insults at, to Christianity, 77–8

Apostolic Council at, S. Peter at, 8

Communism in the Church at, results of, 120 n. 1, 130

Fall and destruction of, effect on Jewish nation, 22, 39, 340, 342, 346–8, 351, 353, 355, 357, 362, 368

Parties in, before first great war, 329–30

Sieges of, in order of date, by Gallus, 330;

Vespasian, 331;

Titus, 331–3;

Severus, 337

Taken by Pompey, 3

Jesus Christ (see also Christ), Godhead of, importance of the testimony of Apostolic Fathers in regard to, 74

Jew, the, and the Talmud (Book V.), 325 et seq.

Jewish Encyclopædia, cited on the life of Rabbinic schools, 359

Jewish heroes, Haggadic legends of, 378

Learning, stimulus to, of Talmudic study, 369

National ideals as affected by War of Extermination, 78–9

Scriptures, Canonical, 361;

inspiration of, 364–5

Women, disabilities of, 367 & n. 1, 380

Jews, attitude of, to the Gospel, reasons for, 7

Discrimination of, from Christians by Romans, progress of, 27, 30, 78, 79, 80, 92, 164

of the Dispersion, influence on, of Rabbinism, 339–41;

and of the Talmud, 339 et seq., 368–9

Fate of, after last wars, 325–6

History of, in Old Testament and after, 325–6;

evidential importance of, to Christianity, 325, 326

Persecutions of, and martyrs of, 336, 337, 338

Preservation of, as distinct race, 326;

cause of, 339, 345–7

in Rome, 3–6, 346;

expulsion of, 8, 18, 25;

Roman attitude to beliefs of, 3, 39;

rulers favourable to, 3

Twentieth Century, distinct, still, as race, 326;

influence of, 346;

numbers of, 369

Wars of, the three last, story of, and of consequences, 77, 78–9, 80, 325, 329 et seq., 354

Jochanan ben Zacchai, Rabbi, and his school of disciples, work of, on the Mishna, 341, 353;

teaching of, 358

John, the Abbot, 228

John, the Deacon, 49

John, King, desired burial-place of, 321

John, the Presbyter, cited on S. Mark, 9–10

Jordani, catacomb of, 258, 260;

tombs in, of sons of S. Felicitas, 259, 303

Joseph of Arimathea, 110

Joseph the patriarch, and idol-worship, 149

Josephus, on the burning of the Temple, 331

Joshua, and the oral Law, 339

Judæa, Roman rule over, 329;

and revolts against (see also Jews, Wars of, and Zealots), 329 et seq.

Judaism, Authority and Influence of the Talmud on, 368–9

Julia Sabina, wife of Hadrian, 75

Julian, Emperor, 75

Letter from, to Arsacius, on Christian characteristics, 131;

on Christian brotherliness, 123 n. 1, 128

Julianus, Pope, martyr, tomb of, 243

Julius Cæsar, 56;

favour shewn by, to Jews, 3

Julius I, Pope, 276

Jupiter, worship of, test for Christians, 194, 195

Justin Martyr, 319 n. 1;

compared with Theophilus of Antioch, 189;

martyrdom of, 94, 104, 184;

teaching of, 138

on Aid to Prisoners, 130;

on Almsgiving, 113–4, 119, 129;

on Assemblies, 108, 113–4;

on Care of the Sick, 127;

on Christian fortitude, 185;

on Christ’s atonement, 117;

on highly-placed Christians, 111;

on Hospitality, 113–4, 128, 129;

on the numbers of Christians, 104, 106, 107;

on Persecutions, 37, 184–6;

on progress of Christianity, 107

Justinian, Emperor, dedication of a church by, to a slave-saint, 136 n. 1;

Talmud condemned by, 365

Justus, and S. Nicomedes, 255–6

Juvenal, on Domitian’s unpopularity, 42 & n. 2;

on the ideal Roman, 88;

on Roman Society, 58

Kabbala, the, 360, 362 n. 1

Kimchi, D., famous Rabbinist, 369

Kyneburg, Abbess of Gloucester, 279

Lactantius, on Almsgiving, 122;

on Care for widows and orphans, 126–7;

on Christian virtues, and burial of the dead, 131–2, 133;

on Persecutions, 32

Lanciani,—, 236,

cited on Basilica of S. Paul, 238

Languages, of Christian Epitaphs in Catacombs, 308

Lateran Museum, Christian sarcophagi in, sculptures on, 19 n. 1

Latin language, debt of, to Cicero, 58

Latin Literature, by Dr. Mackail, cited on Marcus Aurelius’s letters, 63 n. 1

Law, Mosaic (see Torah and Midrash), Commentaries on, see Haggadah, Halachah, Midrash, Talmud, Targumim, &c.

Roman, on treatment of Christians, 32, 49

“Law upon the Lip,” tradition on, 339

Le Blant,—, on the School for Martyrdom, 198 n. 1

Lecky, W. H., cited, see History of European Morals

Leland’s Itinerary, on cult of S. Petronilla (Petronell), 278–9

Leo III, Pope, translation of S. Felicitas and Silanus by, 259, 302

Leo IV, Pope, saints translated by, 249;

on tombs of Priscilla and Aquila, 262

Letter-form, of Apostolic “remains,” 73;

in Literature, reason of popularity, 70–1;

sole O.T. instance of, 69

Letters (see also Epistles), by Classical writers and others, in Roman literature, 56 et seq.

meant for publication, 56, 61–2, 65, 66, 67, 68;

not so meant, 63

others, by Christians modelled on these lines, 69 et seq.

Letters relating the Martyrdom of Polycarp, genuine, 81 n. 1

Liber Pontificalis, antiquity of, 15;

value of, to Catacomb explorers, 226–7

cited on Basilica of Constantine the Great at S. Peter’s tomb, 282;

on S. Cecilia’s tomb, 262, 293 n. 1, 296;

on Novatus, 264;

on S. Priscilla’s catacomb, burials in, 266;

on S. Pudentiana and her sister, 264, 265 n. 1

Liberian or Philocalian catalogue, cited in support of Petrine tradition, 14, 15;

on burials in S. Priscilla’s cemetery, 266;

on the tomb of S. Felicitas and her sons, 301, 302–3, 304

Liberius, Pope, 301;

burial-place of, 272

Licinius, 29

Lightfoot, Bp., 121 n. 1;

on the Acts of the Passion of S. Felicitas, 300;

on the Antonine persecutions, 94 & n. 2;

on the authorship of the 2nd Epistle of Clement of Rome, 104 n. 1;

on Caius, 11;

on the date of the Epistle to Diognetus, 178 n. 1;

on the date of Octavius, 186;

on Epistolary form as usual with the Apostles, 74 n. 1;

on genuineness of Pliny’s letter, &c., 46 & n. 1;

on Hilary’s reference to Vespasian’spersecutions, 40 & n. 3;

on Ignatius, 73;

authenticity of his (so-called) Epistles, 172–3;

his letter to the Roman Church, 9;

his yearning for martyrdom, 175;

on The Shepherd, of Hermas, 180;

on its date and author, 179 n. 1;

on S. Hippolytus, 11, 251–2;

on S. Laurence, 254;

on S. Paul’s Epistle to the Romans and S. Peter’s first coming to Rome, 19 n. 1;

on S. Peter (and S. Mark) in Rome, 10, 18;

on S. Petronilla, 277

Linus, Pope, first Bishop of Rome after S. Peter, 12, 15;

burial-place of, 283, 287;

Jerome on, 14;

“Memoria” chapel of, Papal burial-place in church on site of, 273

Lister, Jane, epitaph of, 309

Literary witness to Martyrs’ histories rehabilitated by De Rossi’s excavations, 225, 230–1

to Numerousness of Martyrs, 209 et seq.

to Persecution, A.D. 64–80, 163 et seq.

Lombards, the, 293, 297

Lorium, country home of Antoninus Pius, 86, 87

Love as bond of Christians, 118–9

Lucilius, Seneca’s letters to, 29

Lucina, Catacomb or Cemetery of, in a garden, 234, 236, 238, 239;

S. Paul’s burial-place, 236;

S. Sebastian’s burial-place, 244

Crypt of, identification of, 245

Lucius Quietus, Roman general, 335

Lucius Verus, Fronto’s correspondence with, 63

“Luminaria,” in the Catacombs, 296 & n. 1;

indication from, of crypt below, 229

Lydda, Rabbinic school of, 357, 358 n. 1

Lyons, birthplace of Sidonius Apollinaris, 65

Literary support from, of Petrine tradition, 9, 13

Martyrdoms at, 94, 201, 208;

genuine accounts of, 81 n. 1

Pliny’s letters read to an audience, 61

Maccabean dynasty, agreements made by, with Rome, 3

Maccabees, story in, like that of S. Felicitas, 258, 298

Mackail, Dr., on letters of Marcus Aurelius, 63 & n. 1

Madaurian persecutions, 94

Maderno, Stefano, architect, 259 n. 1;

statue of S. Cecilia by, 294;

replicas of, ib. n. 1

Magnesia, Epistle to, of Ignatius, 173, 174

Mahommedanism, spread of, compared with that of Christianity, 102

Maimonides, famous Rabbinist, 369;

on the fathers of Rabbinism, 339

Manuals of Martyrdom, 199

Marc-Aurèle, by Renan, cited, 146 n. 1

Marcellinus, Pope and martyr, burial-place of, 266;

identified, 231

Marcellus, Pope and martyr, burial-place of, 266, 272

Marchi, Father, archæological work of, 209, 224

Marcia, patronage by, of Christians, 147

Marcion, 189

Marcius Turbo, Roman general, 335

Marcomanni, war with, 95

Marcus, burial-place identified, 231

Marcus Aurelius Antoninus adopted by Antoninus Pius and successor to him, 83, 145, 245, 292;

attitude of, to Christians, 33, 64, 80, 158

Character of, 84 et seq., 189

Correspondence of, with Fronto, 63–4

Death of, 164

“Meditations” by, 85–6, 96–7;

on Antoninus Pius, 85–6;

Christian pages of, 147;

on his religious ideas, 96–7

its one reference to Christians, 96–7

Persecutions by, 80–1, 163 n. 2, 164, 188–9, 190, 207, 208 n. 1,

and reasons for, 81, 91–7, 137, 194;

martyrs in, 184, 258–9, 264, 266, 289, 290, 291, 298 et seq., 305

Melito’s discourse on, written to, 187–8

Table of succession of, 83

Marriage, Rigourist teaching on, 153

Mars, 195

Martial, poet, 59 n. 1;

attitude of, to the old Roman virtue, 88

Martyrdom, aspiration to, checked by the Church, 154

Attraction of (see Ignatius), 37, 153 et seq.

Schools of training for, 33, 36, 145

Methods of, writers on, 197, 198 & n. 1 et seq.

Physical training for, 198, 201–3

Spiritual training, 198–201

Results, 203–5

Spirit in which faced, 205 et prævi

Martyres, Ad, by Tertullian, 199;

on Physical training, 202

Martyrii, De Laudi, 199;

on Christian fortitude in torture, 193

Martyrologies, literary sources of, in many instances rehabilitated by De Rossi’s catacomb excavations, 225, 230–1;

on Confessors buried in Catacomb of Commodilla, 239

Martyrology of S. Jerome, value of, to Catacomb explorers, 226

Martyrs, Apocalyptic references to, 37, 157, 167–70

Burial and burial-places of (see Catacombs, Cemeteries, and Itineraries), 285–6;

burial near, desired, 312 & n. 1, 321–2

Formula for, of reply to judge, 199

Hermas on, 181

Hymns on, by Prudentius and others, 151–2 & n. 1

under Nero (q.v.), 267–8, 285–6

Numbers of, emphasized, 33;

“small” theory refuted by archæology and literature, 82 & n. 1, 207 et seq., 209 et seq.

Christian and Pagan witness to, 208

Second-century, rarity of Festivals of, 208

Seed of the Church, 196, 203

Slaves, famous, 136

Tombs of, 300 et passim

Traces of, in S. Peter’s Memoria, 284–5

Translation of, 227, 235, 236, 266 & n. 1, 267, 272, 273–4, 292

Martyrum, De Gloriâ, by S. Gregory of Tours, cited on tragedy at tomb of SS. Chrysanthus and Daria, 261

Martyrum, De Locis SS., cited 210–11, 303;

on numbers of martyrs, 212, 213, 214

Marucchi,—, archæological researches and work of, 12, 42, 234, 239, 263, 301;

identification by, of S. Peter’s baptistery, 12, 257

on Acilius Glabrio, 269

on Catacomb of S. Priscilla as associated with S. Peter, &c., 257, 267, 268, 270, 271, 273;

on its immensity and regularity, 271

on the Domitilla Cemetery, 240

on Excavations, results of, attained and anticipated, 231–2

on Nicomedes’ cemetery, reservoir in, 256

on Papal burial-places, 273

on S. Cecilia’s burial-places and tradition, 293 n. 1, 298

on S. Felicitas’s tomb, and those of her sons, 302, 303

on the Thrason Catacomb, 260

on the veneration paid to S. Laurence, 250

Massorah, the, 361 et seq.;

Temple Torah readings preserved in, 333 n. 2

Massoretes, the, duties of, 361–2

Massoretic notes on the sacred Jewish texts, 362–4

Mauritanian martyrdoms, 208

Maximian, Emperor, 148 & n. 1

Maximin, Emperor, Persecution under, 163 n. 2

Meir, Rabbi, codification of Talmud by, 356;

maxims of, on Women, 367

Melito, Bishop of Sardis, on Hospitality, 128;

on Persecution, 32, 187–8;

silent as to Vespasian, 40 n. 3

Memoriæ or Chapel-Tombs of Apostles, at Rome, locale of, 11, 233, 281 et seq.;

testimony of, to Petrine tradition, 17

Mental guerdons of Christianity, 154–9

Messiah, hopes of, revolts due to, 330, 334

pseudo, revolts caused by, 336 et seq., 354–5

Midoth, treatise, 358 n. 1

Midrash, definition of, 371

Explained, two currents in, 350, 351

Subject-matter of, 376–7

Midrashim, the, 360

Milan, Edict of, effect of, on spread of Christianity, 150 & n. 1

Milman, Dean, on the style of the Octavius of Minucius Felix, 186–7

Minucius Felix (see Octavius by), 158

Miracles, Talmudic teaching on, 365

Mishnah (see also Haggadah, Halachah, and Talmud);

basis of, 361;

chief object of study, Rabbinic schools, 358 n. 1;

how studied, 359–60, 362–3;

curiosities of, 346–7;

Divine inspiration claimed for, 365;

evolution of, 341, 342–4;

exclusive spirit in, 366–8;

meaning of name, and nature of work, 341 & n. 1, 344 & n. 1, 356 & n. 3, 358 & n. 1, 365, 370;

oral at first, 344;

in the two Talmuds, 344–5;

on Akiba’s martyrdom, 355 & n. 1;

on the history of the Talmud, 339–40

Mishnah, the non-canonical, 360, 373

Mishnaic Rabbis, work of, on Halachah and Haggadah, 341, 344–5, 347, 351, 352, 358 & n. 1

Mission and Expansion of Christianity, by Harnack, 106 n. 1, 124–5

Mommsen,—, 331 n. 1, on Pagan Rome personified in Apocalypse, 169 n. 1;

on Pliny’s letter, 46

Monza Catalogue and Labels, story of, evidence of, on numerousness of martyrs, 214–5, 228;

reference in to S. Felicitas and her sons, 303–4;

use of, to catacomb explorers, 228

Mosaic work, oldest, in Roman church, 263

Mosaism, destruction of, 341

Moses, 348, 349;

and the Law, 339

Rabbinical teaching in, 343 & n. 1, and on, 364, 373–4, 378

Mucius Scævola, torture of, 187

Muratorian Canon, on date of The Shepherd of Hermas, 178–9

Music, association with, of S. Cecilia, 294 n. 1

Mutual aid between Christian Churches, inculcated, 130–1

Myers, F. W., verse by, on the Atonement, 115 n. 1

Naaman, the Syrian, and Idol-worship, 149

Nævius, the augur, 87

Naples, memorial at, of S. Agnes, 256–7

Nehardea, Rabbinic school at, 357, 358 n. 1

Nero, Emperor, 39, 40, 41, 42 n. 2, 182, 183, 197, 232, 245, 269

Death of, 207, 331

Edict of, against Christians, 32, 54

Fire at Rome attributed to, 26–7, 28, 31, 285

Insanity of, 26

Jews in Rome in reign of, 5

Persecutions by, 10, 28, 30, 46 n. 1, 62, 104, 164, 167, 172, 190, 197;

burnings under, 28–30;

numbers involved, 28, 46 n. 1;

S. Peter martyred during, 267, 285–6;

Tacitus’s references to, 62

New Testament, the, writers of, and writings, see also under names of Authors, and of Books, and see Epistles

Assemblies mentioned in, 101

Haggadic influences seen in, 378–9

Inspiration of, 70

Publication intended, Deissmann on, 71

References in, to Persecution, 165, 166–70

Teaching of, on Hospitality, 128–9;

and on Slavery, 134–5

Witness of, to spread of Christianity, 107

Nicholas, Pope, 226

Nicodemus and other persons of position among Early Christians, 110–12

Nicolaitan heresy, 23 n. 1

Nicomedia, Court of, Christians at, 147–8

Nîmes, birthplace of Antoninus Pius, 83

Nomeseus, martyr, 211

Northcote, Dr., on Early Christian faith as shown in Catacomb inscriptions, 310

“Notices” on the founding of the Roman Church, as bearing on tradition of S. Peter, 8, 9 et seq.

Novatus, Baths of, 264, 265

Numerian, Emperor, persecution under, 260

OCTAVIUS, Dialogue by Minucius Felix, 138, 145–6, 186–7;

on Christian love, 119, 129;

on Christians in high place, 111;

on persecution, 186–7

Octodurum, Martyrdom legend of, 148 n. 1

Old Testament, Books of, text of, Jewish care of, and commentaries on, 342 et seq., 370, 371–9

Christian reverence for, influence on, of the Talmud, and of Rabbinism, 327, 370 & n. 1

Earliest Hebrew MSS. of, 363

History in, value of, 325

Letter in, the one, 69

Teaching of, on Almsgiving, 121

Onesimus, and S. Paul, 134

Oral teaching in Rabbinic Schools, 357–60

Oratory, Church of, London, replica in of Maderno’s S. Cecilia effigy, 294 n. 1

Origen, modified Rigourism of, 146;

teaching of, 139;

identification by, of Hermas, 178;

veneration of, for The Shepherd, by Hermas, 179;

writings by, on Martyrdom, 199

Osric, King of Northumbria, burial-place of, 279

Ostia, 145, 186–7, 235, 236

Ostian Way, Memoria of Apostle on, 11

Ostrian Cemetery, other names of, 255, 257, 271

Otho, Emperor, 39, 331

Overbach,—, views of, on Trajan’s Rescript, 49

Ovid, poetic epistles of, 69 n. 1

Ozanam on Slaves in Roman Empire, first and second centuries, 135 n. 2

PÆDAGOGUS, by Clement of Alexandria, addressed to a cultured community, 111 n. 1;

on Christians in the world, 146

Pagan attitude to Christianity, and its basis (see also Persecutions), 28, 30–4, 35, 36, 51, 77, 137, 142–3, 158–9, 164–5, 194, 196–7

Attitude to death, 134, 313–4

Ideas on Christian misery, 158–9

Neglect to bury the dead, 132

Neglect of the poor, 128

Writings, witnessing to Persecutions (see Pliny’s letter to Trajan), 36;

and to spread of Christianity, 107

Paganism (passim), at core of Roman Empire, De Broglie on, 142–3;

displaced by Christianity, when, and why, 150, 151

Pain, unfelt by Martyrs, testimony to, 200

Palaces, Christians in, 110–11, 147, 149

Palatine Hill, palace on, of the Emperors, 86, 89;

graffito of crucifix on, deduction from, 147 & n. 1

Palestine (see also Gemara and Talmud), Rabbinic Schools of, 326, 344, 362–3, 373;

the chief, 353, 356 & n. 4, 358 n. 1;

mode of teaching at, 357–60

Roman occupations of, and Rabbinism, 340

Traces of the last “War” still seen in, 338–9

Palestinian Talmud, the, 345

Pallanteum, rebuilt by Antoninus, 87

Palm, as Christian Emblem, 310

Pantheon, portico of, robbed for Pope Urban’s baldachino, 280

Papal burial-places, 243, 245, 246, 250, 266 & n. 1, 272–4, 283–5, 286–7, 291

Crypt, named after Pope Callistus (see also Papal burial-places), 234, 236–7, 242, 244 et seq., 273, 287, 296, 297

Papias of Hierapolis, cited in support of Petrine tradition, 9, 10, 13, 14

Paschal I, Pope, 227, 273, 276, body of S. Cecilia found by, 292–4;

and translated, 294, 297;

Church of S. Cecilia built by, 292;

translation by, of Martyrs’ remains, 235, 262, 263, 295

Vision of, 293

on Forgotten Martyrs, 215 n. 1

Passions of the Martyrs, oft-repeated answer given in, 199

of S, Perpetua, on Insensibility of Martyrs to Pain, 200

Pastor (not The Shepherd, q.v.), 264

Patristic views of The Shepherd of Hermas, 179

Paul, the Deacon, 49

Paul I, Pope, 227, 273;

translation by, of Martyrs’ ashes, 235;

especially of S. Hippolytus, 254

Paul V, Pope, 257, discoveries made by, in Vatican cemetery, 280–1 et seq., 287;

work of, on S. Peter’s at Rome, 279–80

“Pax Romana,” the, 58

Peace of the Church, the, 29–30, 203, 215, 228, 259, 263, 266, 272, 276, 302, 309

Pilgrimages to Rome after, 209, 216, 228, 251

Pentateuch (see also Halachah), as canon of Jewish Scripture, post-exilian days, 361;

reverence felt for, 342, 343, 361;

Talmudic view of its inspiration, 364–5

People, the, faith of, shown by Catacombs, 315, 319 n. 1;

how voiced by poets and Popes, 152 & n. 1

Pepin, King, translation by, of S. Petronilla, 279

Pergamos, Church of, message of Apocalypse to, 168, 169–70

Peri-Stephanôn, by Prudentius, poems, subjects of, 151–2 & n. 1, cited on forgotten Martyrs, 287;

on S. Hippolytus, 252–4

Persecutions of Christians, see also Tacitus on

Active or latent, period of, 163 & n. 2

Evidence on, 163 & nn. 1 & 2, 164 et seq.

Beginning, 27–9, 103, 104

Continuity, 29 et seq., 80, 207;

and increasing intensity, 80, 81–3

End, 29

Reasons for, 28, 30, 31, 32, 39 et seq.

Reference to, in The Shepherd of Hermas, 180 et seq.

Silence of writers as to, reasons for, 35 & n. 1, 36–7

Under the Antonines, 80, 81, 94

Decius Aurelius, 97

Diocletian, 97;

severity of, 151

Flavian emperors, 39 et seq.

Hadrian and his successors, 79, 80,

severity of, 81, 82 & n. 1, 83;

reasons, 91–7

Nero, 10, 28, 30, 46 n. 1, 62, 104, 164, 167, 172, 190, 197, 285–6

of Jews, 346

Petro or Petros, as basis of name Petronilla, 277

Petro, T. Flavius, founder of Flavian family, 277

Pharisees, 329–30;

after the Dispersion, 341

Philemon, S. Paul’s Epistle to, 71, 134

Philip, Emperor, lenient to Christians, 97

Philip of Side, on Athenagoras’s conversion, 188 & n. 1

Philip, son of S. Felicitas, tomb of, 259

Philippians, Epistle to, see Epistles

Phœbe of Cenchrea, 110

Physical preparation for Martyrdom (see also Schools of Martyrdom), 198, 201–3

Pilgrim Guides (see also Itineraries), witness of, to numerousness of Martyrs, 210

Pilgrims, visits of, to Rome, 209, 216, 226, 228, 251;

favourite tombs of, 244, 260, 275, 294, 296, 297;

traces of, in Catacombs, 248, 251

Pirke Aboth (Sayings of the Fathers), 339, 340, 362, 365 n. 1

“Pittacia,” the, references in, to S. Felicitas and her sons, 303, 304

Pius I, Bishop of Rome, or Pope, 264, 265 n. 1;

burial-place of, 287;

slave origin of, 136 n. 1

Pius IX, Pope, and the rediscovery of the Callistus Catacomb, 246

Placidia, and the Basilica of S. Paul, 238

Plato, works of, 146

Platonia Chamber or Crypt, Cemetery of S. Sebastian, temporary tomb of SS. Peter and Paul, 237, 243;

tomb of S. Sebastian near, 244

Plautius, 245

Pliny the Elder, 57

Pliny the Younger, family career and character of, 57–9

Letters of, in general, described and discussed, 59–62;

features of, 71;

value of, 57

to Tacitus, 62

to Trajan, and information in, on Christianity, 27, 32, 33, 35 n. 1, 36, 45 et seq., 50, 53–5, 56–7, 60 n. 1, 62, 75–8, 103 & n. 2, 106, 107, 110, 177

Publication of, 60 n. 1

Summary of, 67

Trajan’s Rescript in reply, 53–4

Literary followers of, 64–8

Style of, 60, Renan on, 46 & n. 1, 60

Roman appreciation of, as writer, 63, 65

Rules of, for letter-writers, 67

Villa of, 60

on joys of simple living, 88–9;

on social status of Asiatic Christians, 110

Plotina, Empress, and Hadrian, 75

Plumbatæ, torture of, 295, 300 n. 1

Poems, by Early Christian writers, topics of, 151, 152 & n. 1

Pagan, referring to Christianity, 158 n. 1

Political reasons for Roman attitude to Christianity (see also Paganism), 28, 30, 31–4, 39 et seq.

Polycarp, Bishop of Smyrna, 251;

scholar of S. John Evangelist, 73;

letters of, see Epistles;

letters to, of Ignatius, 108, 172;

Martyrdom of, letters on, genuine, 81 n. 1;

on Christian charity, 125

Pompey, Consul, 56;

first Roman ruler of Judea, 329;

Jerusalem taken by, 3

Pomponia Græcina, identified with Lucina of the Crypt, 245

Pontianus, catacomb of, 211, 235

Baptistery in, 236

Pontianus, Bishop of Rome, or Pope, martyr, tomb of, 252

Pontius, on Christian Charity at Carthage, 127

Pontus, Christians in (see also Bithynia), 45, 50

Pope,——, his ode on S. Cecilia, 294 n. 1

Popes (or Bishops) of Rome (see under individual Names, see also Papal burial-places), martyred, tombs of, with other Martyrs, 243

Poppæa, Empress, friendly to Jews, 27

Porsenna, 87

Portraits in the Catacombs, 296, 302

Portus, Bishop of, see S. Hippolytus Port of Rome, 235

Prayers of the Dead, besought by Early Christians, 309–10, 311–2

S. Augustine on, 311, 312 n. 1, 321–2

S. Cyprian on, 312

Prætextatus, catacomb of, 242, 246–8, 259, 262, 295;

grave (alleged) of S. Cecilia in, 293 n. 1;

tomb of S. Januarius in, discovery of, 301–2;

S. Zeno buried in, 276

Priests as converts, 110

Priscilla (and Aquila), 110, 265–6

Catacomb of, 213;

discovery of, 230

Prisoners, Christian aid to, 130

Prophets, the, 339;

books of, 361;

inspiration of, Talmud on, 365;

Schools of, 343, 349

Prudentius, poems of, 151, 152 & n. 1

Publius, Prefect of Rome, and the martyrdom of S. Felicitas, 299

Pudens, burial-place of, 264, 265, 266;

house, &c., of, on the Aventine, legends connecting with S. Peter, 12, 15, 263;

and with S. Paul, 265, 269;

question of his family, 270;

tradition, on him and his daughter, 263–5, 270

Pumbeditha, Rabbinic School at, 326, 354, 357, 358 n. 1, 359, 373

“Quatuor Coronati,” Saints, burial-places of, 249;

church of, ib.,

relics in, of S. Hippolytus, 255

Quintilian, the earliest Ciceronian, 58

Quo vadis legend, locality associated with, 273, 274

“Rab,” Rabbinic School founded by, 357 n. 1

“Rabbi” (Judah Ha-Nasi), famous pupil of, 357 n. 1;

Talmud codification by, 356–7;

work of, on Halachah, 358 n. 1, 372 n. 1

Rabbinic Dicta, on Inspiration, 364–5 & n. 1

Literature (extra-Talmudic), 360

Schools (see also Babylonian, and Palestinian), 326, 353, 354–5, 362–3, 368, 372, 373;

chief study of, 358 n. 1;

foundation of, 326, 340, 341;

influence of, on Christian belief, 327;

and on Christian love of Old Testament, 327;

method of teaching, 357–60;

work of, on the Gemara, 344–5

Rabbinism, famous scholars of (see Akiba, Gamaliel, Hillel, Meir, “Rab,” Rabbi, Shammai, &c.), nature of, and influence of, on Christianity, 326–7;

and on the Jews of the Dispersion, 339;

new school of, aims of, 353, 355;

spirit of, adverse to Christianity, 366 et seq.;

traditional history of, 339–40

Rabbis, authority of, as successors to the Sanhedrim, 357;

supporting Bar-cochab, 78, 336, 354, 355

Rabbis of the Dispersion, and the Law, 341, 342–3;

books evolved by, 343–5

Raffaelle, painting by, of S. Cecilia, 294 n. 1

Ramsay, Professor, on the date of the 1st Epistle of S. Peter, 8 n. 1, 166 n. 1;

on the date of S. Peter’s death, 166 n. 1;

on Epistles of Ignatius as showing contemporary conditions of Christianity, 173, 174;

on Persecution of Christians as a police measure, by Rome, 31, 32;

on Pliny’s letter, 46;

on Roman Emperor as “beast” of Apocalypse, 169 & n. 2;

on Roman references in the Apocalypse, 169 n. 2

Raschi, famous Rabbinist, 369

Ravenna, 303;

church of S. Vitale at, 136 n. 1

Regulus, tortures of, 187

Relic-hunting in the Catacombs, results of, 224

Religious faith of Jews in Rome, first century, 4–6

Renan, E., on the destruction of the Temple, 331 n. 1;

on large numbers of Christian martyrs, 82 n. 1;

on Octavius by Minucius Felix, 145, 146;

on persecutions between A.D. 134 and 180, 82 n. 1;

on Pliny’s letter, 46 & n. 1;

and on his literary style, ib., 60;

on The Shepherd, of Hermas, 180;

on Talmudic influence on Christianity, 370 n. 1;

on Trajan as persecutor, 49

Reservoirs or wells, in Catacombs and Chapels (see also Baptisteries), 256, 263, 264, 267, 270, 271–2

Reuchlin,—, advocate of the Talmud, 366

Rhea Sylvia, 87

Rigourist School of Christian teaching, 101, 144–5, 150–2, 153–4

Rimmon-worship, Naaman’s dispensation concerning, 149

“Rock, the spiritual, that followed them,” origin of reference, 379

Roman attitude to Christianity, 39 et seq.

Roman attitude to Slaves, and to Freedmen, 134, 137;

craving for posthumous remembrance, 59 n. 1, 65

Christians, saluted in S. Paul’s Epistle to Romans, 17, 21

Church, the, in early days, classes composing, 182, 269–70

Early importance of, 16, 17, 21

Founders of (see also S. Paul and S. Peter), 7 et seq., 16–19, 22, 23, 24, 70

Generosity of, to other Churches, 131

Heresies menacing, first century, 23 & n. 1

Inner life of, information on, from the Catacombs, 219 et seq.

Letter to, of Ignatius, 9

S. Paul’s praise of, 21

Emperors, divine honours paid to, 42 & n. 1, 169, 170

Empire, numbers of Early Christians in great centres of, 106

of Slaves in, first and second centuries, 135 n. 2

Paganism (q.v.), interwoven in, 142–3

Literature, dearth of, second to fourth century, 63, 67

Epistolary forms, nature of, after Cicero, 56–7

Letters in, question of influence on N.T. writers, 69–72

Renaissance, in fourth and fifth centuries, 64 et seq.

Myths depicted on coins of Antoninus Pius, 87, 90

Society, Dill’s book on, cited, 59 n. 1;

first and second century, Pliny on, 58–60;

fourth century, Symmachus on, 65;

fifth century, Sidonius on, 67

Tribute to Christian fortitude, 193

Rome, see also Popes under Names

Archæological investigators of, see De Rossi, Marchi, Marucchi, &c.

Basilicas in, third century, 112

Chief arena of Martyrdom, 175

Christians in, 16;

Assemblies of, 113 et seq.

Behaviour of, in trial, 180–1

Estimate of, in third century, 105

Life of, 101 et seq.

Some of high social status, 110–12, 147, 149

Church of, see Roman Church

Churches in, the most ancient, 263

Those holding relics of S. Hippolytus, 255

Dead, Roman and Christian treatment of (see also Catacombs), 131–3

Devotion to, of the Antonines, 89–90

Earliest founder of, 87

Fire of, under Nero, 25–6;

consequences to Jews and Christians, 27–30

Gospel first brought to, tradition on, and literary support of the same, 7, 8, 9 et seq.

Hadrian’s works in, 76

Jewish agreements with, under Maccabees, 3

Colonists in, and the Rabbinic School, 353

Sabbath observed in, 3

Jews in, 3–6, 346;

expulsion of, 8, 18, 25;

Roman attitude to beliefs of, 3, 39;

rulers favourable to, 3

Literary support from, of Petrine tradition, 9, 13

Memoriæ of the Apostles in, 11

Pagan, Apocalyptic reference to, Ramsay on, 169 & n. 1, 170

Attitude of, to Christianity, 39 et seq.;

reasons for, 89, 91–7

Religion of, support to, of best emperors, 87 et seq.

Rule of, over Judæa, 329, 340;

revolts against (see Wars), 329 et seq., 342, 345, 353

S. Paul’s stay in, 17, 21–24;

and Martyrdom at, 9

S. Peter’s visits to, probable dates of, and events during, 16, 18, 19 & n. 1, 24;

and Martyrdom at, 8;

burial-place in, see Vatican Hill

Slavery in, 134

Temple treasures from Jerusalem at, 333 & n. 2

Rome proper, burial-place in, of S. Paul, 236;

Catacombs in, Itineraries on, 211–4

Rome Souteraine, by Allard, cited on numerousness of martyrs, 215 n. 1

Romulus and Remus, 87

Ruinart,—, on the Martyrdom of the Theban legion, 148 n. 1

Rusticus, Roman prefect, 94, 104

Rutilius Namatianus, poem of, on Christian misery, 158 & n. 1

Sabbath, the, non-Jewish observance of, Rome, 3

Sabinilla, burial of S. Valentinus by, 276

Sacramentum, of Pliny, 52

Sadducees, 329;

last heard of, 341

S. Abdon, burial-place of, 235, 236

S. Achilles, martyr, burial-place and tomb of, 211, 240, 241, 278;

story confirmed by excavations, 230

S. Adauctus, burial-place of, 239;

shrine of, 211

S. Agapetus, deacon and martyr, 301 & n. 1, 302;

History of, 247;

tomb of, 243, 247

S. Agatha, 294 n. 1

S. Agatopus or Agapetus (q.v.), martyr named in tomb of S. Januarius, 301 & n. 1, 302

S. Agnes, 136, 294 n. 1;

basilica of, Catacombs around, 212–3, 255;

burial-place of, identified, 231;

martyrdom and story of, 256;

other martyrs buried with, 214–5;

urn of, 258;

recently seen, 257

S. Alexander, burial-place of, 303

S. Anastasia, 294 n. 1

S. Athanasius, veneration of, for Hermas’s Shepherd, 179

S. Augustine, on asking the prayers of the Saints, 311, 312 n. 1, 322;

on Burial near the Saints, 322;

on S. Laurence, 254

S. Balbinus, Catacomb of, 239

S. Barnabas, Apostle, 110

S. Basilissa, see (infra) S. Hermes and

S. Blandina, slave and martyr, 136;

pain unfelt by, 200

S. Calepodius, catacomb of, 234

S. Callistus, later, Pope, custodian of cemeteries, 245, 291

Catacomb of, 242, 244–6;

Crypt of S. Cecilia in, 290–1, 293 n. 1;

discovery of, 246;

Lucina area of, antiquity of, 266;

Papal burial-place or Crypt in (q.v.), 287, 291;

why chosen, 273

S. Castulus, martyr, catacomb of, 249

S. Cecilia, church of, Rome, 292 et seq.;

her body in, 294, 297

Crypt or burial-place of, 211, 246 & n. 1, 290 et seq.;

discovery of, 231;

other martyrs buried in, 214, 243;

rediscovery of, 289 et seq.

Martyr relatives of, 247

Story of, 290 et seq.

Translation of, 294, 297

S. Chrysanthus and S. Daria, Basilica of, sons of S. Felicitas laid near, 303;

site of their martyrdom, 260;

tragedy at, 261

S. Chrysostom, on Almsgiving, 122

S. Clement of Rome, Pope, 104, 179 & n. 1, 315

Book on, by Bishop Lightfoot, 19 n. 1, 121 n. 1;

cited on Petrine tradition, 10

Epistles of, see under Epistles

Ordination of, by S. Peter, tradition on, 11

Tradition on his Apostolic teachers, 73

on Almsgiving, 121 & n. 1, 124, 126;

on Assemblies, 108;

on care for widows and orphans, 126;

on Christians accused of firing Rome, 27;

on Christ’s Atonement, 115;

on the deaths of S. Peter and of S. Paul, 171;

on early persecutions, 37, 165, 170–2;

on hospitality, 128;

on numbers of Christians, 104 & n. 1, at Rome, 106;

on progress of Christianity, 107;

on S. Peter’s martyrdom, 9

S. Constantia, church of, origin of, 263

S. Cornelius, other martyrs buried with, 214–5

S. Cyprian, Bishop of Carthage, and martyr, 149, 193, 315, 319 n. 1;

and his congregation, charity of, 123, 127

Death of, 146

Flight of, 147

Letter of, ad Thibaritanos, a martyrs’ manual, 199

Teaching of, 139

Writers on, cited, see Benson, and Pontius

on Almsgiving, 121–2;

on Carthaginian generosity to other Churches, 131;

on the Dead as concerned for the Living, 312;

on Death, 155;

on Hospitality, 128;

on insensibility of Martyrs to pain, 200;

on Martyrs’ training, 198;

on Persecutions (third century), 37

S. Cyriaca, burial-place of, 212, 250

S. Daria, once a Vestal, site of her martyrdom, 260, 303

S. Denis, Abbey of, ashes of S. Hippolytus at, 255

S. Domitilla, Basilica of, 257

S. Emerentiana, slave and martyr, 136;

burial-place of, 255, 257;

identified, 231

Catacomb of, 255

Urn of, 258;

recently seen, 257

S. Epimachus, catacomb of, 249

S. Felicissimus, martyr, 301, 302;

history of, 247;

tomb of, 243, 247

S. Felicitas, slave and martyr, 136, 206, 272, 294 n. 1

Catacomb of, her tomb in a basilica over, 213, 259;

discovered, 260, 302

Martyr sons of, and their tombs, 213, 248;

discovered by De Rossi, 231 & n. 1

Story of, 258;

confirmed by archæology, 259–60, 298 et seq.

Translation of, 259, 302

on Insensibility to pain, 200

S. Felix (and S. Adauctus), burial-place of, 239

S. Felix, cemetery of, 211, 235–6

S. Felix, son of S. Felicitas, tomb of, 259, 266, 272, 274, 302–3

S. Felix, other martyrs buried with, 214–5

S. Felix of Nola, martyr, church of, at Nola, 321;

poems on, 152 n. 1

S. Flavian, Vision of, cited, on Martyrs’ insensibility to pain, 200

S. Gall, “sylloge” in library of, 230

S. Genesius, martyr, once an actor, tomb of, 251

S. Gordianus, catacomb of, 249

S. Gregory Nazianzen, on unity of martyrs, 285

S. Gregory of Tours, on the group-martyrdom at tomb of SS. Chrysanthus and Daria, 261

S. Helena, Empress, cross of, laid on S. Peter’s sarcophagus, 282;

tomb of, 249

S. Hermes, translation of, 275

and S. Basilissa, catacomb of, 274–5

S. Hippolytus (of Portus), 11, 151;

catacomb and basilica of, 250–5, 262;

discovery of, by De Rossi, 251, 254

Churches dedicated to, or connected with, 254–5

Lightfoot cited on, 251–2

Pupil of Irenæus, 251

Relics of, 255

Statue of, 252

Tomb of, 251;

Prudentius on, 252–4

Translation of, 254

S. Hyacinthus, martyr, tomb of, 275

S. Ignatius of Antioch, Bishop and martyr, 315;

Epistle of, see Epistles;

Martyrdom desired by, 37, 110, 154, 204–5;

date of, 73

cited in support of Petrine tradition, 9, 13;

on Assemblies, 108;

on Christ’s Atonement, 115;

on his yearning for Martyrdom, 204–5;

on influential Christians at Rome, 110;

on persecutions, 37, 165, 172–6;

on progress of Christianity, 107;

on Roman generosity, 131

S. James, Epistle of, see under Epistles

S. Januarius, 298 n. 1, 304;

martyrdom of, 300 n. 1;

burial-place and tomb of, 243, 248 & n. 1, 301–2;

discovery of, 231;

veneration of, 259

S. Jerome, Catalogue of Roman Bishops by, 14, 15

on S. Agnes, 256;

on S. Peter’s date of arrival in Rome, 14;

on The Shepherd, of Hermas, 179

S. John, Evangelist, 62, 251

Apocalypse of, 37, 156–7, 165, 167–70

Death of, 103, 114, 118, 165

Epistles of, see under Epistles

Martyrdom of, 11

Polycarp’s anecdotes of, 73

Prominence of, in Asia Minor, 9

S. Justus, martyr, tomb of, 250

S. Laurence, 254;

basilica and tomb of, 250, 257;

martyrs buried under, 212

Churches dedicated to, 250, 254

S. Lucia, 294 n. 1

S. Marcellinus, see S. Peter and, infra

S. Marcus, catacomb of, 239

S. Mark, Gospel of, source and place of origin, 10, 14

Relations of, with S. Peter, 9, 10, 14, 22

S. Martialis, son of S. Felicitas, tomb of, 259, 303

S. Martin of Tours, 136

S. Martinianus, see (infra) S. Processus and

S. Matthew, Gospel of, 10, as Martyrs’ Manual, 200 & n. 1, 201

S. Maurice and the Theban Legion, legend of martyrdom of, 148 n. 1

S. Maximus, Roman officer and martyr, 290;

basilica of, and history of, 247;

catacomb of, 259;

tomb of, 242, 293 n. 1, 295

S. Nereus, martyr, burial-place of, 211, 240, 241, 278;

story confirmed by excavations, 230

S. Nicomedes, catacomb of, special features of, 255–6

S. Oswald and S. Wulfstan, 321

S. Pamphilus, martyr, catacomb of, 274

S. Pancratius or Pancras, catacomb of, 234, 235

Churches of, Rome, &c., 235

S. Parnel, Petronell, or Petronilla (q.v.), British churches dedicated to, 278–9

S. Paul, 239, 269, 273;

association with, of Pudens, 265, and see 270

Basilica of, 11, 17, 18, 238

Christology of, 23–4

Cultural status of, 110

Epistles of, see under Epistles

Haggadic influences in writings of, 379

Hermas named by, the Hermas of The Shepherd?, 178

at Rome as prisoner, 21–2;

secondary place accorded by tradition and literature, 9, 11, 13–14, 17;

share in founding Roman Church, 17, 22, 23, 24, 70, 104;

trial of, 25;

and martyrdom, 9, 10, 11, 151, 152, 170, 171;

burial-places of, 211, 236, 237, 242, 243, 283;

sarcophagus of, slabs of, inscription on, and other features, 237–8;

sepulchre of, 242, 243

Teaching of, keynote of, where found, 23–4;

locale of, 107

Tomb of freedman friend of, among royal graves, 241–2

Translation of, 237

on Almsgiving to Christian Churches, 120 n. 1, 130;

on Assemblies, 107;

on Athletic training, 198;

on Charity, 122, 130;

on Death, 154;

on Enduring hardness, 202–3;

on Hospitality, 129;

on the Roman Church, 17, 21;

on Slavery, 134–5;

on Spread of Christianity, 107

S. Paulinus of Nola, 158;

letter of, to Sulpicius Severus, on his slave, 136–7;

poems of, 152 n. 1;

question of, to S. Augustine, 312 n. 1, 321–2

S. Perpetua and her companions, 294 n. 1;

martyrdoms of, 200, 208;

genuine accounts of, 81 n. 1;

pain unfelt by, 200

S. Peter, Apostle and Martyr, First Bishop of Rome (see also S. Petronilla), 226, 269

Associations of, with Catacomb of S. Priscilla, 257, 263, 267, 271–4

with S. Mark, 9, 10, 14, 22

with Pudens, 12, 15, 263, 265, and see 269–70

Baptistery of, site of, 12, 257, 267, 273

Book on by Barnes, cited, 281 n. 1 et seq.

Catacomb of, and of S. Marcellinus, 249

Founder of Church in Bithynia, 51

Founder of Church at Rome, tradition, archæological, and literary support to the belief, 7 et seq., 16, 19, 22, 70, 104

in Rome, 18, 24;

date of arrival discussed, 8, 11, 13 et seq., 16;

martyrdom of, 8, 10, 16, 18, 19, 151, 153, 170, 171, 233, 234;

date and site of, 166 n. 1, 267;

burial-places, and tomb of, 49, 273;

Bishops of Rome buried around, 16, 23, 233 & n. 1, 279–88;

sarcophagus of, adorned by Constantine, 237, 282–3;

traditional notices of, legendary with historical basis and other, 15, 16;

translation of, 237

Quo vadis legend on, 239, 273, 274

Teaching of, catholicity of, 367

on hospitality, 129;

on locale of Asiatic converts, 107;

on persecution, 165, 166–7;

on slavery, 135;

on spread of the faith, 107

S. Peter and S. Marcellinus, catacomb of, 249

S. Peter Chrysologus, laudation by, of S. Felicitas, 305

S. Peter’s (Basilica), Rome, 8, 233, 238;

martyrs buried beneath, 210, 285;

origin of, and former representatives of, 233, 238

Reason of its position, 11;

site of, associations of, 28;

veneration shown to, 17, 18

S. Petronilla (see also S. Parnel), daughter of S. Peter, 240, 241;

hypotheses on, discussed, 277–8

Basilica of, 241, 278

Burial-place of, 211, 240–1, 277

Translation of, 279

S. Philip, burial-place of, 266, 272, 274, 302–3

S. Philippus (S. Philip), other martyrs buried with, 214–5

S. Prassedis (see also S. Pudentiana), burial-place of, 263, 264–5, 266, 268

Catacomb founded by, 270

Church of, 262;

Zeno chapel in, mosaics of, 276;

relics in, 262–3;

well in, 263

S. Priscilla, mother of Pudens, Catacomb of, 8, 258, 261 et seq., 266;

antiquity, size, and importance of, 236, 240, 257, 261;

associations of, with S. Peter, 12, 257, 263, 267, 271–3;

baptistery in, 236;

Basilica of S. Sylvester over, 257, 273;

called “ad Nymphas,” and why, 272;

chief glory of, 257;

De Rossi on, 262;

evidence of discoveries in, on tradition of S. Peter as founder of Roman Church, 8, 15, 16, 42, 267, 268, 271;

founders of, 270;

galleries and other features of, 267 et seq.;

inscriptions in, 267, 268, 271;

notable interments in, 266, 302

Church of, 262

Original tomb of, 268

S. Processus and S. Martinianus, catacomb of, 234;

story of, 234

S. Protus, martyr, tomb of, 275

S. Pudentiana (see also supra, S. Prassedis), burial-place of, 263, 264, 266, 268;

sarcophagus of, 263

Church of, 262;

antiquity and interest of, 263 et seq.

Part founder of S. Priscilla’s catacomb, 270

S. Quirinus, Crypt of, 247;

history of, ib.

S. Riquier, “syllogæ” in library of, 230

S. Sebastian (ad Catacombas), catacomb of, 237, 242, 243–4;

memories of SS. Peter and Paul connected with, 273;

story of, 244;

translation of, 244

S. Sennen, burial-place of, 235, 236

S. Silanus, burial-places of, 259, 302;

body once stolen, 304;

translation of, 302

S. Silvester in Capite, Church, body of S. Hippolytus translated to, 254

S. Simferosa, tomb of, 250

S. Soteris, virgin, martyr, catacomb of, 239, 242, 243, 246

S. Stephen, protomartyr, 110;

and S. Laurence, parallel positions of, 234

S. Suzanna, church of, 302;

final resting-place of S. Felicitas, 259 & n. 1

S. Sylvester, Pope, Basilica erected by, 266 & n. 1;

notoriety of, 272;

Popes buried in, 272–4;

saintly remains in, 213, 266 & n. 1, 272, 302–3;

site of, 257, 266 & n. 1, 270, 272, 273

Burial-place of, 272

S. Symphorosa, burial-place of, 212

S. Tertullinus, catacomb of, 249

S. Thekla, catacomb of, 236, 239

S. Thomas Aquinas, 319 n. 1

S. Tiburtius, martyr, Basilica of, 247;

relation of, to S. Cecilia, 290;

tomb of, 293 n. 1, 295

S. Urban, martyr, tomb of, 242–3

S. Urbanus, Bishop (not of Rome), and S. Cecilia, 290, 296

S. Valentinus, martyr, 262;

catacomb of, 214, 275–6;

basilica in, 276

S. Valerianus, husband of S. Cecilia, martyr, 290, 292, 294 n. 1;

tomb of, 242, 247, 293 n. 1, 295

S. Vitale, a slave-martyr, Church of, Ravenna, 136 n. 1

S. Vitalis, son of S. Felicitas, tomb of, 259, 303

S. Zeno, Basilica of, 247;

burial-place of, 262, 276;

Chapel of, 276;

treasures in, 262–3

Saintly persons, power of, over wild creatures, 176 & n. 1

Saints, Communion of, Early Christian view on, 307, 309–10

Dead, invocation of, and prayers of, besought, Early Christian attitude as to, 309–10, 311, 312 & n. 1, 321–2

Desire for burial near, S. Augustine on, 312 n. 1, 321–2

Salii, College of, M. Aurelius, a member, 95

Salzburg Itinerary cited, 211, 212, 214, 242–3, 302, 303;

date of, 227

Samuel, prophet, and the Schools of the Prophets, 349

Sanhedrim, the Great, authority of, successors in, after Dispersion, 357, 360

Sanhedrim treatise, in Talmud, 343 n. 1

Sarcophagi, Christian, Lateran Museum, and S. Peter’s escape from Prison, 19 n. 1

Sardinia, exiles and martyrs in, 252

Sardis, 187

Saturninus, catacomb of, 258, 260

Schools of Martyrdom, 145;

methods of, 197, 198 & n. 1 et seq.;

writers on, 198 et seq.

of the Prophets, 349

of Teaching, Early Christian

Practical, and Gentle, 101, 145–50

Rigourist, 101, 144–5, 150–2

Scillitan martyrdoms, 94, 208;

Acts of martyrs genuine, 81 n. 1

Scorpiace, by Tertullian, 121 n. 1, a martyrs’ manual, 199;

S. Paul cited in, on Martyrdom, 202, 203 & n. 1

Scribes, the, and their duties, 341, 343 & n. 3, 350, 351, 361

Second Century, congregations of Christians in, locales of, 36

Seligenstadt, SS. Peter and Marcellinus’ bodies at, 249

Selinus, death at, of Trajan, 87

Senate, the, decadence of, 64–5

Seneca, letters by, see under Epistles

Possible reference by, to Nero’s burning of Christians, 29

Sentius Augurinus, a lengthy recital by, 61

Sepphoris, Rabbinic school at, 358 n. 1

Serenus Granianus, Rescript to, of Hadrian, on Christians, 77

Sergius Paulus, 110

Severus,—, Emperor, persecution under, reason for, 194

Severus, Alexander, Emperor, 234, 252;

and the Jews, 333 n. 1;

leniency of, to Christians, 97;

and supposed Christianity of, 147

Septimius (historian), on Nero’s anti-Christian Edict, 32

Sextus Julius (General), operations of, in Judea, 337

Sulpicius, letter to, of Paulinus of Nola, on his slave, 136–7

on destruction of the Temple, 331 & n. 1, 332;

on Titus’s speech against Jewish and Christian religions, 39–40

Sfondrati, Cardinal, finder of the bodies of S. Cecilia, 294 & n. 1, 297;

and of her husband, &c., 295

Shammai, a Rabbi, 366

Shema invocation, 355 n. 1

Shemoth Rabba, treatise, cited, 365

Shepherd (Pastor), The, of Hermas, 136 n. 1;

discussed, 178–9 & n. 1, 180;

reasons of its popularity, 183 n. 1;

theology of, 138, 179, 182–3;

on care of widows, &c., 126;

on Christ’s Atonement, 116;

on Christian charity, 124 & n. 1, 125;

on hospitality, 128;

on the martyrs and the recusants, 36, 37;

on numbers of Christians, 104;

on persecutions, 180–4;

on progress of Christianity, 107;

on rich Christians, 111

Sicarii, the, 330

Sick, the, care of, by Early Church, 126–7

Side, 188 & n. 1

Sidonius, Apollinaris, family, career, and writings of, 64, 65–7, 68

Simon the Just, 339

Simon Magus in Rome, 11

Sinai, 365

Siricius, Pope, Basilicas built and adorned by, &c., 235, 241, 263, 278;

burial-place of, 272

Sixtus I, Pope and martyr, 247;

burial-place of, 243, 287

Sixtus II, Pope, deacons of, martyred, 302;

and S. Laurence, 250, 254

Sixtus III, Basilica built by, to S. Laurence, 250;

work of, at S. Cecilia’s crypt, 292

Sixtus V, Pope, Church of S. Suzanna built for, 259 n. 1

Slavery, England’s crusade against, Lecky on, 135 n. 1

Slaves, Christian, freed by advice of Pope Pius I, 264;

position and condition of, 134 et seq.

Slaves, numbers of, Roman Empire, first two centuries, Ozanam on, 135 n. 2

Smyrna, 173

Social life and pleasures, difficulties in, of Early Christians, 141

Status of Early Christians, literary testimony to its range, 110–12

Solomon, King, 352

Soter, Bishop or Pope of Rome, 10, 131;

on numbers of Christians at Rome, 104 & n. 2, 106, 107

Spartianus, historian, 75

Stanley, Dean, on a child’s Epitaph in the Abbey, 309;

on early Christianity, 318 n. 2, 319 & n. 1;

on the witness of the Catacombs to the life of the Early Church, 219–20

Statius, 59 n. 1

Stephen, Bishop or Pope of Rome, 131

Suetonius, history by, 60, 62, 63, 269;

on Christians accused of firing Rome, 27;

on Domitian’s persecutions, 41;

on Jewish expulsion from Rome, and its cause, 18;

on Neronic persecution, 62;

on Vespasian’s attitude to Christians, 40

Sura, Rabbinic School at, 326, 327, 344, 346, 358 n. 1, 359, 373;

founder of, 357 & n. 1

“Syllogæ” of Early Christian Inscriptions, where found, 230

Sylloge Palestina, the, 215

Symmachus, Memmius, and his father’s Letters, 65

Symmachus, Pope, 60 n. 1;

Council held by, 262

Symmachus, Q. Aurelius, career of, and writings (Letters) of, 64–5, 66

Syria, Vespasian’s legions in, 331

Tacitus, History of, 60, 61, 62

Lost Book of, on Titus’s destruction of the Temple, 39, 331 & n. 1, 332

Period of, 63

Pliny’s letter to, 92

on Christianity, progress of, 107;

on Christians accused of firing Rome, 27;

on Christians of high station, 110;

on conversion of Pomponia Græcina, 245;

on numbers of Christians, 103, 107

on Jewish fecundity, 5 n. 1;

on the persecutions, 36, 46 n. 1, 62, 103, 177, 208;

on Roman simplicity, 88

Talmud, the, see also Mishnah and Gemara

Akiba’s work on, 354–6

and the Jew (Book V.), 325 et seq.

Authority of, 368–9

Codification of, workers on, 356–7

Divine inspiration claimed for, 365

History of, traditional, 339–40

Influence of, on Christianity, 326, 327, 348, 370 & n. 1

on the Jews of the Dispersion, 339, 340, 346–7, 353, 368, 372–3

Jewish devotion to, 326, 327, 347, 350, 368–9

Materials, origin and founders of, 348 et seq., 358 n. 1, 360

Meaning of term, 358 n. 1

Object of, 345

Popularity of, cause of, 371

Power of, 346–7

Recensions of, 344, 345, 359, 373

Story of, 365–6

Teaching of, differences in, from that of Christ, 366–8

Method of, 357–60

Spirituality of, 345, 352

on Inspiration of Pentateuch and of the Prophets, 364–5

on Miracles, 365

on Bar-cochab, 336–7;

and on Rabbi Akiba, 355;

on the last war of the Jews, 98, 338 & n. 1;

and on destruction of the Temple, 332

Tannaim, the, 344, 358 n. 1

Targumim, the, 360;

Haggadic pieces in, 373;

excerpts from, 373–5

Tarquinius Priscus, 87

Taylor, Dr., on Rabbinic dicta, 365 n. 1

Teaching and doctrine, Early Christian Assemblies, 113–4;

groundwork of, 115–9;

as met with in the Catacombs, 220, 309 et seq., 312 & n. 1, 315, 316 et seq.

Telesphorus, Pope, burial-place of, 287

Temple, the, of Jerusalem, destruction of, 22, 331–4, 340 et seq., 355, 362, 368;

the end of Mosaism, 341

Stones of Wailing all that is left of, 338

Treasures from, in Rome, 333 & n. 2, 351

Women’s Court in, 380

of Peace, Rome, 333 n. 2

Tenth Legion, at Jerusalem, 332

Tertullian, 151, 204, 315

Rigourism of, 146, 151, 153–4, 179, 182

Silent as to Vespasian, 40 n. 3

Teaching of, 138

Writings of:—

ad Uxor, on Hospitality, 128

Apology of, resemblances between, and Octavius of Minucius Felix, 186

Martyrs’ Manuals, 199

Scorpiace, 121 n. 1;

S. Paul cited in, 202, 203 & n. 1

Treatise on Idolatry, 144 n. 1;

on training for Martyrdom, 203

cited in support of Petrine tradition, 10–11, 13, 14;

on aid to prisoners, 130;

on almsgiving, 120;

on burying the poor, 132, 133;

on Christ with the Kid, 319, 320;

on Christian love, 119;

on highly-placed Christians, 111, 147, 149;

on idol-worship, 144 n. 1;

on insensibility of martyrs to pain, 200;

on numbers of Christians in the second century, 104, 105;

on penalty of being a Christian, 197 & n. 1;

and on enduring hardness, 153–4;

on persecutions, 32, 36, 37, 190–1;

on physical training for martyrdom, 198, 202–3;

on Pliny’s correspondence with Trajan, 45, 46;

and on inconsistencies in Trajan’s Rescript, 55

Testaments of the XII Patriarchs, on Almsgiving, 121

Theban Legion, martyrdom of, legend of, 148 n. 1

Theodelinda, and the Monza Catalogue (q.v.), 214–5, 228, 304

Theodosius, Emperor, 253;

and the Basilica of S. Paul, 238;

Latin writers of his period, 64

Theophitus, Bishop of Antioch, on assemblies, 108–9;

on persecution, 189–90

Thibaritanos, Ad, letter by S. Cyprian, 198 n. 2, 199

Thirty-nine Articles, the, 319 n. 1

Thrason, Catacombs of, 258, 260

Tiber, the, Catacombs beside, Itineraries on, 210–14;

S. Peter’s baptisms in, 11, 14

Tiberias, Rabbinic School at, 326, 327;

method, study, and work at, 344, 346, 357, 358 n. 1

Tibur, Hadrian’s Villa near, 82

Tiburtius, martyr, tomb of, 242

Tigellinus, evil counsel of, to Nero, 27

Tillemont,—, 289;

on the Acts of S. Felicitas, 300;

on the martyrdom of the Theban Legion, 148 n. 1

Titus, Bishop of Crete, Epistle of S. Paul to, on slavery, 135

Titus, Emperor, 85, 325;

persecution under, 172, 173, 174, and see 207

Siege by, of Jerusalem and triumph after, 331–4, 351, 352

Views of, on Jewish and Christian religions, 39

Toleration, advocated by some Early Christians, De Broglie on, 142–3

Torah, the, 330, 341, 351, 352, 370;

additions, directions, explanations made to (see also under Names), 343 & nn. 1 & 2 et seq.

Haggadic notices on, from Palestinian Targum, 373–5

Halachic developments of, 376–7

History of, 339

Inspiration claimed for, 343, 364

Mishnah and Gemara built up on, 361

Post-exilic reverence for, 342 et seq.

Schools devoted to study of (see also Rabbinic Schools), 326

Temple copy of, in Rome, 333 & n.2

Torre Pignatara, tomb of S. Helena at, 249

Trade, difficulties in, of Early Christians, 141

Tradition, rehabilitated by Archæology, 105, 225–6, 230–1, 239–40, 241, 289, 293, 298, 304

on S. Peter as founder of Roman Christianity, 7, 8;

literary and archaeological support to, 8, 9 et seq.

Trajan, Emperor, 110, 164, 171, 172, 182;

attitude to, of Christian historians, 48–9

Characteristics of, 49–50, 55, 85

Death of, and successor, 75

Pliny’s letter to, 27, 32, 35 n. 1, 43, 45 et seq., 56, 103 & n. 2, 177

Pope Gregory the Great’s prayer for, 49

Principles of, as to Christians, 78, 97

Rescript of, in reply to Pliny, 45 et seq., 56, 57, 177;

effect of, 180;

provisions of, 49–50;

publication of, 60 n. 1;

Tertullian’s criticisms on, 55;

views of scholars cited on, 49

Social life of his time, 89

Zealot revolt under, 334

Translation of remains of Martyrs and Saints, 235, 236, 262, 263, 266 & n. 1, 267, 272, 273–4, 292, 298

Trastevere Quarter, Catacombs in, Itineraries on, 210–11

Tridentine Catechism, the, 319 n. 1

Trinity, Blessed, references to, in Catacombs, 316

Triumvirate, proscription of, 56

“Tropæum,” the, probable identification of, 282

Ubaldi, Canon of S. Peter’s, on discoveries during erection of Bernini’s baldachino, 281 & n. 1 et seq.

Uhlhorn,—, views of, on Trajan’s Rescript, 49

Urban VIII, Pope, and the discovery of S. Peter’s sarcophagus, 233 n. 1, 280 et seq.;

epigram on, 280

Urbanus, Bishop (not of Rome), and S. Cecilia, 290

Urbanus, Bishop of Rome, 290

Uxor, Ad, by Tertullian, 128

Valentinian ii, Emperor, and the Basilica of S. Paul, 238

Valentinus, the Gnostic, 112 n. 1

Valerian, Emperor, favour shown by, to Christians, 147;

persecution under, 243, 247, 256, 275

Vatican Basilica, the, 293

Hill, Cemetery on, 243, 272–3;

beginning of, 280, 285, 286;

“Itinerary” on, 210;

rediscovery of, 280

Papal tombs and Crypt of, 234, 236–7, 242, 244, 245 et seq.;

Popes buried in, 16, 233, 273, 283, 284, 286–7

S. Peter’s tomb in, 16, 232, 233, 237

Gardens on, martyrdoms in, 28, 29, 30, 32;

site of S. Peter’s death, 267

Vatican Hill, “Memoriæ” of Apostles on, 11, 233

Vergil, poems by, 87, 88, 91;

teaching of, 88, 95

Verus, son of Ælius Verus, adopted by Antoninus Pius, 83

Vespasian, Emperor, 33;

attitude of, to Christianity, 39–40 & nn., 207;

difficulties with the Jews, 92

Persecution under, 172, 173, 174

Roman characteristics of, 85

Siege by, of Jerusalem, 330–1

Temple of Peace built by, 333 n. 2

Triumph of, 333

Vestibule of Domitilla Cemetery, 240

Via Appia, catacombs of, 211–12, 234, 237, 242 et seq., 301

Ardeatina, catacombs of, 211, 239–42;

excavations in, value of, to history, 239–40

Aurelia or Aurelia Vetus, catacombs along, 210–11, 233–5

Flaminia, catacomb of, 214, 275–6

Labicana, catacombs of, 212, 249

Latina, catacombs of, 212, 248–9

Nomentana, catacombs of, 212–3, 255–8

Ostiensis, catacombs on, 211, 236–9, 243

Portuensis, catacombs on, 211, 235–6

Salaria, catacombs of, rediscovery of, 223 & n. 1

Cemetery of S. Priscilla on, 12

Salaria Nova, catacombs of, 213, 258 et seq., 302, 303

Salaria Vetus, catacombs of, 213, 274–5

Tiburtina, catacombs of, 212, 250–5

Vaticana, catacombs of, 210

Victor, Pope, burial-place of, 287

Vienne, martyrdoms at, 201, 208;

persecution at, by M. Aurelius, 94

Vigilius, Pope, burial-place of, 272

Viminal Hill, church on, 262

Vision of S. Flavian, on Insensibility of Martyrs to Pain, 200

Vision, The, of Perpetua, 199

Vitellius, Emperor, 39, 331

“War of Extermination,” the, 338

Wars of the Jews, the three last, 77, 78–9, 80, 325, 329 et seq., 338, 354

Westcott, Bishop, on date of letter to “Diognetus,” 178 n. 1

Westminster Abbey, epitaph of Jane Lister in, 309

Westminster Confession, 319 n. 1

Whepstead, church of S. Parnel at, 278

Widows and orphans, care of Early Church for, 124, 126

William of Malmesbury, Itinerary of, on Roman Catacombs, 210, 211, 213

Authority of, 210, 213, 227

Date of, 227

on S. Cecilia’s tomb, 293;

on S. Felicitas and her sons and their tombs, 303

Wiseman, Cardinal, 263

Women, Christ’s teaching on, and the Talmudic contrasted, 367 & n. 1;

Court of, in the Temple, 380

Worcester, two Saints of, 321

Wordsworth, W., poem of, on S. Cecilia, 294 n. 1

Worship (see also Assemblies, Idol-worship, Incense), in Christian Assemblies, Justin Martyr on, 113–4

Wulphere, King of the Mercians, 279

Xiphilin or Xiphilinus, on Domitian, 41;

on Hadrian, 75

Zealots, Rabbinic masters unsympathetic to, 342, 353, 354;

revolts of, and results, 330–1, 332, 334–5

Zephyrinus, Pope, martyr, 11;

tomb of, 243, 245, 273, 291

Printed by Morrison & Gibb Limited Edinburgh

FOOTNOTES:

Notes in this chapter

Note 1 · A singular and interesting passage of Allard here deserves to be quoted verbatim: “Dans Rome où le celibat est devenu une plaie sociale, où Note 2 · Professor Ramsay in his book, The Church in the Roman Empire, prefers a later date for the composition of the First Epistle of St. Peter thaNote 5 · Histoire ancienne de l’Église, vol. i. p. 61 (4th edition, 1908).Note 6 · It will be noticed that an interesting hypothesis dwelt on by Allard (Histoire des Persécutions, vol. i.) and by other writers has not been Note 2 · Such as the heresies of the Nicolaitans and Cerinthians, and certain of the false Docetic teachings.Note 5 · It is this which makes the vivid picture which the younger Pliny, in his Letter to Trajan, paints of Christian life and influence in a greatNote 6 · See Ramsay, The Church in the Roman Empire, xii. 2.Note 8 · Bishop Lightfoot discusses at some length the great probability of the accuracy of this definite statement of S. Hilary of Poitiers, and decNote 9 · “Domitian loved to be identified with Jupiter, and to be idolized as the Divine Providence in human form; and it is recorded that Caligula, Note 10 · He struck (says the Roman poet), without exciting popular indignation, at the illustrious citizen: “Tempora sævitiæ, claras quibus abstulit Note 3 · Lightfoot well observes (Apostolic Fathers, part ii. vol. i., S. Ignatius, pp. 54–6) that these two famous letters cannot be separated from Note 5 · There is a striking passage, based on Pliny’s reflexions, in Professor Dill’s Roman Society from Nero to Marcus Aurelius, on this longing toNote 6 · It seems most probable that the first nine Books of Pliny’s Letters were put out in “book form” for public use at different periods—and subsNote 7 · Dr. Mackail, Latin Literature, iii. v.Note 9 · We might also cite here the well-known “poetic” epistles of Ovid and Horace.Note 11 · The words which occur in “the address” of the Letters of Ignatius to the Christian congregation in the city of Tralles are remarkable. “The Note 1 · Seventeen of these cities so named are commemorated on extant coins and medals; and this number is largely increased by some writers. These Note 2 · De Champagny, Les Antonins, iii. 1, tersely and well sums up his character: “Il a tous les dons, et toutes les faiblesses, toutes les grandeNote 4 · A certain number of them, however, are by all responsible critics received as absolutely genuine, such as: The Letters relating the MartyrdoNote 6 · No scholar is more definite here than Renan, who certainly cannot be regarded as one who would be likely to dwell with emphasis on testimonyNote 8 · See pp. 189–90 and 200.Note 9 · Bishop Lightfoot has been referred to in this brief summary of the position of Christians during these two great reigns. This careful and exNote 10 · This especially refers to the ancient song of the Arval Brotherhood, of which college Marcus was also a member.Note 2 · Further details of Pliny’s report to the Emperor Trajan upon the numbers of Christians in his province will be found above, Book I. pp. 49–6Note 4 · Clement of Rome, Epist. ad Cor. vi.Note 5 · The quotation referred to is from the so-called 2nd Epistle of Clement of Rome (section 2), which Harnack attributes to Soter, bishop of RomNote 7 · Tertullian, Apologeticus, 1.Note 11 · Professor Harnack, Mission and Expansion of Christianity, book iv. chap. iii. sec. 14.Note 19 · Harnack well observes that among Clement of Alexandria’s writings, the Pædagogus evidently assumes that the Church for which its teaching waNote 20 · The more eminent of the Gnostic teachers who in the first instance separated themselves from the Christian congregations, as far as we can jNote 21 · This is strikingly put by F. W. Myers in his poem “S. Paul”: “This hath he done and shall we not adore Him? This shall He do and can we stiNote 22 · The more notable of the Atonement prophecy passages in Isaiah were: “Surely He hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows.... He was wouNote 24 · If the experiment of “communism” in the early Christian Church was ever tried, it was in the congregation of Jerusalem, and there it is cleaNote 25 · The writer here evidently means “atones for a multitude of our own sins”; so Tertullian, Scorpiace, 6 (see Bishop Lightfoot, Clement of RomeNote 27 · See Archbishop Benson, Cyprian, vi. 1.Note 28 · The Emperor Julian’s well-known Letter to Arsacius is a good example. It is clear that charity did not restrict itself to the “Household of Note 29 · The last clause is a very important one. It tells us that to the collections made in the assembly for the poor and needy, even the poorest aNote 30 · Archbishop Benson happily paraphrases Cyprian’s words thus: Noblesse oblige. S. Cyprian, vi. 1, 2.Note 32 · Slavery was not authoritatively condemned until the year of grace 1807. Lecky characterizes the action of Christian England here in the follNote 33 · Ozanam estimates the numbers of slaves in the first and second centuries of our era as amounting to half the population of the Empire. The eNote 35 · Hermas, the author of the famous Shepherd, belonged to the slave class. The Roman Bishop Pius, A.D. 142–157, was the brother of Hermas. The Note 38 · See, for instance, Tert. De Idolat. viii., where the various trades connected with idols and temples are enumerated.Note 40 · See Renan, Marc-Aurèle, chap. xxii.Note 41 · Some put this graffito a little later, perhaps in the days of Alexander Severus, A.D. 222–35.Note 42 · The well-known recital of the martyrdom of S. Maurice and of the Theban Legion, whether it be accepted as absolutely genuine or not, is an aNote 43 · The edicts favourable to Christianity were quietly received, even approved, in many places warmly welcomed; and vast and ever increasing numNote 44 · See Lecky, Hist. of Morals, chap. iii.Note 45 · Prudentius does not stand alone as voicing the opinions of the people. A contemporary of his—Paulinus of Nola—although far behind PrudentiusNote 4 · On “the Mortality,” i.e. the plague of Alexandria, 20–24.Note 5 · This Rutilius was a Gallic gentleman of high position who had filled important offices at Rome, and had become a Senator. His undisguised opNote 1 · The testimony of the Roman catacombs here is also very weighty. See Book III. part iii., where the numbers of martyrs and confessors buried Note 2 · In this Third Book, where the question of the persecutions to which the early Christian Church was subjected is discussed, the period especiNote 3 · This early and usually accepted date, circa 65–7, seems the more probably correct. It is the traditional date, and generally fits in with thNote 4 · The reference here is to pagan Rome, as “the woman drunken with blood”; so Mommsen quoted by Ramsay, who dwells on the fact that the death oNote 5 · “The mind of the writer is practically restricted to the Roman world.... He thinks like a Roman that ‘genus humanum’ is the Roman world. TheNote 6 · So called from the position it holds between the longer recension of the “ten Letters,” three of which are put aside as later compilations, Note 8 · See Part I. section 1, chap. iii. in the author’s work, The Golden Age of the Church, entitled, “The Monks and the Animal World,” where thisNote 11 · The date circa A.D. 117 is suggested by Bishop Westcott, and Bishop Lightfoot generally agrees in placing the writing about this time. Some Note 12 · So Harnack; Duchesne, in his Histoire ancienne de l’Église, vol. i. p. 225 (published 1908), generally adopts Harnack’s conclusions respectiNote 13 · What Hermas wrote specially of Rome, no doubt in a very large degree was the state of things in the provinces of the Empire. This is clear fNote 15 · Side was a maritime town of Pamphylia. Philip wrote in the early part of the fifth century.Note 2 · “It is not lawful to be you,” but it is impossible to render in English the full force of this epigrammatic saying of Tertullian.Note 3 · De Boissier, the Academician, specially calls attention to it as a somewhat novel piece of very early ecclesiastical history, and he refers Note 4 · S. Cyprian, Epist. lxvi. ad Thibaritanos.Note 5 · A very ancient and probably an authoritative reading. When in the text the language of didactic calmness passes suddenly into the language oNote 7 · Quoted in the Scorpiace of Tertullian, and much more from S. Paul to the same point.Note 1 · Although the usual date given for this last attack on Christianity is a few months after the death of the Emperor Marcus. There is no doubt Note 5 · Allard translates these lines: “Si vous voulez savoir, ici reposent amoncelés les ossements d’un grand nombre des saints; ces vénérables tomNote 1 · It was in the year of grace 1578 that some workmen digging out sand in a vineyard about a mile from Rome on the Via Salaria came upon the gaNote 3 · Several additional discoveries of historic crypts have been made since this computation was made.Note 4 · Other tombs of the famous martyr-sons of Felicitas have since been identified, and much knowledge of this incident in early Christian historNote 5 · The tomb of S. Peter and its surroundings will be described at length in Appendix II., which follows the section treating of the “Catacombs,Note 7 · The story of the tomb of S. Cecilia and her crypt is told in detail in the section immediately succeeding this general sketch of the catacomNote 9 · Further details respecting the identification of this once famous shrine will be found below on pp. 301–2.Note 10 · The Church of S. Suzanna has a striking history. It was rebuilt by Maderno for Sixtus V, on the site of an ancient church or oratory erectedNote 11 · In two of the MSS. of the second edition or Recension of the Liber Pontificalis under the account of Pope Pius I (A.D. 142–57), we find the Note 12 · See on p. 272, where details are given of the translation of these confessors and of certain of the bishops of Rome originally interred in tNote 1 · The important and interesting details which follow here have been largely taken from the chapter which treats of Ubaldi’s Memoir by Mr. BarnNote 1 · The text of the Liber Pontificalis mentions the Cemetery of Prætextatus as the site of the lost tomb. It was there where her husband ValeriaNote 2 · The writer of this book simply tells the story as it has been handed down and often repeated. From the clear testimony of the responsible anNote 3 · A “luminare” (plural “luminaria”) was a shaft communicating with the surface of the ground which admitted light and air. Many of these were Note 5 · The eldest of the “seven” was the well-known S. Januarius.Note 6 · The manner of death of this illustrious family of Christian martyrs was as follows, as far as we can gather from the concise notices in the Note 7 · Agapitus is so spelt in the rough graffite here referred to.Note 1 · S. Augustine in the first quarter of the fifth century, circa A.D. 421, in reply to a question addressed to him by S. Paulinus of Nola, discNote 2 · The initial letters of the Redeemer’s names and principal titles (in Greek) made up the word ἰχθύς or fish. Thus: IHϹΟΥϹ = Jesus. ΧΡΙϹΤΟϹ = Note 3 · See especially Heb. xiii. 20; 1 Pet. ii. 25–v. 4; S. Luke, xv. 4, 7, and above all S. John x. 11, 16.Note 4 · Dean Stanley of Westminster, Christian Institutions, chaps. xiii., xiv.Note 5 · Dean Stanley (Christian Institutions) calls attention to the curious fact that the popular religion of the first two centuries, as shown in Note 1 · Mommsen, Renan, and Ramsay without hesitation ascribe the statement quoted here as taken by Sulpicius Severus (fourth century) from the lostNote 3 · The arch was completed by Domitian after the death of Titus.Note 4 · The golden relics were deposited in the Temple of Peace, which Vespasian built opposite the Palatine; it was dedicated A.D. 75. The temple iNote 5 · The authorities for the details of this terrible and protracted war are Dion Cassius and the notices in the Talmud, especially in the treatiNote 6 · But these numbers, as we have stated, although derived from contemporary authorities, are evidently very much exaggerated.Note 7 · What the Mishnah was will be explained below (p. 358), where a general description of the Talmud is given.Note 8 · These singular assertions will be found in the Mishnah, in the Talmudic treatises of the Sanhedrim and the Baba-Bathra.Note 9 · Halachah signifies literally custom, practice, rule. The term is further explained and illustrated in the following chapter on the “ContentsNote 10 · These Scribes, their position and means of livelihood, are discussed more fully below on p. 350.Note 11 · The Mishnah and the Gemara are explained in detail below on p. 358.Note 14 · At the close of this Fifth Book is a short general description of “Haggadah.” See, too, in the Appendix for a further description of HaggadaNote 15 · Of Akiba, the Mishnah tells us, as he was in his last agonies, while his flesh was being torn with combs of iron, he kept repeating the wordNote 18 · For a full definition of these two famous terms Mishnah and Gemara, see below, p. 358, where the terms in question are explained at some lenNote 19 · The Palestinian Gemara was closed nearly a century and a half before the Babylonian Gemara was completed.Note 20 · The Rabbinic school of Sura was founded by Rab, one of the most important pupils of R. Judah Ha-Nasi (Rabbi).Note 21 · Mishnah.—A noun formed from the verb “shanah,” to repeat. In post-Biblical Hebrew the verb “shanah” acquired the special meaning of “to teacNote 22 · R. Akiba (early second century) in the Mishnah treatise “Pirke Aboth” used to say, “Massorah is a fence to the Torah.” This has been generalNote 23 · “It is evident that some of the ‘dicta’ of the Rabbis, such as, for instance, the above-quoted passages, are not intended to be taken literaNote 24 · “For when they shall rise from the dead [men and women are both alluded to] ... they are as the angels which are in heaven” (S. Mark xii. 25Note 25 · Renan recognizes the service rendered by the Talmudical Rabbis to Christianity, but while acknowledging this, curiously limits it to the preNote 26 · While it is generally acknowledged that the decisions arrived at in connection with the Law of Moses termed “Halachah” were transmitted oral
Explore with AITake your curiosity a little further.

Reading settings