← Table of contents
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXXIV, No. 6, June 1849

FOR AND AGAINST.

Reading edition

FOUND AMONG THE PAPERS OF THE LATE

———

WALTER HERRIES, ESQ.

———

I don’t think I ever really loved but once; fancies I have had, and fond ones, too; but now when the cold, gray twilight of age is dimming the visions of the past, memory still recalls, with wonderful power, one bright face from the fair picture gallery of my early loves—the face of Edla Fane, the schoolmaster’s daughter. Beautiful she was not, and yet I loved her, as I learned too late. She seemed to bind me by some spell of witchery that I could not withstand, and yet against which I rebelled, because it appealed not to my outer senses. I understand it now; she bound me by the might of a lofty, spiritual love; and I blindly cast aside that gem of countless price to grasp the dross of earth.

High-toned, and pure-minded, tender, and confiding as a child, yet with a sweet womanly pride, and withal a dash of quiet humor, Edla Fane kept me vacillating near her for a many months. At one time feeling as though I could fall at her feet and worship her, at another fearing I had expressed too much, and withdrawing in cold reserve.

One evening a cold mood came over me; I feared I had committed myself in my ardent protestations to Edla, and now spoke with the calmness of friendship or platonic affection. She listened with a slight curve of her expressive lip, and assented to my proposal of affectionate friendship so readily, that my self-love was aroused, and with characteristic variableness my feelings gained immediate force again. But Edla remained unmoved. The next day I received the following lines in a blank envelope.

You say that you love me, yet are not a lover;

As you know not yourself what it is you intend;

And right sorry are you, I have chanced to discover,

That you’re less than a lover, and more than a friend!

For you know you’re a ranger,

And think there is danger,

That when you are weary, and wish to depart,

I, believing you true,

May have learned to love you,

And you’ll leave me all lonely, without any heart!

You have cautioned me well, and have done but your duty;

The proverb says truly, “Forearmed, when forewarned,”

And though I can boast not of wealth or of beauty,

I yield not one feeling, I think would be scorned.

When a lover I find

Who knows his own mind!

I will give up my heart in return for his vow;

I must have all or none,

Must be wooed to be won—

And now I’ll advise you, if you will allow.

You at once must restrain all expression of feeling,

Not only of words, but of glances and sighs,

Lest by some odd mischance the strange secret revealing,

Your friendship should prove to be—“love in disguise!”

Remember, take care,

I bid you beware,

For Cupid’s a sly, little mischievous elf,

When you think your heart free

He may bind it to me,

And make you prove constant in spite of yourself.

Then, when I have plighted my vows to another,

You will sue for one glimpse of old feeling in vain;

For when once the bright flame of affection you smother,

You never can kindle its brilliance again;

I’ll turn proudly away,

And will calmly say nay,

(While I look on you coldly, not seeming to see,)

I esteem, and admire,

That is all you desire—

Think well of me always, but never love me!

Provoking! thus to have my own words turned against me, at the close of these unexpected verses. I saw Edla frequently after this; but my evanescent vows, were never after tolerated even for a moment, and thus, when too late, her prophecy was fulfilled—I loved her. But Edla Fane is now a happy wife and mother, and I—a Bachelor.

Explore with AITake your curiosity a little further.

Reading settings