Part 4 / Book 3 — CHAPTER XIV.
Reading edition
PLACES OF CRIMINATION AND PURGATION.
One, from the removal of ill opinion in the hearer, imprinted in him by the adversary or otherwise.
Another from this: that the thing done is not hurtful, or not to him, or not so much, or not unjust, or not great, or not dishonourable.
A third from the recompense: as, I did him harm, but withal I did him honour.
A fourth from the excuse; as, It was error, mischance, or constraint.
A fifth from the intention; as, One thing was done, another meant.
A sixth from the comprehension of the accuser; as, What I have done, the accuser has done the same, or his father, kinsman, or friend.
A seventh from the comprehension of those that are in reputation; as, What I did, such and such have done the same, who nevertheless are good men.
An eighth from comparison with such as have been falsely accused or wrongfully suspected, and nevertheless found upright.
A ninth from recrimination; as, The accuser is a man of ill life, and therefore not to be believed.
A tenth from that the judgment belongs to another place, or time; as, I have already answered, or am to answer elsewhere to this matter.
An eleventh from crimination of the crimination: as, It serves only to pervert judgment.
A twelfth, which is common both to crimination and purgation, and is taken from some sign; as, Teucer is not to be believed, because his mother was Priam’s sister. On the other side, Teucer is to be believed, because his father was Priam’s enemy.
504A thirteenth, proper to crimination only, from praise and dispraise mixed; as, to praise small things, and blame great ones; or to praise in many words, and blame with effectual ones; or to praise many things that are good, and then add one evil, but a great one.
A fourteenth, common both to crimination and purgation, is taken from the interpretation of the fact. For he that purgeth himself, interpreteth the fact always in the best sense; and he that criminates, always in the worst; as when Ulysses said, Diomedes chose him for his companion, as the most able of the Grecians, to aid him in his exploit: but his adversary said, he chose him for his cowardice, as the most unlikely to share with him in the honour.