Chapter XXVI

Conclusion—Retribution.

A few days later, and the last act in this sad drama of crime was performed. The four youthful criminals were arraigned for trial before a conscientious judge, and by a jury composed of gentlemen, many of whom were intimately acquainted with two of the accused, Eugene Pearson and Dr. Johnson, both of whom, it will be remembered, were born and reared in the little town of Geneva. As may be imagined, the trial attracted universal attention in that section of the country, and on the day that the court was convened, the town was filled with people from all the surrounding districts, who came to witness the important proceedings. Long before the hour fixed for the commencement of the trial, the court-room was crowded to suffocation by the eager multitude, who had come from far and near, for the purpose of being present at this unusual judicial investigation. Many were actuated only by the promptings of idle curiosity, and regarded the trial somewhat in the light of a diverting exhibition, for which no admission fee was charged; others, from a stern sense of justice, came to view a trial in which crime was to be punished, and the law in all its majesty was to be invoked for the protection of the honor of society, and the property of the individual. There was yet another class, who came from the impulses of love and sympathy and friendship—some who were linked to the unfortunate criminals by the ties of family and blood, and some who had known and esteemed them ere their hearts had been hardened, and before the wiles of the tempter had lured them from the paths of honor and virtue. There were present also the gray-haired father and mother of Eugene Pearson, broken and bowed with the grief and shame which had been brought upon them by the crimes of their beloved son; the aged parents of Dr. Johnson, who had come to witness, with saddened hearts, the doom of their darling boy; the young wife of Newton Edwards, who in the moment of her husband's ruin had, with true womanly devotion, forgotten his past acts of cruelty and harshness, and now, with aching heart and tear-stained eyes, was waiting, with fear and trembling, to hear the dreaded judgment pronounced upon the man whom she had sworn to "love and cherish" through "good and evil report."

Since his incarceration she had been a constant visitor to his cell, and by her love and sympathy had sought to uphold the fallen man in the dark hours of his shame and disgrace. Here also was the aged father of Thomas Duncan, the only friend whom the young man had in all that vast assembly. Though his face was stern and immovable, yet the quivering of the lips and the nervous trembling of the wrinkled hands told too plainly that he too was suffering beyond expression in the sorrow that had been wrought by the boy who in his early years had been his pride and joy.

When the judge had taken his seat, and the door opened to admit the four youthful prisoners, all eyes were turned upon them. Slowly and with downcast eyes they entered the chamber of justice, and amid an awe-like stillness that pervaded the room, took their seats in the prisoners' dock. In spite of all that had transpired, and with the full conviction that these youthful offenders richly merited whatever judgment they were to receive, there was not one in that entire audience, whose heart did not throb with sympathy for the aged parents and relatives of the accused, and even for the culprits themselves in this, the dreadful hour of their humiliation and grief.

The trial was not a protracted one. A jury was speedily empaneled, the low, stern tones of the judge were heard in timely admonition, and the prosecution was commenced. Upon the prisoners being asked to plead to the indictments which had been prepared against them, Mr. Kirkman, a prominent attorney of Geneva, who had been retained to defend the unfortunate young men, arose, and in impressive tones entered a plea of guilty. With the keen perceptions of a true lawyer, he felt that the proofs were too strong to be overcome, and that to attempt to set up any technical defense would only result in greater hardships to his clients. He, however, made an eloquent and touching appeal for the exercise of judicial clemency. He referred in feeling terms to the youth of the prisoners, to the groups of weeping and stricken relatives, whose prayerful hearts were echoing his appeals. He urged that the evidences of sincere repentance had been manifested by all of the prisoners, and that, as this had been their first offense, the exercise of gentle mercy would be both grand and productive of good results.

His words were not lost even upon the prosecuting attorney, and when Mr. Kirkman had concluded, that gentleman arose, and in a few words echoed the sentiments of the attorney for the defense. He also expressed the conviction that, while justice called loudly for sentence, yet there were elements in this case in which the wisest judgment would be that which partook of the qualities of mercy.

At the conclusion of this request, the judge, with a delicate regard for the tender feelings of the assembled relatives, ordered an adjournment of the court, in order that he might take the merits of the case under advisement, and to enable him to administer such sentence, as, in his best judgment, was demanded under the circumstances. Slowly the immense audience dispersed, and for a few moments the prisoners were allowed to converse with their weeping friends, after which they were again conducted to their cells to await the action of the court.

A few days later they were brought quietly before the judge and their sentences were pronounced. Dr. Johnson, owing to the existence of a doubt as to his complicity in the robbery, was condemned to four years' imprisonment on the charge of forgery, while Newton Edwards, Eugene Pearson, and Thomas Duncan were each sentenced to an imprisonment of six years on the indictment for burglary.

Thus ended this important case, and the action of the court received the almost universal approbation of the community, while the relatives and nearest friends of the prisoners were compelled to acknowledge its fairness and justice.

But little remains to be told. The prisoners were soon conducted to the state prison, and a short time afterward, having occasion to visit that institution, I saw them again. They all bore evidences of the most acute remorse and contrition, and their life in prison had produced serious effects upon their robust persons. Far different was their lot now, to the free and happy existence which had once been theirs. Eugene Pearson, the dapper young gentleman, was put at hard labor in the stone-cutting department; Johnson, the dentist, was assigned to the machine shop, while Edwards and Duncan were working in the shoe-making department. Day after day the weary labor was performed, and night after night the gloom of the prison cell enshrouds them. Weeks will roll into months and the months will stretch into weary years, ere they will breathe the sweet air of liberty again. Within the frowning walls of the prison, they are paying the heavy penalty for their crime, and here we must leave them, in the earnest and sincere hope that true repentance may come to them, and that when their term of servitude is ended, they may come forth, filled with resolves to live down the stain upon their characters, and by upright and honorable lives to redeem and obliterate the dark and painful past. That "judgment overcometh crime," has been fully proven in the lives of these men, and trusting in the future to redeem the past, we leave them to the burdens and the solitude to which they have brought themselves.

THE END.

1883

G.W. Carleton & Co

NEW BOOKS

AND NEW EDITIONS,

RECENTLY ISSUED BY

G. W. Carleton & Co., Publishers,

Madison Square, New York.

The Publishers, on receipt of price, send any book on this Catalogue by mail, postage free. All handsomely bound in cloth, with gilt backs suitable for libraries.

Mary J. Holmes' Works.

Tempest and Sunshine.$1 50Darkness and Daylight.$1 50

English Orphans.1 50 Hugh Worthington.1 50

Homestead on the Hillside.1 50 Cameron Pride.1 50

'Lena Rivers.1 50 Rose Mather.1 50

Meadow Brook.1 50 Ethelyn's Mistake.1 50

Dora Deane.1 50 Millbank.1 50

Cousin Maude.1 50 Edna Browning.1 50

Marian Grey.1 50 West Lawn.1 50

Edith Lyle.1 50 Mildred.1 50

Daisy Thornton.1 50 Forrest House.1 50

Chateau D'Or. (New)1 50 Madeline. (New)1 50

Marion Harland's Works.

Alone.$1 50Sunnybank.$1 50

Hidden Path.1 50Husbands and Homes.1 50

Moss Side.1 50Ruby's Husband.1 50

Nemesis.1 50Phemie's Temptation.1 50

Miriam.1 50The Empty Heart.1 50

At Last.1 50Jessamine.1 50

Helen Gardner.1 50From My Youth Up.1 50

True as Steel. (New)1 50My Little Love.1 50

Charles Dickens—15 Vols.—"Carleton's Edition."

Pickwick, and Catalogue.$1 50David Copperfield.$1 50

Dombey and Son.1 50Nicholas Nickleby.1 50

Bleak House.1 50Little Dorrit.1 50

Martin Chuzzlewit.1 50Our Mutual Friend.1 50

Barnaby Rudge—Edwin Drood.1 50Curiosity Shop—Miscellaneous.1 50

Child's England—Miscellaneous.1 50Sketches by Boz—Hard Times.1 50

Christmas Books—Two Cities.1 50Great Expectations—Italy.1 50

Oliver Twist—Uncommercial.1 50

Sets of Dickens' Complete Works, in 15 vols.—[elegant half calf. bindings].50 00

Augusta J. Evans' Novels.

Beulah.$1 75St. Elmo.$2 00

Macaria.1 75Vashti.2 00

Inez.1 75Infelice. (New)2 00

May Agnes Fleming's Novels.

Guy Earlscourt's Wife.$1 50Heir of Charlton.$1 50

A Wonderful Woman.1 50Carried by Storm.1 50

A Terrible Secret.1 50Lost for a Woman.1 50

A Mad Marriage.1 50A Wife's Tragedy.1 50

Norine's Revenge.1 50A Changed Heart.1 50

One Night's Mystery.1 50Pride and Passion.1 50

Kate Danton.1 50Sharing Her Crime.1 50

Silent and True.1 50A Wronged Wife. (New).1 50

Allan Pinkerton's Works.

Expressmen and Detectives.$1 50Gypsies and Detectives.$1 50

Mollie Maguires and Detectives.1 50Spiritualists and Detectives.1 50

Somnambulists and Detectives.1 50Model Town and Detectives.1 50

Claude Melnotte and Detectives.1 50Strikers, Communists, etc.1 50

Criminal Reminiscences, etc.1 50Mississippi Outlaws, etc.1 50

Rail-Road Forger, etc.1 50Bucholz and Detectives.1 50

Bank Robbers and Detectives.1 50

Bertha Clay's Novels.

Thrown on the World.$1 50A Woman's Temptation.1 50

A Bitter Atonement.1 50Repented at Leisure.1 50

Love Works Wonders.1 50Between Two Loves.1 50

Evelyn's Folly.1 50Lady Damer's Secret.1 50

Under a Shadow. (New).1 50A Struggle for a Ring. (New).1 50

"New York Weekly" Series.

Brownie's Triumph—Sheldon$1 50Curse of Everleigh—Pierce.$1 50

The Forsaken Bride. do.1 50Peerless Cathleen—Agnew.1 50

Earle Wayne's Nobility. do.1 50Faithful Margaret—Ashmore.1 50

Lost, A Pearle— do. (New)1 50Nick Whiffles—Robinson.1 50

A New Book. do.1 50Grinder Papers—Dallas.1 50

His Other Wife—Ashleigh.1 50Lady Leonora—Conklin.1 50

Miriam Coles Harris' Novels.

Rutledge.$1 50The Sutherlands.$1 50

Frank Warrington.1 50St. Philips.1 50

Louie's Last Term, St. Mary's.1 50Round Hearts for Children.1 50

A Perfect Adonis.1 50Richard Vandermarck.1 50

Missy. (New).1 50Happy-Go-Lucky.1 50

A. S. Roe's Select Stories.

True to the Last.$1 50A Long Look Ahead.$1 50

The Star and the Cloud.1 50I've Been Thinking.1 50

How Could He Help it?1 50To Love and to be Loved.1 50

Julie P. Smith's Novels.

Widow Goldsmith's Daughter.$1 50The Widower.$1 50

Chris and Otho.1 50The Married Belle.1 50

Ten Old Maids.1 50Courting and Farming.1 50

His Young Wife.1 50Kiss and be Friends.1 50

Lucy.1 50Blossom Bud. (New).1 50

Artemas Ward.

Complete Comic Writings—With Biography, Portrait and 50 illustrations.$1 50

The Game of Whist.

Pole on Whist—The English standard work. With the "Portland Rules".$ 75

Victor Hugo's Great Novel.

Les Miserables—Translated from the French. The only complete edition. $1 50

Mrs. Hill's Cook Book.

Mrs. A. P. Hill's New Southern Cookery Book, and domestic receipts. $2 00

Carleton's Popular Quotations.

Carleton's New Hand-Book—Familiar Quotations, with their authorship. $1 50

Carleton's Classical Dictionary—Condensed Mythology for popular use. 75

Celia E. Gardner's Novels.

Stolen Waters. (In verse).$1 50Tested.$1 50

Broken Dreams. do.1 50Rich Medway.1 50

Compensation. do.1 50A Woman's Wiles.1 50

A Twisted Skein. do.1 50Terrace Roses.1 50

Captain Mayne Reid's Works.

The Scalp Hunters$1 50The White Chief$1 50

The Rifle Rangers1 50The Tiger Hunter1 50

The War Trait1 50The Hunter's Feast1 50

The Wood Rangers1 50Wild Life1 50

The Wild Huntress1 50Osceola, the Seminole1 50

Hand-Books of Society.

The Habits of Good Society—The nice points of taste and good manners$1 00

The Art of Conversation—For those who wish to be agreeable talkers1 00

The Arts of Writing, Reading and Speaking—For Self-Improvement1 00

New Diamond Edition—The above 3 books bound in one volume—complete1 50

Josh Billings.

His Complete Writings—With Biography, Steel Portrait, and 100 Illustrations$2 00

Old Probability—Ten Comic Alminax, 1870 to 1879. Bound in one volume1 50

Charles Dickens.

Child's History of England—With Historical Illustrations for School use$ 75

Parlor Table Album of Dickens' Illustrations—With descriptive text2 50

Lord Bateman Ballad—Notes by Dickens; Pictures by Cruikshank25

Annie Edwardes' Novels.

Stephen Lawrence$ 75Ought We to Visit Her$ 75

Susan Fielding75A New Book75

Ernest Renan's French Works.

The Life of Jesus. Translated$1 75The Life of St. Paul. Transl.$1 75

Lives of the Apostles Do.1 75The Bible in India— By Jacolliot2 00

G. W. Carleton.

Our Artist in Cuba, Peru, Spain, and Algiers—150 Caricatures of travel$1 00

M. M. Pomeroy (Brick).

Sense. A serious book$1 50Nonsense. (A comic book)$1 50

Gold Dust. Do.1 50Brick-dust. Do.1 50

Our Saturday Nights1 50Home Harmonies1 50

Miscellaneous Works.

Every-Day Home Advice. For Household and Domestic Affairs$1 50

The Comic Liar. By the Funny Man of the N. Y. Times. With illustrations1 50

The Children's Fairy Geography—With hundreds of beautiful illustrations2 50

Carleton's Popular Readings—Edited by Mrs. Anna Randall Diehl1 50

Laus Veneris, and other Poems—By Algernon Charles Swinburne1 50

Longfellow's Home Life—By Blanche Roosevelt Machetta1 50

Hawk-eyes—A comic book by "The Burlington Hawkeye Man." Illustrated1 50

Redbirds Christmas Story—An Illustrated Juvenile. By Mary J. Holmes50

The Culprit Fay—Joseph Rodman Drake's Poem. With 100 illustrations2 00

L'Assommoir—English Translation from Zola's famous French novel1 00

Parlor Amusements—Games, Tricks, Home Amusements, by Frank Bellew1 00

Love [L'Amour]—English Translation from Michelet's famous French work1 50

Woman [La Femme]—The Sequel to "L'Amour" Do. Do.1 50

Verdant Green—A racy English college Story. With 200 comic illustrations1 50

Why Wife and I Quarreled—Poem by the Author of "Betsey and I are Out"1 00

A Northern Governess at the Sunny South—By Professor J. H. Ingraham1 50

Birds of a Feather Flock Together—By Edward A. Sothern, the actor1 50

West India Pickles—A yacht Cruise in the Tropics. By W. P. Talboys1 50

Yachtman's Primer—Instructions for Amateur Sailors. By Warren50

The Fall of Man—A Darwinian Satire, by author of "New Gospel of Peace."50

The Cronicles of Gotham—A New York Satire. Do. Do.25

Ladies and Gentlemen's Etiquette Book of the best Fashionable Society1 00

Love and Marriage—A book for young people. By Frederick Saunders1 00

Under the Rose—A Capital book, by the author of "East Lynne."1 00

So Dear a Dream—A novel by Miss Grant, author of "The Sun Maid."1 00

Give me thine Heart—A capital new domestic Love Story by Roe1 00

Meeting Her Fate—A charming novel by the author of "Aurora Floyd."1 00

Faithful to the End—A delightful domestic novel by Roe1 00

Delicate Ground—A powerful new novel by Mrs. Annie Edwardes1 00

Miscellaneous Works.

Dawn to Noon—By Violet Fane$1 50Don Quixote—Illustrated$1 00

Constance's Fate—Do.1 50Arabian Nights—Do.1 00

French Love Songs—Translated50Robinson Crusoe Do1 00

A Bad Boy's First Reader10Swiss Family Robinson—Illus.1 00

Lion Jack—By P. T. Barnum1 50Debatable Land—R. Dale Owen2 00

Jack in the Jungle—Do.1 50Threading My Way. Do.1 50

Cats, Cooks, Etc—By Edw. T. Ely.50Spiritualism—By D. D. Home2 00

Drumming as a Fine Art50Fanny Fern Memorials2 00

How to Win in Wall Street50Orpheus C. Kerr—4 vol. in one2 00

The Life of Sarah Bernhardt25Northern Ballads—E.L. Anderson1 00

Arctic Travels—Isaac I. Hayes1 50Offenbach's Tour in America1 50

College Tramps—Fred. A. Stokes1 50Stories about Doctors—Jeffreson1 50

Gospels in Poetry—E. H. Kimball1 50Stories about Lawyers Do.1 50

Me—By Mrs. Spencer W. Coe50Mrs. Spriggins.—By Widow Bedott1 50

N. Y. to San Francisco—Leslie1 50How to Make Money—Davies1 50

Miscellaneous Novels.

Doctor Antonio—By Ruffini$1 50Saint Leger—R.B. Kimball$1 75

Beatrice Cenci—From the Italian1 50Was He Successful? Do.1 75

Madame—By Frank Lee Benedict1 50Undercurrents of Wall St. Do.1 75

A Late Remorse Do.1 50Romance of Student Life. Do.1 75

Hammer and Anvil Do.1 50To-day. Do.1 75

Her Friend Laurence Do.1 50Life in San Domingo Do.1 75

Prairie Flower—Emerson Bennett1 50Henry Powers, Banker Do.1 75

Among the Thorns—Dickinson1 50Led Astray—Octave Feuillet1 50

Women of To-day-Mrs. W. H. White1 50She Loved Him Madly—Borys1 50

Braxton's Bar—R. M. Daggett1 50Thick and Thin—Mery1 50

Miss Beck—Tilbury Holt1 50So Fair yet False—Chavette1 50

Sub Rosa—Chas. T. Murray50A Fatal Passion—C. Bernard1 50

Hilda and I—E. Bedell Benjamin1 50A Woman's Case—Bessie Turner1 50

A College Widow—C. H. Seymour1 50Marguerite's Journal—For Girls1 50

Old M'sieur's Secret—Translation50Rose of Memphis—W. C. Falkner1 50

Petticoats and Slippers50Spell-Bound—Alexandre Dumas75

Shiftless Folks—Fannie Smith1 50Heart's Delight—Mrs. Alderdice1 50

Peace Pelican. Do.1 50Another Man's Wife—Mrs. Hartt1 50

Price of a Life—R. Forbes Sturgis1 50Purple and Fine Linen—Fawcett1 50

Hidden Power—T.H. Tibbles1 50Pauline's Trial—L. D. Courtney1 50

Two Brides—Bernard O'Reilly1 50The Forgiving Kiss—M. Loth1 75

Sorry Her Lot—Miss Grant1 00Flirtation—A West Point novel1 50

Two of Us—Calista Halsey75Loyal unto Death1 50

Cupid on Crutches—A.B. Wood75That Awful Boy50

Parson Thorne-E.M. Buckingham1 50That Bridget of Ours50

Marston Hall—L. Ella Byrd1 50Phemie Frost—Ann S. Stephens1 50

Ange—Florence Marryatt1 00Charette—An American novel1 50

Errors—Ruth Carter1 50Fairfax—John Esten Cooke1 50

Unmistakable Flirtation—Garner75Hilt to Hilt. Do.1 50

Wild Oats—Florence Marryatt1 50Out of the Foam. Do.1 50

Widow Cherry—B.L. Farjeon25Hammer and Rapier. Do.1 50

Solomon Isaacs. Do.50Warwick—By M. T. Walworth1 75

Edith Murray—Joanna Mathews1 50Lulu. Do.1 75

Doctor Mortimer—Fannie Bean1 50Hotspur. Do.1 75

Outwitted at Last—S.A. Gardner1 50Stormcliff. Do.1 75

Vesta Vane—L. King, R.1 50Delaplaine. Do.1 75

Louise and I—C.R. Dodge1 50Beverly. Do.1 75

My Queen—By Sandette1 50Kenneth—Sallie A. Brock1 75

Fallen among Thieves—Rayne1 50Heart Hungry—Westmoreland1 50

San Miniato—Mrs. Hamilton1 00Clifford Troupe. Do.1 50

All For Her—A Tale of New York1 50Silcott Mill—Maria D. Deslonde1 50

All for Him—Author "All for Her"1 50John Maribel. Do.1 50

For Each Other. Do.1 50Conquered—By a New Author1 50

The Baroness—Joaquin Miller1 50Janet—An English novel1 50

One Fair Woman. Do.1 50Tales from the Popular Operas1 50

ALLAN PINKERTON'S

GREAT DETECTIVE BOOKS.

1.MOLLIE MAGUIRES AND DETECTIVES.

2.STRIKERS, COMMUNISTS, AND DETECTIVES.

3.CRIMINAL REMINISCENCES AND DETECTIVES.

4.THE MODEL TOWN AND DETECTIVES.

5.SPIRITUALISTS AND DETECTIVES.

6.EXPRESSMAN AND DETECTIVE.

7.THE SOMNAMBULIST AND DETECTIVES.

8.CLAUDE MELNOTTE AS A DETECTIVE.

9.MISSISSIPPI OUTLAWS AND DETECTIVES.

10.GYPSIES AND DETECTIVES.

11.BUCHOLZ AND DETECTIVES.

12.THE RAIL ROAD FORGER AND DETECTIVES.

13.BANK ROBBERS AND DETECTIVES.

14.BURGLAR'S FATE AND DETECTIVES.

These wonderful Detective Stories by Allan Pinkerton are having an unprecedented success. Their sale is fast approaching one hundred thousand copies. "The interest which the reader feels from the outset is intense and resistless; he is swept along by the narrative, held by it, whether he will or no." All beautifully illustrated, and published uniform with this volume. Price $1.50 each. Sold by all booksellers, and sent free by mail, on receipt of price, by

G. W. CARLETON & CO., Publishers, New York.

Cover of "The Burglar's Fate and The Detectives"