INDEX
Reading edition
Abbott, J. B: 245, footnote
Abel, Annie Heloise: work cited, 71, footnote, 191, footnote
Abolitionists: Indians’ slaves enticed away, 23; charges against Calhoun, 30; Quantrill in league with, 49; desire Indian lands, 76, 118; among Cherokees, 132; Cherokees repudiate idea that they are, 225; charges against, 291-294
Adair, W. P: 219, footnote
Address: of John Ross at Cherokee mass-meeting, 220
Agency system: under Confederacy, 179
Alabama: Creeks, Choctaws, and Chickasaws from, 20, 193, footnote; Choctaws in, 20, footnote; David Hubbard, commissioner from, 108
Alliance: Indians given political position in return for, 17; reasons for southern Indians entering into, with Confederacy, 18; Confederate State Department to effect, 140, footnote; failure of Pike to effect, with Cherokees, 156; Choctaw General Council authorizes negotiation of treaty of, 156; Confederacy paid dearly for its Indian, 177; nature of Seminole, with Confederacy, 197; principles of active, inserted by Pike into treaties, 212; McCulloch to accept Drew’s regiment of Home Guards as soon as treaty of, be consummated, 227; conditions of, between the Indians and Confederacy, 280; result of Battle of Pea Ridge on Indian, 284
Allies: Indian, 17; hope of finding in Cherokees, 125
Allotment in severalty: suggested to Creeks, Choctaws, and Chickasaws, 58
American Baptist Missionary Union: 38
American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions: work among Cherokees and Choctaws, 39; records of, 40, footnote; missionaries among Choctaws remove themselves from patronage, 41, 42, 43, footnote
American Civil War: [See Civil War]
American Historical Association: Report, 20, footnote
American Revolution: effect upon Cherokee emigration to Texas, 20, footnote; work of Committees of Correspondence in connection with, 83
Amnesty: provided for, 176
Annuities: negro and Indian half-breeds share Indian, 23, footnote; Choctaw, distinct from Chickasaw, 34, footnote; Indian, declared forfeited by Lincoln government, 145; John Ross considers Indian, safe, 147; payment of Indian, assumed by Confederacy, 163; Indian, diverted from regular channels, 170; to use, of hostile Indians, 274; Crawford makes requisition for Cherokee, 307
Antelope Hills: 55, 136, footnote
Apucks-hu-nubbe: district of, 34, footnote
Arbuckle, General: 193, footnote
Arkansas: Choctaws and Cherokees tarry in, 19, footnote; Indian Territory annexed to, for judicial purposes, 23, footnote; and Indian patronage, 59; and Indian participation in Civil War, 63; interest in Indian Territory, 67; Knights of Golden Circle active in, 68; interest in Indian alliance, 83; affairs reach crisis, 97; Hubbard, commissioner to, 108; sends commission to Indian country, 119; sends Albert Pike as delegate, 132-133
Arkansas Baptist: 47, footnote
Arkansas Convention: Journal, 119, footnotes, 120, footnotes
Arkansas Historical Association: Publications, 106, footnote
Arkansas Legislature: House Journal, 103, footnote, 110, footnote, 111, footnote
Arkansas River: 67, 76, 97, 135, footnote, 162, 175
Arms: description of, needed for Indians, 190, footnote; Choctaw-Chickasaw regiment not furnished with, 211; scarcity of, 211, footnote; Cherokees in, at Tahlequah mass-meeting, 217; Ross able to bear, 137, footnote; Creeks under, threaten hostilities, 138, footnote; fear, for Indians will be taken by secessionists, 228, footnote; Confederate difficulty in securing, 253 and footnote
Armstrong Academy: 40, footnote
Armstrong, William: 193, footnote
Asbury Mission: Indian amity compact concluded at, 69, footnote
Assinneboin: suggested Territory of, 32, footnote
Atchison, David R: letter to, mentioned, 33, footnote
Austin State Gazette: 80, footnote
Averell, William W: 101, footnote
Baker, George E: work cited, 58, footnote
Balentine, H: 79
Ball-playing: connected with secret organization of “Pins,” 86, footnote
Bancroft, Frederic: work cited, 58, footnote
Barnes, James K: 260, footnote
Barnesville: 245, 246
Beams’s Negroes: 23, footnote
Beaver Creek: 55
Beening, S. T: 102, footnote
Benjamin, Judah P: 140, footnote, 200, footnote, 215, footnote, 252, footnote
Benton, Thomas H: plan for a national highway, 28; request, 33, footnote
Big Chief: merit chief of Great Osages, 238
Billy Bowlegs: leaves Florida, 20 footnote; communications from, 198, footnote; refuses to sign treaty with Confederate States, 198-199; death of, 198, footnote; regarded as good commander, 277, footnote
Bird Creek: battle of, 138, footnote, 255-256
Bishop, A. W: work cited, 67, footnote, 68, footnote, 133, footnote
Black Beaver: 101 and footnote, 303
Black Dog: see Shon-tah-sob-ba
Blackhoof, Eli: 209, footnote
Blain, S. A: 56, footnote, 57, footnote
Blankets: furnished Indian refugees, 261; to be furnished Indian soldiers in U. S. A., 271, footnote; Indians need, 310; Leeper offers to give Kiowas, 318; Rector urges Leeper not to promise, Kiowas, 332; Kiowas receive from U. S. government, 343
Bloomfield Academy: 40, footnote
Bob Deer: 244
Boggy Depot: 91, 230, footnote
Bonds: 61, 145-146
Boone, A. G: 210, footnote
Boonsboro [Boonsborough]: 111 and footnote, 125
Boudinot, E. C: 119, 153, 156, footnote, 219, footnote
Bourland, James: appointed commissioner, 88; report, 91
Branch, Harrison B: 182-183, 210, footnote, 228, 232-233, 249, 271, 279, footnote
Brazos Agency: 55
Bribery: William McIntosh guilty of, 236; of chiefs to induce secession, 262, footnote
Brigade: jayhawking character of Lane’s, 233; Lane’s gives John Mathews his deserts, 239; Hunter asks permission to muster, of friendly Indians, 250; Kile, quartermaster in 274; proportion of white troops in Pike’s, 280
Brooks, Preston: 45, footnote
Brown, James: 217
Buchanan, James: administration charged by free-state Kansans with bad faith, 37; endorses pro-slavery policy, 45, footnote; distrusted, 47; “no coercion” policy, 87, footnote; patronage, given to southern men, 262, footnote; work cited, 22, footnote, 29, footnote
Buckner, H. S: 92
Buffalo Hump: 305, 315, 330, 338, 348
Bureau of Indian Affairs (Confederate): 128, 141, footnote, 190, footnote
Burgevin, Edmund: 105, footnote
Burleigh, Walter A: 227, footnote
Burlington: 259, 260, footnote
Burroughs, B: 120
Burrow, N. B: 99, 298, 305, 330, 341
Bushwhackers: drive Caddoes out of Texas, 19, footnote
Butler, George: agent for Cherokees, 45, 47, footnote, 285, 290
Byington, Cyrus: 79
Cache Creek: 55
Caddoes: from Louisiana, 19, footnote; Pike to meet, 189, footnote; horses stolen by, 353
Calhoun, J. M: 90, footnote
Calhoun, John C: report, 27; motive, 29; political heresy, 133
Cameron, Simon: 234, 249, footnote
Campbell, A. B: 260, footnote
Canadian River: 55, 63, 67, 162
Cane Hill: 296, 327
Carolinas: Catawbas in, 20, footnote
Carroll, H. K: work cited, 37, footnote
Carruth, E. H: report, 84, footnote, 197, footnote, 198, footnote; appointed by Lane, 242; interviews Creek delegates, 245; tries to arrange for inter-tribal council, 246; letter, 267
Cass, Lewis: 193, footnote
Catawbas: admitted to Choctaw citizenship, 20, footnote; in possession of northeastern part of Choctaw country, 20, footnote; in South Carolina fight with South, 20, footnote
“Catron letter”: 29, footnote
Chah-la-kee: suggested territory of, 31, footnote
Chah-lah-ki: district of, 178
Chah-ta: suggested territory of, 31, footnote
Chahta Tamaha: 189, footnote
Chatterton, Charles W: 259, footnote
Checote, Samuel: 193, 194
Cherokee Declaration of Independence written by Pike, 137, footnote
Cherokee Executive Council, 136, footnote; John Ross promises to call meeting of, 153; meeting of, 216, 217; communicates with McCulloch, 226
Cherokee Neutral Lands: location, 21, footnote, 64; size, 21, footnote; intruded upon, 35, 46, 285, 290; project for selling, 50, 163; McCulloch takes position opposite, 225; Lane’s proposed camp in, 233; Stand Watie ordered to take up a position in, 252, footnote; Cowart sets out for, 294
Cherokee Outlet: 54, footnote, 63, footnote, 64
Cherokee Proclamation of Neutrality: 153-154
Cherokee Strip: location, 21, 64; coveted by Kansans, 21
Cherokee Treaty: 157 and footnote; declares allegiance to C. S. A., 159, footnote; contains guarantee of autonomy, 159, footnote; contains promise of representation in Congress 159, footnote; navigable waters, 174; admission to military academy, 180; appointment of postmasters, 180; considered by Provisional Congress, 206; negotiated, 237; Ross’s characterization of, 257
Cherokees: from Tennessee and Georgia, 20; tarried in Arkansas, 19, footnote; go to Texas, 20, footnote; removal to Arkansas suggested by Jefferson, 20, footnote; in North Carolina fight with South, 20, footnote; “Eastern” in controversy with “Western,” 20, footnote; character of constitution, 31, footnote; visited by Sacs and Foxes, 36, footnote; work of A.B.C.F.M. among, 39; schools among, 39, footnote; religious denominations among, 39-40; desirable to have slaveholders settle among them, 42; material progress due to slavery, 46; search organization among, 48; with Cooper as volunteers, 54; antebellum relations with people of Arkansas, 64; representatives at inter-tribal conference, 71; visited by commissioners from Texas, 92; in council with Creeks, Seminoles, Quapaws, and Sacs, 94; Pike’s negotiations with, 134, footnote; to be indemnified, 163; made an exception, 168; at Battle of Wilson’s Creek, 214-215, 214, footnote; secession of, 217; resolutions of, 223-225; secret organization among, 291-293
Chickasaw: district, 34, footnote, 52
Chickasaw and Choctaw Herald: 56, footnote
Chickasaw Legislature: act, 68; resolutions, 122, footnote, 155
Chickasaw Manual Labor School: 40, footnote
Chickasaws: from Alabama and Mississippi, 20; character of constitution, 31, footnote; domestic troubles, 34; political connection with Choctaws, 34, footnote; religious denominations among, 40, footnote; construct government, 51; as volunteers, 54; country, 63; not represented at inter-tribal conference, 71; convention of Choctaws and, 91; prevented from attending council at North Fork, 94; take charge of property abandoned by Federals at Fort Arbuckle, 102; appeal of Burroughs to, 120-121; resolutions of Choctaws and, 130; negotiations of Albert Pike with, 136, footnote, 196-197; reported as anxious to join Southern Confederacy, 155; treaty with, considered by Provisional Congress, 204-207; E. H. Carruth communicates with loyal portion of, 246-247
Chilton, William P: 127
Chippewas: from Michigan, 19; warriors, 227, footnote
Chi-sho-hung-ka: 238, footnote
Chisholm, Jesse: 313, 320
Choctaw-Chickasaw Regiment: 77, 207, 210, 211, 230, footnote, 252, footnote
Choctaw-Chickasaw Treaty: 157, and footnote; declares allegiance to C. S. A., 159, footnote; contains promise of representation in Congress, 159, footnote; suggests ultimate statehood, 160, footnote; recognizes Choctaw country as distinct from Chickasaw, 161; transfers lease of Wichita Reserve to Confederate States, 162; navigable waters, 174; amnesty, 175
Choctaw Corn Contract: scandal involves Pike, 57, footnote
Choctaw General Council: act, 20, footnote; resolution, 72-74; under authority of Chief Hudson declares Choctaw Nation “free and independent,” 156, 196; plan treaty of alliance and amity with Confederacy, 156; communication from Pike, 187, footnote, 196, footnote
Choctaw Light Horse: 24, footnote
Choctaws: tarried in Arkansas, 19, footnote; Catawbas wish to unite with, 20, footnote; intimacy with negroes, 20, footnote; in Mississippi fight with South, 20, footnote; prepared to assent to territorial bill, 31, footnote; domestic troubles, 34; political connection with Chickasaws ended, 34, footnote; religious denominations among, 39-40; schools among, 40, footnote; desirable to have slaveholders settle among them, 42; ask relief, 57, footnote; country, 63; antebellum relations with people of Arkansas and Texas, 64; not represented at inter-tribal conference, 71; delegation, 74; affairs, 75-79; treaty with Confederate States, 78, 204; convention of Chickasaws and, 91; prevented from attending council at North Fork, 94; resolutions of Chickasaws and, 130; negotiations of Pike with, 136, footnote, 196-197; reported as anxious to join Confederacy, 155; enlist in army, 210; Carruth in communication with loyal portion, 246-247
Chuahla: 39, footnote
Chustenahlah: battle of, 258
Citizenship: U. S. recommended for Indians, 31 and footnote; Ottawas express preference for U. S., 36, footnote; Indians to determine own tribal, 169; Jim Ned’s right of, forfeited within Leased District, 306
Civil War (American): no adequate history of American, 17; Indian allies of South in, 20, footnote; in Choctaw-Chickasaw country threatened, 34 and footnote; delays Indian removal from Kansas, 37; corrupt practices of Democratic Party just prior to American, 45, footnote; Stand Watie on Southern side in, 49, footnote; responsibility of Texas and Arkansas for participation of Indians in, 63; early interest of Texas and Arkansas in Indian country, 67; see also Enlistment of Indians
Civilization Fund: 37
Clark, George W: 211, footnote, 240, footnote
Clover, Seth: 209, footnote
Cobb, Howell: 45, footnote
Cockrell, S. R: 119
Coe, Chas. H: work cited, 20, footnote
Coffin, William G: 80 and footnotes, 184, 245, 247, 259, 274
Colbert, D: 41, footnote
Colbert, Holmes: 261, footnote
Colbert, Winchester: 197, 201, footnote
Colbert Institute: 40, footnote
Coleman, Isaac: 186, footnote, 259, footnote
Collamore, George W: 261, footnote
Colley, S. G: 350
Collin (Texas): exodus of non-secessionists from, 95
Colorado: indigenous tribe, in, 19, footnote; attempts to secure Indian coöperation, 83
Comanche Treaty: 157, footnote, 158; amnesty, 176
Comanches: 51, 52, 55, 189, footnote, 200 and footnote, 201, 206, 313, 320, 323, 324, 331, 337, 347, 351
Commission: from Texas to Indian nations, 88 et seq.; from Arkansas, 108, footnote
Concharta: 255
Confederate Contract: for supplying Indians of Leased District, 301-303, 347, 352
Confederate Military History: work cited, 103, footnote
Congressional Globe: work cited, 58, footnote
Connelley, W. E: work cited, 34, footnote, 49, footnote
Connor, John: 544
Cooley, D. N: 56, footnote, 134, footnote, 226
Cooper, Douglas H: citizen of Mississippi, 41; fears abolitionization of Indian country, 41; sends note to Superintendent Dean, 42; sanguine as to slavery conditions among Indians, 45; survey of Leased District, 53; Choctaw Corn Contract, 57, footnote; becomes colonel in Confederate army, 76; regiment of Choctaws to be under command of, 77, 207; absent from post, 82 and footnote; apparently disapproves of Texan interference, 96; receives suggestions from Rector, 106-107, footnote, 187; instructions to, 147, footnote; defection of, 186-187; asked to continue as agent, 190, footnote; wishes to be agent and colonel, 197, footnote, 212, footnote; report concerning Indian enlistment, 211; in battle with Opoethleyohola, 254 et seq., 312; complains of not having more white troops, 280
Cooper, Samuel: 53, footnote, 147
Corn Contract: see Choctaw Corn Contract
Council: Cherokee, in session at Tahlequah, 50, footnote; Choctaw at Doaksville, 77; composition of Doaksville, 77; at Fort Smith, 226-227, 241; at Tahlequah, 237 et seq., 240; Coffin holds, with representatives of non-secession element of various tribes, 267; Agent Johnson holds, with Delaware chiefs, 272, footnote; Indian refugees hold, at Fort Roe, 278, footnote; Creek, demands payment of money, 289; Cowart reports rumor of Cherokee, 294; Cherokee, to meet, 296; of each tribe to consider amendments to treaties, 323; Leeper holds with Indians of Leased District, 346; Comanches propose, to effect everlasting peace with Southern people, 347; see also Inter-tribal Conference
Covode, John: 276
Covode Committee: 45, footnote
Cowart, Robert J: 46, 82 and footnote, 89, footnote, 114 and footnote, 184, 290, 295, 298
Cowetah: 69, footnote
Cox, John T: 261, footnote
Crawford, John: 183, footnote, 184-185, and footnotes, 190, footnote, 215, footnote, 216, 218, 219, footnote, 220, 223, 325
Creek Country: Seminoles accommodated within, 50; proposal for giving southern Comanches home within, 51 and footnote; proposal to allot lands in severalty, 58
Creek Light Horse: 218, footnote
Creek National Council: rejects proposal for allotment of lands in severalty, 58, footnote; approves draft of treaty with C. S. A., 194
Creek Treaty: 157 and footnote; Dole ignorant of existence, 157, footnote; declares allegiance to C. S. A., 159, footnote; contains guarantee of autonomy, 159, footnote; contains promise of representation in Congress, 159, footnote; model on subject of recognizing slavery, 166-167; extradition, 173; negotiation of, 192-195; considered by Provincial Congress, 206; clauses providing for active alliance, 212
Creeks: from Georgia and Alabama, 19-20; assist in Seminole removal, 20, footnote; mixture with negroes, 20, footnote, 23, footnote; status of free negro among, 23, footnote; Presbyterians among, 40; desirable to have slaveholders settle among, 42; repent giving home to Seminoles, 51; location, 67; representatives at inter-tribal council, 71; visited by commissioners from Texas, 92; in council with Cherokees, Seminoles, Quapaws, and Sacs, 94
Crime: unjustly charged against missionaries, 47; charged against Reserve Indians, 52
Crutchfield, Major P. T: 111
Culbertson, Alexander: 210, footnote
Cumberland Presbyterians: 40, footnote
Curtis, Gen. S. R: 138, footnote
Cushing, Caleb: opinion as attorney-general, 22
Cutler, Abram: 229, footnote
Cutler, George A: 184, footnote, 249, footnote, 259, footnote, 266
Davis, Jefferson: influences Cushing, 22; writes to Worcester, 23, footnote; nominates Hubbard Commissioner of Indian Affairs, 128; appoints Pike special commissioner to Indians, 130; message, 202; Marshall writes to, 207
Davis, John B: 23, footnote
Davis, John D: 199, footnote
Davis, William P: 199, footnote
Dawson, J. L: 193, footnote
Dean, Charles W: 42; work cited, 35, footnote, 60, footnote
Debray, X. B: 102, footnote
Decotah: suggested territory of, 31, footnote
Deep Fork of Canadian: 254
Delawares: from Indiana, 19; tarry in Missouri, 19, footnote; free state men among, 35; anxious to avoid white man’s interference, 36, footnote; Baptist school on reservation, 38; as refugees, 56, footnote; Leeper to communicate with, 181, footnote; Pike hopes to meet, 189, footnote; wealth, 208, footnote; treaty with, 231, footnote; employed as scouts, 232; appeal to, 268; response of, 268; and Shawnees attack Wichita Agency and kill Leeper, 329, footnote
Delegates: five great tribes should have, in Congress, 31, footnote; Pike sent as, 132-133; to be allowed in Confederate Congress, 159, 161, 177, 203, 204, 324; Creek on way to Washington, 245; Gamble to Confederate Congress, 312
Delegation: Choctaw and Chickasaw, gives assurance to Indian Office of neutrality, 74 and footnote, 75; from non-secession element in various tribes, 265-266 and footnote, 267 and footnote; from Leased District visits Kiowas, 353
Denton: exodus from, 95
Denver, J. W: 270
Derrysaw, Jacob: 69, footnote, 194, 218, footnote
Dickey, M. C: 209, footnote
Dickinson, J. C: 50, footnote, 296
Diplomacy: used to effect Indian alliance, 17; and intrigue to effect Seminole removal from Florida, 20, footnote
District of Columbia: status of slavery in, 22
Disunion: Pike’s poem on, 133 and footnote
Doaksville: 39, footnote; Choctaw constitution, 51; Council at, 77
Dole, William P: 56, footnote, 74, footnote, 75, 80, 231 and footnote, 233, 241-242, 250, 266, 271, 273, 274
Dorn, Andrew J: 30, footnote; takes charge of Neosho Agency, 35, footnote, 51; absent from post, 82; citizen of Arkansas, 82, footnote; tells Neosho River Agency Indians to attend Tahlequah meeting, 241; letter of, 295; Rector complains of conduct of, 328
Dred Scott Decision: effect upon Indian interests, 29
Drew, John: 137, footnote, 214, footnote, 217, 226, 253, footnote, 255
Drew, Thomas: work cited, 30, footnote; issues permits to peddle in Indian country, 60
Drouth: 57, 146, 208
Du Val, Ben T: 104, footnote
Dwight: Cherokee school at, 39, footnote
Echo Harjo: 58, footnote, 80, footnote, 192, 193, 243
Edwards, John: 78
Elder, Peter P: 81, footnote
Elk Horn Tavern: battle of, 138, footnote
Ellis, Jo: 244
Emigration: of Indians voluntary, 19, footnote
Emissaries: 83, 88, 89, footnote, 113 et seq., 114, footnote, 115, footnote, 132, 142, 148, footnote, 183, 208, 210, footnote, 218, footnote, 219, footnote, 242
Emory, William H: 96-102, 98, footnotes
Enlistment of Indians: Pike favors, 132; McCulloch instructed to secure, 144, 147; no intention of Confederacy to use as Home Guards exclusively, 148; Pike objects to use outside of Indian country, 149; Hyams urges, 155; Chief Hudson authorizes, among Choctaws, 156; Federal attitude towards, 227 et seq., compulsory, illegal, 228, footnote; Lane resolves upon, 229-230 and footnotes; Frémont favors, 231-232; Delaware chiefs oppose, 232; Lane persists in urging, 248; urged by Hunter, 250; to be resorted to by Federals in invading Indian Territory, 270-271 and footnotes, 272, footnote; U. S. War Department reverses action respecting, 275, 279 and footnotes; Coffin’s views on, 277, footnote; muster roll showing, 344; among Comanches abandoned, 350
Euchees: 52
Factions: among Cherokees, 49-50, 151 et seq., 215, 223, 240; among Creeks, 192-194, 254; among Seminoles, 198-199; among Comanches, 306
Fairfield: Cherokee school at, 39, footnote
Fall Leaf: 231, footnote, 232 and footnotes, 233, footnote
Farnsworth, H. W: 229, footnote, 272
Fayetteville: 67, footnote, 184, 310, 326
Female seminaries: Indian girls attend, 67, footnote
Finch, John: 30, footnote
Finley, C. A: 270
Fishback, William Meade: 104, footnote
Fleming, Walter L: work cited, 108, footnote
Floyd, John B: 53, 296
Folsom, George: 23, footnote
Folsom, Israel: 74
Folsom, Joseph P: 77
Folsom, Peter: 74, 76, 196
Folsom, Sampson: 41, footnote, 76, 196
Food: Indian refugees need, 260; to destitute Delawares from Cherokee country, 268, footnote; Creek refugees destitute of, 273, footnote, 278, footnote; supposed fraudulent character of contract for supplying, 285-289; Confederate contract with Charles B. Johnson for supplying, 301-303; for Comanches, 313; to be furnished Indians in council considering amendments to treaties, 323; receipt for, furnished, 345
Fort Arbuckle: 54, 87, footnote, 97, 135, footnote, 201, footnote, 297, 303, 345, 357
Fort Belknap: 88, footnote
Fort Caleb: 295
Fort Cobb: 82, footnote, 84, footnote, 96, 97, 98 and footnote, 189, footnote, 296, 332, 356
Fort Coffee Academy: 40, footnote
Fort Davis: 349
Fort Gibson: abandoned as military post, 53; Major Emory and, 104; distance from Fort Smith, 108; Pike returns to, 137, footnote; Armstrong to meet emigrating Creeks at, 193, footnote; Cooper draws off in direction of, 256; money at, 325
Fort Leavenworth: 88, footnote, 103, 208, footnote, 251, 259, 266, 267, 270
Fort Lincoln: 229, footnote, 230, 243
Fort McCulloch: 139, footnote, 284
Fort Randall: 227, footnote
Fort Roe: 259 and footnote, 275, footnote, 277, footnote
Fort Scott: 249, footnote, 266
Fort Smith: headquarters of southern superintendency, 64; evacuated, 76; W. G. Coffin fails to reach, 81, footnote; Emory reaches, 97; Emory tarries at, 99; hot-bed of sectionalism, 103; distance from Fort Gibson, 108; J. J. Gaines reaches, 113; Pike proceeds to, 138, footnote; McCulloch at, 150; talk of confiscating Rector’s property at, 182, footnote; distance from Scullyville, 211; fire at, 298
Fort Smith Council: 192, footnote, 226-227, 241
Fort Smith Papers: cited, 41, footnote, 43, footnote, 50, footnote, 104, footnote, 197, footnote, 198, footnote, 285-328
Fort Smith Times: cited, 47, footnote
Fort Sumter: 118
Fort Towson: 40, footnote
Fort Washita: 77, 91, 96, 189, footnote, 297, 303
Fort Wise: 210, footnote
Forty-niners: covet land in Indian country, 28
Frauds: William Walker, head chief of Wyandots, takes part in Kansas election, 22, footnote
Frazier, Jackson: 41, footnote
Free negroes: status among Creeks and Seminoles, 23, footnote; among Choctaws, 24, footnote; Leased District rendezvous for, 56-57
Free-soilers: 45, 46, 113
Free-state expansion: charge that Calhoun intended to prevent, 30
Free-state men: intrenched among Delawares north of Kansas River, 35
Frémont, John C: 214, footnote, 215, footnote, 231, 232, 233, footnote, 248, 312
Frontier: action along Missouri-Arkansas in Civil War, 17; character of men of, 114; Indians exploited for sake of men of, 170; trouble on, to be expected, 183, footnote
Frozen Rock: 53
Fugitive Slave Law: operative within Indian country, 22, 166, 178
Gaines, J. J: 113, 115, footnote, 116
Gamble, James: 41, footnote, 54, footnote, 197, 312
Garland, Samuel: 74, 76
Garrett, William H: 58, footnote, 82, and footnote, 183, 184 192, 194, 212, footnote, 324
Georgia: Creeks and Cherokees from, 20, 193, footnote; D. E. Twiggs from, 87
Grayton: exodus from, 95
Green, J. J: 105, footnote
Greenwood, A. B: 36, footnote, 45, footnote, 46, 48, 113, 192, 209, footnote, 291, 292, 294
“Grier letter”: 29, footnote
Griffith, Samuel: 119, 182, footnote, 183-184
Grimes, Marshal: 56, footnote, 57, footnote, 98, footnote, 336, 337
Hagerstown (Md.): Quantrill, native of, 48
Half-breeds: status of, 23, footnote; generally slaveholders, 46; influence sought in holding Indian country for South, 67; planter class in Indian Territory, 67, 75; white men and Choctaw, hold secession meeting, 77; missionaries fear, 78; hated by “loyal” Cherokees, 139, footnote; attempt to force full-bloods into alliance with Confederacy, 216
Halleck, Henry W: 215, footnote, 275
Hamilton, Charles A: appointed commissioner, 88; report, 91
Harris, C. A: 193, footnote
Harris, Cyrus: 41, footnote, 69, footnote, 80, footnote; visited by commissioners from Texas, 91
Harris, Thomas A: 130
Harrison, James E: appointed commissioner, 88; report, 91; referred to by Governor Clark, 131, footnote
Helena (Ark.): 104
Hemphill, John: 100, footnote
Hester, G. B: 230, footnote
Hicks, Charles: 237, footnote
Hindman, Thomas C: 48, footnote, 105, footnote, 357
Hobbs, Reverend Doctor S. L: 79
Hotchkin, Ebenezer: 42, 76
Houston, Sam: 31, footnote, 90, 93
Howard, O. O: work cited, 220, footnote
Hubbard, David: 108; letter to Governor Moore, 109-110; nominated as Commissioner of Indian Affairs, 128; Pike hopes for coöperation, 141; receives instructions from Walker, 142-143; ill-health, 143, footnote; writes to John Ross, 144-145; reply of John Ross to, 146-147; instructed not to offer statehood, 161; advice to Crawford, 308; advises economy, 315
Hudson, George: 77, 80, footnote; declares Choctaw Nation “free and independent,” 156; dealings with Pike, 196; proclamation, 196, 210
Humboldt: 243, footnote, 247
Humphreys, John J: 185, 218, footnote
Hunter, David: 248, 249, and footnote, 250, 251, 260, 266, 270, 275, 276, 312
Hyams, S. M: 155
Illinois: tribes from, 19
Indian adoption: 169
Indian camp: Lane plans establishment to prevent foraging into Kansas, 230; to be located in Cherokee Neutral Lands, 233; Cooper reaches, 254
Indian country: west of Arkansas and Missouri, 19; tribes within, indigenous and emigrant, 19 and footnote; population, 20-21; cut in two by Missouri Compromise line, 20; reservation system established, 21; listed with District of Columbia as strictly federal soil, 22; Fugitive Slave Law declared operative within, 22; presence of free negroes sometimes source of grave danger, 23, footnote; constantly beset by difficulties, 24, 27; likely to be greatly reduced in area by Manypenny treaties, 35; intruders attracted by supposed mines of precious metals, 35, footnote; rivalry among churches, 37; intruders to be removed by Agent Cowart, 46; practically no U. S. troops within, 52-53; northern tribes of less importance politically than southern, 62, footnote; slaveholding politicians work through halfbreeds to hold for South, 67; strategic importance of, appreciated by Arkansas, 108; military necessity of securing, 131; Pike describes sojourn in, 134 et seq., footnote; McCulloch to give military protection to, 148; McCulloch lays plans for taking possession of, 149; establishment of Confederate States courts promised by treaty with great tribes, 177; postal system to be maintained throughout, 180; U. S. War Department resolves upon expedition to, 270
Indian Home Guards: Pike in favor of Indians as, 132; no evidence that Indians wanted exclusively as, 148; individual Cherokees as, 149-151; disposition to keep Indians as, 212; Ross’s plan defeated by McCulloch, 226-227; authorized by Cherokee Executive National Council, 226; Drew’s regiment tendered to McCulloch, 227; Drew’s regiment escorts Pike to Park Hill, 240
Indian Intercourse Law: difficulty in enforcing, 24, footnote; Greenwood’s exposition of, 290; Leeper asks for copy, 315; Leeper reports troops necessary to enforce law within Leased District, 346
Indian Property Rights: put in jeopardy by pioneer advance, 28; in trans-Missouri region, 29; rendered secure by treaty promises, chap. iii
Indian Removal: policy, 19, footnote; law for, 19, footnote; indemnification for, 164-166
Indian States in Union: suggested by southern politicians, 31; suggested by Texas newspapers, 31, footnote; Confederacy promises to Choctaws, 78; no assurance of, to be given by Hubbard, 143; promised in treaties made by Confederacy, 160 and footnote, 161; Davis calls attention to clauses in Indian treaties providing for, 203; Provisional Congress modifies treaty guarantee for, 204
Indian Territory: small tribes find their way to, 19, footnote; annexed for judicial purposes to Western District of Arkansas, 23, footnote; in danger of being abolitionized,41-42; only home for Indians from Kansas, 36; drouth in, 58; political status of tribes in, 62, footnote; position with respect to Texas and Arkansas, 63; topographical description of, 63; early interest of Texas and Arkansas in, 67; halfbreeds of, a planter class, 67, 75; Knights of Golden Circle active in, 68; Indians to be driven out of, 76; cut off from communication with U. S. Indian Office, 81, footnote; agents within, all southern men, 82; Commissioner Dole urges reoccupation of, 241; strategical importance of, 242; included within Trans-Mississippi District of Department No. 2, 280
Indian trade: licenses for, 59-60; regulations respecting, 169-171
Indiana: tribes from, 19; W. G. Coffin from, 80
Indians: lands granted in perpetuity, 18; participation in American Civil War inevitable, 18; as emigrants, 19; number of colonized, 20-21; proportion of southern to northern, 21; slaves enticed away by abolitionists, 23; seized as fugitives by southern men, 23; interests militated indirectly against by Dred Scott decision, 29; territorial form of government for, 30, footnote, 31, footnote; treaty rights likely to be seriously affected by repeal of Missouri Compromise, 34; plan for colonizing Texas, 52, 55; Knights of Golden Circle active among, 68; condition of, reported by Texas commissioners, 94; Choctaw and Chickasaw friendly to Confederate States, 100, footnote; enlistment, 132, 147-149, 155, 181, footnote, 207, 210, 211-212, 227, footnote, 248, 250, 252, footnote, 270, 275, 279; treaties with Confederate States, 157-158, 202-206; judicial rights under treaties with Confederate States, 172-174; military support secured early by Confederacy, 207; use of, by U. S. as soldiers uncertain, 227 et seq.; not subject to conscription, 228, footnote; reported arming themselves on southern border of Kansas, 228, footnote; conference with Lane at Fort Lincoln, 230; totally abandoned by U. S. government, 262, footnote; see also under names of individual nations and tribes
Interior Department: 53, 80, 218, footnote, 242, 265, 273
Interlopers: encourage slavery within Indian country, 22; see also Intruders
Inter-tribal Conference: documents relating to, called by the Chickasaws, 68, footnote; assembling of, at Creek Agency, 70; attendance, 71; action, 71-72; action not officially reported to U. S. government, 82; Motey Kennard and Echo Harjo in Washington at time, was planned, 192; Indians solicit, 209, footnote; Lane arranges for, to meet at Fort Lincoln, 243, 246; Coffin desires, at Humboldt, 247; plans for, at Leroy, 248; Hunter instructed to hold, 250; difference between, as planned by Lane and by Hunter, 250, footnote; John T. Cox gives account of, 262, footnote
Interview: of Pike and McCulloch with Cherokee Confederate sympathizers, 135, footnote, 152; of Lane with representatives of various tribes at Fort Lincoln proposed, 243, 246; of Coffin with Carruth, 243, footnote; of Carruth with Creek delegation, 245
Intrigue: and diplomacy to effect Seminole removal from Florida, 20, footnote; Pike expected to succeed in, with Southern Indians, 86, footnote
Intruders: to be removed by Agent Cowart, 46; interfere with slavery, 47; Confederate military authority to supplement tribal in expulsion of, 169; Agent Butler’s reports, 285; Greenwood discusses matter with Rector, 290-291; Cowart reports progress in removal of, 295, 296, 297; Cowart gives notice to John B. Jones to leave Cherokee Nation, 296; see also Interlopers
Iowas: 189, footnote
Irish, O. H: 227, footnote
Iyanubbi: Choctaw school at, 39, footnote
Jackson, Andrew: 19; inducements offered to Indians, 58; procedure of, 72; opposed to political tenets of John C. Calhoun, 133
Jayhawking: of Lane’s brigade, 233, 234, 277
Jennison, C. R: 275, footnote
Jesup, Thomas S: 164, footnote, 165
Jim Ned: 306, 330, 341
Jim Pockmark: 306, 338
John Chupco: 198, footnote, 199
John Jumper: and Seminole removal, 20, footnote; favors boarding schools for youth of tribe, 40, footnote; approached by Albert Pike, 85, footnote, 197, footnote, 198, footnote; signs complaint against General Jesup, 164, footnote; signs treaty with Confederate States, 198; signature attached to Comanche treaties, 200, footnote; doing duty faithfully, 319; letter to, 337
Johnson, Charles, B: 56, footnote, 98, footnote, 105, footnote, 190, footnote, 199, 287, 289, 301, 314, 323, 332, 352
Johnson, F: 231, footnote, 232, 248, and footnote, 329, footnote
Johnson, James B: 105, footnote
Johnson, Richard H: 47, footnote, 105, footnote
Johnson, Robert W: 31, footnote, 47, footnote, 105, footnote, 127; correspondence with Albert Pike, 131, 132; motion, 204; Crawford serves by request, 308; elected senator, 334
Johnson, Thomas: slavery-propagation work among Indians, 22, footnote, 39
Johnson, W. Warren: 303
Johnson: exodus from, 95
Jones, Evan: 47, 93, 135, footnote, 217, 218, footnote, 236, 240, footnote, 292, 293
Jones, H. P: 199, 348, 350
Jones, John: 309
Jones, John B: 47, 269, footnote, 296
Jones, R. M: 75, 77, 79, 197, 344-345
Journeycake, Charles: 231, footnote, 268, footnote
Jumper, John: see John Jumper
Ka-hi-ke-tung-ka: 238, footnote
Kannady, J. R: 125
Kansa: indigenous to Kansas, 19; suffering of, 209, footnote
Kansas: Indian tribes in, 19; agitation for the opening up of, 28; compared with Choctaw country, 31, footnote; suggested organization causes excitement among Indians, 33-34; citizens encroach upon Cherokee Neutral Lands, 46; drouth in, 58; political status of tribes in, 62, footnote; and Cherokee Outlet, 64; Elder, citizen of, 186; Pike desires to raise Indian battalion, 207; Indians wish to fight, 227, footnote
Kansas Historical Society: Collections, 19, footnote, 34, footnote
Kansas-Nebraska Bill: effect upon Indian interests, 29, 35; settlers demand Indians to vacate territory covered by, 36; Seward’s speech on, 58-59
Kansas Territory: first districting illegally included Indian lands, 35; free-state settlers charge Buchanan government with bad faith, 37
Kappler, C. J: work cited, 20, footnote, 34, footnote, 49, footnote, 50, footnote, 52, footnote
Kaskaskias: from Illinois, 19
Keitt, Lawrence M: 127, 129
Kennedy, John C: 211, footnote
Kickapoos: from Indiana, 19; tarry in Missouri, 19, footnote; denominationalism among, 37, footnote; refugees, 56, footnote; Leeper to communicate with, in name of Albert Pike, 181, footnote; Pike hopes to meet, 189, footnote
Kile, William: 261, footnote, 274
Kingsbury, Rev. Cyrus: 40, and footnote, 43, footnote, 76
Kingsbury Jr., Cyrus: 79
Kiowas: 52; Texans reported tampering with, 210, footnote; messengers from, 309; talk for, 320; treaty with, to be effected, 323, 331; delegation of, 324; Big-head, chief of, 342; Lone Wolf, chief of, 350; E-sa-sem-mus, chief of, 350; annual festival of, 351; treaty with, 354
Knights of Golden Circle: probable influence with Arkansas Legislature, 68, footnote; evidence of activity among Indians, 68; halfbreeds belong to, 86, footnote
Koonsha Female Seminary: 40, footnote
Lands: plot to dispossess Indian of, 18; pledged by U. S. government as Indian possession in perpetuity, 18, 28; of Cherokees extended north of thirty-seventh parallel, 21; of Indians coveted by Forty-niners, 28; of Indians in Kansas excluded from local governmental control, 35; allotment in severalty proposed to Creeks, Choctaws and Chickasaws, 58; violation of treaties to cost Indians their, 86, footnote; property rights of Indians guaranteed by Confederacy, 161 et seq.; Indians to have right to dispose of by will, 172; Cherokee halfbreeds fear designs upon Indian, 216
Lane, James H: 125, 229, 231, footnote, 233, 242, 251 and footnote, 265, 270, 276, 278
Lane, W. P: 357
Laughinghouse, G. W: 120
Leased District: 52 and footnote, 54, 56, 57, footnote, 63, 67, 96, 179, 199, 297, 340, 349
Lee, Robert E: 88, footnote, 98, footnote, 99
Lee, S. Orlando: letter, 75-79, 197, footnote
Leeper, Matthew: 57 and footnote, 82 and footnote, 96, 98 and footnote, 99, 180, footnote, 199, footnote, 303, 304-307, 311, 315-319; removal of, asked for by Rector, 323; death of, 329, footnote; charges against, 333
Leeper Papers: cited, 57, footnote, 99, footnote, 102, footnote, 181, footnote, 186, footnote, 199, footnote, 200, footnote, 201, footnote, 329-357
Lee’s Creek: Cherokee school at, 39, footnote
Lefontaine, Louis: 208, footnote
Leroy: 248, 266
Lincoln, Abraham: 68, 76, 80, 86, footnote, 93, 95, 118, 122, footnote, 182, 185, 234 and footnote, 250, 265, footnote, 266, 274, 276, 278
Little Captain: 277, footnote
Little Rock: 103, 108, 190, footnote
London, John T: 104, footnote
Long John: 198, footnote
Love, Overton: 23, footnote
Lower Creeks: 50, 80, footnote, 192, 244
Lowrie, Walter: 75
“Loyal Creeks”: 192, footnote, 193, 194, footnote, 195, 199, 243-246, 250, 254, 259; sufferings, 260; measures for relief of, 260 et seq., 272; annuities of “hostiles” to be applied to relief of, 274
Luce, John B: 125, 282, footnote
McCarron, Thomas: 311
McClellan, George B: 265, footnote, 275, 276
McCulloch, Ben: 85, footnote, 120, 135, footnote, 141, 143-144; letter of Hubbard to, 144-145; attempt to secure Cherokee help, 149-153; communication with John Ross, 149; reply of John Ross to, 150; correspondence with Secretary Walker, 151, and footnote; reports Choctaws and Chickasaws as anxious to join Confederacy, 155; accompanies Albert Pike, 189, footnote; gives authority for calling out six hundred rangers from Fort Cobb, 198, footnote; objects to appointment of Garrett as colonel of Creek regiment, 212, footnote; acts under direct orders from Richmond, 225; promises to protect Cherokee borders, 227; orders Stand Watie to take up position in Cherokee Neutral Lands, 252, footnote; goes to Richmond, 257, footnote
McCulloch, Henry E: 99, footnote, 207
McCulloch, Thomas C: 210, footnote
McDaniel, James: 262, footnote, 268, and footnote
Machinations: secessionist sympathy of Indians not due to, of agents and others, 219, footnote
McIntosh, Chilly: 92, 140, footnote, 193, and footnote, 200, footnote
McIntosh, D. N: 92
McIntosh, James: 256 et seq.
McIntosh, Rolly: 193, footnote
McIntosh, William: 191, footnote, 193, footnote; attempts to bribe John Ross, 236, footnote
McRae, John J: presents petition for removal of Choctaws, 20, footnote
McWillie, M. H: 207, footnote
Mails: insecurity, 116; none in Indian country, 190, footnote; irregularity, 230, 252, footnote; must be provided for in Leased District, 309; Rector has no authority to establish, 332
Malfeasance: Rev. Thomas Johnson suspected of, 39, 41; few Indian Office officials free from, 56, footnote; Washburn implicated in, 85, footnote; Indian agents guilty of, 262, footnote
Manassas Junction: battle of, 216
Mandan: suggested territory of, 32, footnote
Manypenny, George W: 30, footnote; Indian treaties made by, 33, footnote, 35; promises to look into expediency of Comanche removal, 51, footnote; suggests giving Indians control of trade, 170
Marcy, William L: 165, footnote
Marshall, F. J: 207
Marysville: 207
Mass-meeting: of Cherokees at Tahlequah, 217 et seq., 226, 234
Mathews, John: 235, footnote, 239
Mayers, Abram G: 56, footnote, 197, footnote, 230, footnote, 287, 288, 289, 312
Mayes, Joel: 214, footnote
Medicines: Texans seize, 305, 308; Leeper’s requisition can not be honored, 330-331
Memphis (Tenn.): 97, 104, 134, footnote
Methodist Episcopal Church South: 37, footnote, 38, 40, footnote
Methodists: 38
Mexican War: effect upon Indian interests, 28; service of Pike in, 132
Miamies: from Indiana, 19; charges against Agent Clover, 209, footnote
Michigan: tribes from, 19
Mikko Hutke: 194, 244
Military Board of Arkansas: 190
Minnesota: territory of Decotah to be carved out of, 31, footnote
Mission: of Pike, 134 et seq.; of Hubbard, 143 et seq.; of Carruth, 242, 246-247
Missionaries: encourage slavery within Indian country, 22; among Indians, 39 et seq.; suspected of attempting to abolitionize Indian country, 41; charged with inciting to murder, 47; search organization among Cherokees due to, 48
Missionary Herald: cited, 40, footnote, 41, footnote
Missions: 39 et seq., 143
Mississippi: Choctaws and Chickasaws from, 20; Choctaws in, fight on side of South, 20, footnote; Cooper, citizen of, 41
Mississippi River: 17, 63
Missouri: Kickapoos, Shawnees, and Delawares tarry in, 19, footnote; interests herself in Indian alliance, 83
Missouri Compromise: line approximately boundary between northern and southern Indian immigrants, 21; encroachment upon northern rights under, 22; as affected by Kansas-Nebraska bill, 30
Mitchell, Charles B: 97, 98, 334
Montgomery: 76, 87, footnote, 94, 109, 192, 196, 297
Moore, Andrew B: 108
Moore, Frank: work cited, 45, footnote, 125, footnote, 227, footnote
Moore, Thomas O: 155, 192, footnote
Moo-sho-le-tubbee: district of, 34, footnote
Moravians: 38
Morton, Jackson: 127
Motey Kennard: 58, footnote, 80, footnote, 92, 94, 119, 191, and footnote, 193, 199, 200, footnote, 218, footnote, 243, 337
Mound City: 230, footnote
Munsees: from Ohio, 19; Moravians among, 38
Murphy, J: 119
Mus-co-kee: territory of suggested, 31, footnote
Navajoe: suggested territory of, 32, footnote
Ne-a-math-la: 193, footnote
Nebraska: indigenous tribes in, 19, footnote; agitation for opening up of, 28; drouth in, 57
Ne-con-he-con: 268, footnote
Negroes: Choctaws charged with mixing with, 20, footnote; Creeks almost completely mixed with, 22, footnote; Creeks possess no aversion to race mixture, 23, footnote; no rights that white men are bound to respect, 29; Quantrill plans to rescue, 48; Indians agree to return fugitive, 166, footnote; six hundred, seized by Kansans, 334
Neighbors, Robert S: 56, footnote
Neosho: suggested territory of, 31, footnote
Neosho River: 208, 277, footnote
Neosho River Agency: 30, footnote; invaded, 35, footnote; Elder put in charge of, 186; Indians of, at Fort Smith Council, 241
Neutrality: McCulloch agrees to respect Cherokee, 136, footnote; of Indians scarcely possible, 145; Chief Ross gives reasons for preserving, 147, 150; Chief Ross objects to violation of, 150; majority of Cherokees favor, 153; Chief Ross’s Proclamation of, 153-154; discussion in Cherokee meeting at Tahlequah, 220 et seq.; McCulloch orders Stand Watie’s men not to interfere with Cherokee, 227
New Hope Academy: 40, footnote
New Orleans Picayune: 32, footnote
Newspapers: 47, 75, 80, footnote
New York Indians: from Wisconsin, 19; reservation invaded, 35; members of Neosha River Agency, 51; Refugees camp upon lands of, 260
North Carolina: Cherokees fight on side of South, 20, footnote
North Fork Village: 92, 94, 95, 157, 188, 192
North Fork of Canadian: 67, 136, footnote, 189, footnote, 254
Northern Baptists: 38, 39
Northern Indians: colonized within limits of great American desert, 18; relative position of, 21; Pike hoped to exert influence over, 208; reported organized into spy companies by Federals, 306
Oak Hills, or Wilson’s Creek: battle of, 215, 216, 225, 257, footnote
Ochiltree, William B: 129
Office of Indian Affairs: plans for removal of Catawbas from Carolinas, 20, footnote; takes measures for removal of Seminoles from Florida, 20, footnote; refuses to remove Choctaws from Mississippi, 20, footnote; unable to execute plan for removal of Texas Indians before 1859, 52; reply of Creeks to proposals, 58; patronage of, 59; out of communication with Indian Territory, 81, footnote; complaint filed at, 96; in possession of documents incriminating D. H. Cooper, 186; discontinues Indian allowances, 192; supports War Department, 271
Ogden, John B: 89, footnote, 108, footnote, 115, footnote
Ohio: people of, desire information about Manypenny treaties, 33, footnote
Okanagan: suggested territory of, 32, footnote
Ok-ta-ha-hassee Harjo [Sands]: 194, 244, and footnote
Old Choctaw Agency: 211, footnote
Oldham, W. S: 100, footnote
Old Scottish Gentleman: 107 and footnote
Old Settlers Party: 49
Omaha Mission School: youths from, enlist in army, 227, footnote
Omahas: 227, footnote
Opoeth-le-yo-ho-la: 138, footnote, 193 and footnote, 194, 195, footnote, 198, footnote, 236, footnote, 243, 253, footnote, 254 et seq., 268, 278
Oregon: occupied, 28
Osage Manual Labor School: 38, footnote
Osage Mission: 182, footnote
Osage River Agency: 208, footnote
Osage Treaty: 157 and footnote; lands, in Kansas guaranteed by, 162; model on subject of rendition of slaves, 167; navigable waters, 175; negotiated, 237
Osages: indigenous to Kansas, 19; Great and Little, 20, footnote; reservation invaded, 35, 295; determined to resist removal, 36; Roman Catholicism among, 38 members of Neosho River Agency, 51; negotiations with Pike, 137, footnote; described as “lazy,” 208, footnote; letter to, from John Ross, 235, 236, footnote; bands of, 237
Otis, Elmer: 210, footnote
Otoes: 209, footnote
Ottawas: from Michigan, 19; regard removal as useless, 36, footnote; Baptists among, 38
Ozark Mountains: 19, footnote
Pacific Railroad Surveys: cited, 54, footnote
Pa-hiu-ska: 238, footnote
Panola: county of, 68, footnote
Pape, Henry: 182, footnote
Park Hill: Cherokee school at, 39, footnote; residence of John Ross, 135, footnote, 188, footnote; John Ross at, 150; W. S. Robertson retires to, 218, footnote; Pike invited to, 234; treaties negotiated at, 237
Parker, Eli S: 228, footnote
Parker, Thomas Valentine: work cited, 49, footnote
Parks, Robert W: 355
Pas-co-fa: 198 and footnote, 319
Pawnees: purchase from, 33, footnote; offer to enlist in U. S. army declined, 227, footnote
Pea Ridge: battle of, 138, footnote, 284
Pearce, N. Bart: 120, 131
Pegg, Major: 256, 257
Peoria, Baptiste: 235, footnote
Peorias: from Illinois, 19
Petition: of Representative John J. McRae, 20, footnote
Phelps, J. S: 81, footnote; 211, footnote, 240, footnote
Phillips, U. B: work cited, 134, footnote, 191, footnote
Piankeshaws: from Illinois, 19
Pickens: county of, 68, footnote
Pierce, Franklin: 41, footnote, 56, footnote
Pike, Albert: dislike of Van Dorn, 55, footnote; concerned with Choctaw Corn Contract, 57, footnote; and Choctaw commissioners, 78; writes to Seminole chief, 84, footnote; telegram, 105, footnote; poem in honor of Elias Rector, 106; correspondence with Robert Toombs, 129, 131, 134 and footnote, 152 and footnote; appointed by President Davis special commissioner to Indians west of Arkansas, 130; correspondence with R. W. Johnson, 131, 132; writings, 132, footnote, 133 and footnote; unjust to John Ross, 134, footnote; commissioner from Arkansas, 190-191; views on use of Indians as soldiers, 149; continues intercourse with Ridge Party, 156 and footnote; moderate in promises to strong tribes, 163; assumes financial obligations in name of Confederacy, 163-164; opens communication with Indian field service, 180-181; offers post to Leeper, 180, footnote; negotiates with Creeks, 192-195; negotiates with Choctaws and Chickasaws, 196-197; negotiates with Seminoles, 197-199; negotiates with western Indians, 200-202, 200, footnote; report submitted by President Davis to Provisional Congress, 202; invited to be present at consideration of Indian treaties, 205; desires to raise an Indian battalion from Kansas, 208; informed of Cherokee willingness to treat, 234; assigned to command of Indian Territory, 253-254, 322; Van Dorn’s plans for, 280, 283; retires to Fort McCulloch, 284; continues Charles B. Johnson as contractor, 301-303; receives Leeper’s apology, 356
Pike, W. L: 194
Pine Ridge: 43, footnote
Pins: 86, footnote, 135, footnote, 137, footnote, 138, footnote, 216
Pioneers: 18, footnote
Pitchlynn, P. P: 74, 77
Pitchlynn, W. B: 197
Policy: of U. S. government with respect to Indians, 18; of Confederate States government, 147
Politicians: as influencing Indian policy of government, 18, footnote; motives of, 21; demands of, for Indians, 31; reason for urging secession among Indians, 98, footnote; unjust charges against Ross, 150
Polk, James K: work cited, 49, footnote, 166, footnote
Pomeroy, Samuel C: 231, footnote
Pontotoc: county of, 68, footnote
Pope, John: 105, footnote
Population: of Indian country, 20-21; of southern superintendency, 211, footnote; of Creek Nation as estimated by Agent Garrett in report to Hubbard, 252-253, footnote
Postal system: to be maintained by Confederate States throughout Indian country, 180
Potawatomies: from Indiana, 19; Roman Catholicism among, 38; Southern Baptists among, 38
Poteau River: 108
Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions: 37, footnote, 40, footnote, 41, 79
Presbyterians (Old School): 38, footnote, 39, 40, footnote, 41
Price, Sterling: 138, footnote, 225, 257, footnote, 280, 283, 312, 326, 334
Prince, J. E: 98, footnote, 231, footnote
Proclamation: of Ross pledging Cherokee neutrality, 153-154; of Hudson announcing Choctaw independence, 196, 210
Pro-slavery men: intrenched among Shawnees south of Kansas River, 35; settled upon Cherokee Neutral Lands, 35, footnote
Protectorate: over Indian tribes suggested, 130, 142, 158, 190
Provisional Congress of Confederate States: act of, May 21, 1861, 130, 158 and footnote; considers treaties with Indian tribes, 202-206
Pulliam, Richard P: 183, footnote, 184, 294, 295, 297, 311, 324
Pushmataha: George Folsom, chief of district of, 23, footnote; District of, 34, footnote
Quakers: 39
Quantrill, Wm. Clarke: 48, 214, footnote
Quapaw Treaty: 157 and footnote
Quapaws: 51, 64, 67; in council with Creeks, Cherokees, Seminoles, and Sacs, 94; negotiations with Pike, 136, footnote, 235, footnote, 237
Quesenbury, William: 183, footnote, 184, 190, footnote, 194, 303, 323
Ray, P. Orman: work cited, 22, footnote, 34, footnote, 38, footnote
Reagan, J. H: 230, footnote
Rector, Elias: superintends removal of Seminoles, 20, footnote, 182, footnote; demands for Indians, 31, footnote; Cooper writes to, 42; urges that Frozen Rock be converted into military post, 53; enters into sort of private contract with Johnson and Grimes, 56 and footnote; Grimes and, 57, footnote, 285-289; relieved, 80, footnote; seconds efforts of cousin, 106; suggestion to Cooper, 106-107, footnote, 187; gives letter of introduction to Gaines, 113; gives information concerning Choctaws and Chickasaws, 120; attempt of U. S. government to find successor to, 182; uncertainty as to when entering Confederate service, 182, footnote; interview with Pike, 190, footnote; in company of Pike, 197, 198, footnote; writes to Leeper, 199, footnote; expense account of, 304; complaint against Pike, 328
Rector, Henry M: 102, 112
Red Fork of Canadian: 67, 255
Red River: 55, 63, 77, 91, 95, 100 and footnote, 108, 139, footnote, 175, 347, 349
Refugees: Opoethleyohola, leader of, 195; Coffin prepares to meet, 259; take up station between Verdigris and Arkansas Rivers, 259; approximate number of, 260 and footnote; sufferings of, 260-261 and footnotes, 265, footnote, 272; absolute destitution of, 273, footnote; Dole furnishes supplies to, 274; joint resolution for relief of, 274; annuities of hostile Indians to be diverted to relief of, 274 and footnote
Regiment: Colonel Cooper’s filled with Texans, 78; Choctaw-Chickasaw and Creek, 210-211; Creek, to elect its own officers, 213; Drew’s, organized, 226-227; work and character of Drew’s, 240 and footnote; of Choctaw-Chickasaw Mounted Rifles, of Creeks, and of Cherokee Mounted Rifles, 252, footnote, 262, footnote; Drew’s deserts Cooper, 256; only one white, in whole Indian Department, 280; Leeper asks for at least one, to keep order on Reserve, 349
Reid, Alexander: 76, 78
Removal: of Indiana more or less compulsory, 19 and footnote; slavery advanced as objection to Indian, 21-22; makes no difference in matter of slavery among Indians, 22; difficulties within Indian country incident to, 27; Calhoun’s plan for, 27; U. S. government slow to adopt policy of, 27-28; settlers demand, of Indians from Kansas, 36; certain tribes contemplating, 36, footnote; of Indians from Kansas delayed on account of Civil War, 37; Missionary Herald useful for history of, 40, footnote; reasons for, 48; project for, of Cherokees causes dissensions within tribes, 49; of Texas Indians, 52; Wichitas ask for immediate, 56; guarantee of territorial integrity in treaties arranging for, 160-161; indemnification for, 164-166; Choctaw claims under treaty of, 196
Reservation: system, introduced into trans-Missouri region, 21; Creeks disgusted with idea of individual, 58
Reserve Indians: see Indians of Leased District, Wichitas, Tonkawas, Euchees, etc.
Resolutions: of Choctaws, February 7, 1861, 72-74, 75; of Chickasaw Legislature, May 25, 1861, 122-124 and footnote; offered by Chilton of Alabama, 127; offered by Toombs for appointment of special agent to Indian tribes, 129; of Choctaws and Chickasaws showing friendly disposition towards South, 130 and footnote; passed at Cherokee mass-meeting at Tahlequah, August, 1861, 218, footnote, 223-225; joint, for relief of Indian refugees in Kansas, 274
Rhodes, J. F: work cited, 45, footnote, 129, footnote, 146, footnote
Richardson, James D: work cited, 129, footnote, 158, footnote, 202, footnote
Ridge, John: 47, footnote
Ridge, or Treaty Party: in favor of Cherokee removal, 49; connives with Ben McCulloch to circumvent wishes of Chief Ross, 151; minority party, 153; Pike’s intercourse with, continues, 156; attempts to develop public sentiment in favor of Confederacy, 215; collision with Ross faction, 240
Robertson, W. S: 101, footnote, 192, footnote, 218, footnote
Robinson, Charles: 228, 234
Rock-a-to-wa: 231, footnote
Rogers, H. L: 332, 333, 336, 337
Rolla: W. S. Robertson fleeing from Indian country, reaches, 218, footnote
Roman Catholics: 38, footnote
Ross, John: correspondence, 69, footnote, uncle of Wm. P. Ross, 71; instructions of, 71, footnote; influence, 72; character, 72, footnote; letter of Dole to, 80, footnote; no one firmer friend to Union than, 86, footnote; correspondence with John B. Ogden, 89, footnote, 115, footnote; called upon by commissioners from Texas, 93; letter from Governor Rector, 112; letter to Rector, 117; letter from citizens of Boonsboro, 111, footnote, 124; J. R. Kannady communicates with, 125; issues proclamation of neutrality, 125, 153-154; Albert Pike unjust to, 134, footnote; letter of Hubbard to, 144-145; reply to Hubbard, 146-147; correspondence with Ben McCulloch, 149-151; sincerity possibly doubted, 168; declared shrewd, 189, footnote; Ridge Party attempts to undermine popularity, 215; attends meeting of Cherokee Executive Council, 217; address, 220, 223; suspected of not acting in good faith, 226; notifies Pike of Cherokee willingness to treat, 234; communicates with Creeks and Osages, 235; called upon to rally Cherokees, 256
Ross, Lewis: 138, footnote
Ross, Mrs. John: 220, footnote
Ross, Mrs. William P: work cited, 71, footnote
Ross, William P: 71, 89, footnote, 116, footnote, 137, footnote, 139, footnote, 217, 223
Ross, W. W: 210, footnote
Ross Party: opposed to removal, 49; majority party, 153
Round Mountain: 255
Route: of Opoethleyohola’s retreat, 261-262 and footnote
Rust, Albert: 105, footnote
Rutherford, A. H: 30, footnote, 190, footnote
Rutherford, Samuel M: 86, footnote, 183, 199 and footnote, 319
Sackett, Major: 98, footnote
Sacs and Foxes: of Missouri, 36, footnote
San Antonio: 52, footnote
Sands: see Ok-ta-ha-hassee Harjo
Schoenmaker, John: 182, footnote
Scott, S. S: 198, footnote, 201, footnote, 314, 321
Scott, Winfield: 88, footnote, 97, 249
Scottish Songs: work cited, 108, footnote
Screw Fly: work cited, 56, footnote
Scullyville: Choctaw constitution of, 51; Creek regiment forming at, 211
Sebastian, William K: 106, footnote, 287
Secession: meeting held by white men and Choctaw half-bloods, 77; Presbyterian ordained missionaries favor, 79; Indian country threatened by advocates for, 80; Indian agents active for, 82-83 and footnote; mercenary motives in urging, 98, footnote; sentiment in Arkansas, 103 et seq.; Pike offers arguments for, 133; secret organization of “Pins,” 135, footnote; Stand Watie’s party afraid to raise flag of, 140, footnote; large element within Cherokee Nation favors, 153; Griffith appointed commissioner to interview Indians in interests of, 184; Indian opponents absent from Pike’s meeting at North Fork Village, 192; Jones most prominent of Choctaw advocates, 197; traces of influence of, 208; August mass-meeting of Cherokees ending in, 217
Second Seminole War: 20, footnote, 23, footnote, 164, footnote, 164-166
Secret Society: purpose of organization, 32, footnote; in Missouri, 35, footnote; among full-blooded Cherokees, 48; “the Pins,” 86, footnote, 135, footnote, 216; among Cherokees for abolition purposes, 291, 293; Greenwood orders its dissolution, 292; Cowart’s views upon schemes of, 294
Sells, Elijah: 186, footnote
Seminole Treaty: 157 and footnote; declares allegiance to C. S. A., 159, footnote; contains guarantee of autonomy, 159, footnote; contains promise of representation in Congress, 159, footnote; negotiated, 197-199, 197, footnote; considered by Provisional Congress, 206
Seminoles: from Florida, 20; removal in late fifties, 20, footnote; status of free negro among, 40; Presbyterians among, 40; manifest only slight interest in education, 40, footnote; given home in Creek country, 50; destitute, 57, footnote; representatives at inter-tribal conference, 71; letter to chief of, 80, footnote; condition reported by Carruth, 84, footnote; in council with Creeks, Cherokees, Quapaws, and Sacs, 94; negotiations of Pike with, 136, footnote; complaint against General Jesup, 164, footnote; Rector’s transactions with, 182, footnote
Seneca and Shawnee Treaty: 157 and footnote
Senecas: 51, 64, 67; negotiations of Pike with, 136, footnote; from Cattaraugus Reservation, 227, footnote
Senecas and Shawnees: 51, 64, 67; negotiations of Pike with, 136, footnote, 237
Settlers: in Kansas demand that Indians vacate territory, 36
Seward, William H: reference to “higher law” speech, 42, footnote; Chicago speech, 58, 75; Senate speech, 58
Shawnee Manual Labor School, 38
Shawnee Mission: work of Rev. Thomas Johnson at, 22, footnote
Shawnees: from Ohio, 19; tarry in Missouri, 19, footnote; pro-slavery men among, 35; reported by Agent Dorn as anxious to leave Kansas, 36, footnote; Baptist school on reservation of, 38; Southern Methodists among, 38; as refugees, 57, footnote; trouble over tribal elections, 209, footnote; attack Wichita Agency, 329, footnote
Shon-tah-sob-ba [Black Dog]: 235, footnote, 238, footnote
Short Bird: 319
Shoshone: suggested territory of, 32, footnote
Siebert, W. H: work cited, 23, footnote, 49, footnote
Sigel, Franz: 215, footnote
Simon, Ben: 329, footnote
Sioux: uprising, 21, footnote; warriors, 227, footnote
Slaughter, Thomas C: 208
Slavery: in Kansas, 22; encouraged, 22; among Southern Indians, 22, 292; influence of churches upon, 37; white men to prevent abolition among Indians, 42; opposition among Choctaws and Chickasaws, 45; is being interfered with by intruders, 47; cause in jeopardy among Cherokees, 48; North to exterminate among Indians, 145; recognized as legal institution by treaties, 166 and footnote; offers easy solution of labor problem, 219; Cowart reports complaints of interference with, 293
Slaves: 22, 142, 143, 144-145, 165, 166, footnote, 167, footnote, 172, 216, 261
Smith, Andrew J: charges against, 41, footnote
Smith, Caleb B: 74, footnote, 183, 242, 271, 274, 275
Smith, E. Kirby: 100, footnote
Smith, John G: 192
Smith, William R: work cited, 108, footnote, 109, footnote
Snow, George C: 198, footnote, 199, footnote
Southern Baptist Convention: 39, footnote
Southern Baptists: 38, 39
South Carolina: 20, footnote
Southern Indians: 18, 21, 32, 34, 36
Southern Methodists: 38, 39, 40
Southern Superintendency: 30, footnote
Sparrow, Edward: 127
Spencer Academy: 40, footnote, 75, 76, 78
Springfield: 214, footnote, 217, 255, 283, 312, 334
Spy companies: reported equipped by Federals, 306
Stand Watie: 49, footnote, 137, footnote, 153, 156, footnote, 227, 240, 283, 324
Stanton, Edwin M: 276, 279
Stanwood, Edward: work cited, 106, footnote
Stark, O. P: 76
State Department (C. S. A.): Albert Pike, commissioner from, 134, footnote, 152; Bureau of Indian Affairs, part of, 188, footnote
Stephens, Alexander H: work cited, 118, footnote, 119, footnote
Stevens, R. S: 209, footnote
Stevens, Thaddeus: 210, footnote
Stidham, G. W: 194
Stocks: 61, 76, 203, footnote
Stockton, G. B: 107, footnote, 186, footnote
Strain, J. H: 285, 287
Sturm, J. J: 199, 201, footnote, 330, 331, 353, 357
Sumner, Charles: 45, footnote
Sur-cox-ie: 268, footnote
Surveyors: 53
Tahlequah: 39, footnote, 93, 188, footnote, 217, and footnote, 218, footnote, 226, 234, 237, 293
Tallise Fixico: 194
Tatum, Mark T: 50, footnote, 104, footnote, 296
Taylor, J. W: 193, footnote
Taylor, N. G: 30, footnote
Tennessee: Cherokees from, 20; John J. Humphreys from, 185
Tenney, W. J: work cited, 90, footnote
Tents: furnished to refugees, 261
Territorial expansion: 28, 58
Territorial form of government: 30, 31, footnote, 33
Texas: indigenous tribes in, 19, footnote; Indians expelled from, 19, footnote, 52, 340; Cherokees in, 20, footnote; annexed, 28; troops from, 53; Indian patronage, 59; Indian participation in Civil War, 63; interest in Indian Territory, 67; interest in securing alliance of Indians, 83, 88, 90; interest in amnesty provisions of Indian treaties, 175-176; commissioners from, 183; attitude of northern countries of, 200, footnote; desires Reserve Indians placed under her jurisdiction, 297
Texas Historical Association Quarterly: work cited, 20, footnote
Texas Superintendency: 56, footnote
Thomason, Hugh F: 202, 335
Thompson, Jacob: 45, footnote, 46, 54, 56, footnote
Tishomingo: county of, 68, footnote
Tonkawas: 52 and footnote, 189, footnote, 200, 201, footnote, 340, 353
Toombs, Robert: 129, 131, 134 and footnote, 135, footnote, 152
Totten, James: 103, 104
Traders: 22, 27, 59-60, 169 et seq., 193, footnote, 238-239, 319
Trammel, Dennis: 288, 289
Treat, S. B: 43, footnote
Treaties: 34, footnote, 37, footnote, 53, 78, 84, footnote, 102, 117, 122, footnote; made with Indians as with foreign powers, 17; Ohio desires information as to Manypenny, 33, footnote; relations to U. S. in, 70, footnote; obligation to abide by, 71, footnote; reduction of forts violation of guaranties in, 97, footnote; resulting from council at Tahlequah, 237 et seq.; with the Cherokees in part the result of intimidation, 240, footnote; with the Neosho Agency Indians, 241; money due the Creeks under, 289; Pike reports all ratified, 320; amendments to, 323; manuscript copies of, 329-330, footnote; no Indian Department to be organized until ratification of, 331; terms of the, with the wild Indians, 352; Leeper makes a, with the Comanches, 354-355
Troops: Confederate—in Cherokee country, 136, footnote; no Arkansas, available, 253, footnote; Van Dorn’s erroneous surmise as to proportion of white, in Pike’s brigade, 280; Van Dorn’s plans as to disposition of, 283; Leeper inquires when, may be expected, 310; Pike’s confidence in white, 320; lack of, in Leased District, 343, 349; non-arrival of, 345. Indian—Confederacy secure before negotiation of treaties of alliance, 207; plans for distribution of, 207; Cherokee, under McCulloch, 226-227; Northern, offer to furnish U. S. with, 227, footnotes; large and increasing number in Indian Territory, 252; not possible to keep order, 346. United States—few within Indian country, 52-53; Secretary Floyd disposed to withdraw from Indian frontier, 53; from Texas ordered to protect U. S. surveyors, 53; number to be retained in Indian country queried, 72, footnote; Carruth reports all gone from Indian Territory, 86, footnote; ordered to leave, 87 and footnote; disposition, reported upon by Texas commissioners, 95; under Emory ordered to Indian Territory, 96 et seq.; flee from Indian Territory, 101; dissatisfaction at reported change in disposition in Arkansas, 103, 105; to counteract influence of secessionists, 216; method of warfare under Lane, 233; Dole urges to re-occupy Indian Territory, 241; sudden withdrawal spreads alarm in Leased District, 299
True Democrat: work cited, 47, footnote, 48, footnote, 106, footnote
Tuckabatche Micco: 51, footnote
Tuckabatchee Town: 193, footnote
Tulsey Town: 255
Turnbull, John P: 189, footnote
Turner, J. W: 260, 272, footnote
Tusaquach: 247
Tush-ca-horn-ma: district of, 179
Twiggs, D. E: 55, footnote, 87
Umatilla: suggested territory of, 32, footnote
Underground railroad: 40
Upper Arkansas Agency: 210, footnote
Upper Creeks: 50, 208, footnote, 191, footnote, 192, 193, footnote, 236, footnote, 244, 319
Usher, John P: 56, footnote, 228, footnote
Van Buren (Ark.): 64, footnote
Van Dorn, Earl: 55, 138, footnote, 280, 283
Vann, Joseph: 217, 223
Verdigris River: 259, 272
Wah-pa-nuc-ka Institute: 40, footnote
Walker, David: 116, 298
Walker, Leroy P: 119, 127, 142, 147, 151, 161, 200, footnote, 207, 215, footnote
Walker, William: head chief of the Wyandots, 22, footnote
Walker, William: 105, footnote
Wall, David: 23, footnote
Walnut Creek: 259
War Department: C. S. A., 128, footnote, 139, footnote, 140, footnote, 193, footnote, 257, footnote; U. S. A., 52, 80, 87, 96, 228, footnote, 234, 241, 250, 264-265, 275
Washburn, J. W: 84, footnote, 164, footnote, 238, and footnote
Washita: Indians driven from country of, 19, footnote
Wattles, Augustus: 229, footnote
Waul, Thomas N: 127, 205
Weas: from Illinois, 19
Weber’s Falls: 86, footnote
Welch, George W: 84, footnote
West Florida: seizure of, 28
West Point: 215, footnote
Wheelock: Choctaw school, 39, footnote
White, Joseph: 209, footnote
White, S. W: letter of, 33, footnote
White Cloud: 227, footnote
Whitney, Henry C: 208 and footnote
Whittenhall, Daniel S: 350
Wichita Agency: site for, 54, 56, footnote, 136, footnote; attack upon, 329, footnote
Wichita Mountains: 51, 55
Wichita Treaty: 157, footnote, 158, 163, 176
Wichitas: 52; colonization of, 55; subsistence given to, 57, footnote; Leased District of, 63; colonized on land claimed as their own, 166; Pike hopes to meet, 189, footnote; Pike fears hostility of, 200; refuse to be cajoled or intimidated, 201
Wilson, Henry: work cited, 32, footnote
Wilson, William: 23, footnote
Wilson’s Creek: battle of, 225
Winneconne: 219, footnote
Wisconsin: tribes from, 19
Wolcott, Edward: 273, footnote
Worcester, Reverend S. A: 23, footnote; opposed to slavery, 41
Wyandots: from Ohio and Michigan, 19; William Walker, head chief of, 22, footnote; initiate movement for organization of Nebraska Territory, 34; interested in Kansas election troubles, 34, footnote; Methodism, 38
Yancton Sioux: Agent Burleigh suggests that garrison Fort Randall, 227, footnote
Young, William C: 100
Yulee, David L: 238, footnote
Footnotes:
[1] Confessedly much to its discredit, the United States government has never had, for any appreciable length of time, a well-developed and well-defined Indian policy, one that has made the welfare of the aborigines its sole concern. Legislation for the subject race has almost invariably been dictated by the needs of the hour, by the selfish and exorbitant demands of pioneers, and by the greed and caprice of politicians.
[2] There were, of course, other indigenous tribes to the westward, in the direction of Colorado and Texas, and to the northward, in southern Nebraska; but only the latter were more than remotely affected, as far as local habitation was concerned, by the coming of the eastern emigrants and the consequent introduction of the reservation system.
[3] Kansas Historical Society Collections, vol. viii, 72-109.
[4] In scarcely a single case here cited was the old home of the tribe limited by the boundaries of a single state nor is it to be understood that the state here mentioned was necessarily the original habitat of the tribe. It was only the territorial headquarters of the tribe at the time of removal or at the time when the policy of removal was first insisted upon as a sine qua non. Some of the Indians emigrated independently of treaty arrangements with the United States government and some did not immediately direct their steps towards Kansas or Oklahoma; but made, through choice or through necessity, an intervening point a stopping-place. The Kickapoos, the Shawnees, and the Delawares tarried in Missouri, the Choctaws and the Cherokees, many of them, in Arkansas but that was before 1830, the date of the removal law. After 1830, there was no possible resting-place for weary Indians this side of the Ozark Mountains.
[5] Some of the more insignificant southern Indians eventually found their way also to Oklahoma. In 1860 there were a few Louisiana Caddoes in the northwestern part of the Chickasaw country, most likely the same that, in 1866, were reported to have been driven out of Texas in 1839 by bushwhackers and then out of the Washita country at the opening of the Civil War. They continued throughout the war loyal to the United States. In 1853 the Choctaw General Council passed an act admitting to the rights of citizenship several Catawba Indians; and from that circumstance, the Office of Indian Affairs surmised that the Choctaws would be willing to incorporate Catawbas yet in the Carolinas. In 1857 there were about seventy Catawbas in South Carolina on a tiny reservation. They expressed an ardent wish to go among the Choctaws. In 1860 the Catawbas were in possession of the northeastern part of the Choctaw country.
[6] For the detailed history of events leading up to Indian removals, particularly the southern, see American Historical Association, Report, 1906, 241-450.
[7] Not all of the southern Indians had emigrated in the thirties and forties. A considerable number of Cherokees removed themselves from the country east of the Mississippi to Texas. This was immediately subsequent to and induced by the American Revolution [Texas Historical Association, Quarterly, July, 1897, 38-46 and October, 1903, 95-165]. Many Cherokees, likewise, took the suggestion of President Jefferson and moved to the Arkansas country prior to 1820. Moreover, there were “Eastern Cherokees” in controversy with the “Western Cherokees” for many years after the Civil War. Their endless quarrels over property proved the occasion of much litigation. In the late fifties active measures were taken by the Office of Indian Affairs to complete the removal of the Seminoles and to accomplish by intrigue and diplomacy what the long and expensive Second Seminole War had utterly failed to do. Elias Rector of Arkansas superintended the matter and the Seminole chief, John Jumper, gave valuable assistance, as did also the Creeks, who generously granted to the Seminoles a home within the Creek country west [Creek Treaty, 1856, Kappler’s Indian Laws and Treaties, vol. ii, 757]. Billy Bowlegs was the last Seminole chief of prominence to leave Florida [Coe’s Red Patriots, 198]. In 1853 there were still some four hundred Choctaws reported as living in Alabama and there must have been even more than that in Mississippi. In 1854 steps were taken, but unsuccessfully, for their removal. In 1859 Representative John J. McRae presented a petition from citizens of various Mississippi counties asking that the Choctaws be removed altogether from the state because of their intimacy and intercourse with the negroes. The Office of Indian Affairs refused to act. Perchance, it considered the moment inopportune or the means at hand insufficient. It may even have considered the charge against the Choctaws a mere pretext and quite unfounded since it was commonly reported that the Choctaws had a decided aversion to that particular kind of race mixture. In that respect they differed very considerably from the Creeks who to-day are said to present a very curious spectacle of an almost complete mixture. Choctaws from Mississippi and Cherokees from North Carolina and Catawbas from South Carolina fought with the South in the Civil War.
[8] Other Indians made trouble during the progress of the Civil War, as, for instance, the Sioux in the summer of 1862. The Sioux, however, were not fighting for or against the issues of the white man’s war. They were simply taking advantage of a favorable occasion, when the United States government was preoccupied, to avenge their own wrongs.
[9] The existence of the “Cherokee Neutral Land” out of which the southeastern counties of Kansas were illegitimately formed was not exactly an exception to this. The Neutral Land, eight hundred thousand acres in extent, was an independent purchase, made by the Cherokees, and was not included in the exchange or in the original scheme that forced their removal from Georgia. It was a subsequent concession to outraged justice.
[10] By far the best instance of missionary activity in behalf of slavery among the northern Indian immigrants is to be found in the case of the Reverend Thomas Johnson’s work at the Shawnee Mission [Ray’s Repeal of the Missouri Compromise, footnote 207]. Johnson, like William Walker, head chief of the Wyandots, was an ardent pro-slavery advocate [ibid., footnote 205] and took a rather disgracefully prominent part in the notorious election frauds of early Kansas territorial days [House Report, 34th congress, first session, no. 200, pp. 14, 18, 94, 425].
[11] Buchanan’s Works, vol. iii, 348, 350, 353.
[12] Siebert’s Underground Railroad from Slavery to Freedom, 284.
[13] The most interesting case that came up in this connection was that of the so-called Beams’ Negroes, resident in the Choctaw country and illegally claimed as refugees by John B. Davis of Mississippi [Indian Office, Special Files, no. 277]. The Reverend S. A. Worcester interested himself in their behalf [Jefferson Davis to Worcester, October 7, 1854] and a decision was finally rendered in their favor. Another interesting case of similar nature was, “In re negroes taken from Overton Love and David Wall of the Chickasaw Nation by Citizens of Texas, 1848-’57” [ibid., no. 278].
[14] Under the Intercourse Law of 1834, the Indian Territory had been annexed for judicial purposes to the western district of Arkansas. The Indians were much dissatisfied. They felt themselves entitled to a federal court of their own, a privilege the United States government persistently denied to them but one that the Confederate government readily granted. As matters stood, prior to the Civil War, the red men seemed always at the mercy of the white man’s distorted conception of justice and were, perforce, quite beyond the reach of the boasted guaranties of theoretical Anglo-Saxon justice since the very location of the court precluded a trial by their peers of the vicinage. The journey to Arkansas, in those early days, was long and tiresome and expensive. Complications frequently arose and matters, difficult of adjustment, even under the best of circumstance. Among the Creeks and Seminoles, the status of the free negro was exceptionally high, partly due, with respect to the latter, to conditions growing out of the Second Seminole War. As already intimated, the Creeks had no aversion whatsoever to race mixtures and intermarriage between negroes and Indians was rather common. The half-breeds resulting from such unions were accepted as bona fide members of the tribe by the Indians in the distribution of annuities, but not by the United States courts—another source of difficulty and a very instructive one as well, particularly from the standpoint of reconstructionist exactions.
Occasionally the presence of the free negro within the Indian country was a source of grave danger. The accompanying letters outline a case in point:
Head Quarters 7th. Mil: Dept. Fort Smith, March 5th. 1852.
Sir: By direction of the Colonel commanding the Department I transmit herewith copies of a communication from George Folsom, Chief of the Pushmataha District, to Colonel Wilson Choctaw Agent and one from Colonel William Wilson Choctaw Agent to Brevet Major Holmes commanding Fort Washita asking aid from the Military force.
As the letter from the Choctaw Agent is not sufficiently explicit as to what he wishes done by the Military authority the subject is referred to you, and if on investigation it be found that Military interference is necessary to enforce the intercourse law, prompt assistance will be rendered for the purposes therein specified, under the direction and in presence of the Choctaw Agent. Respectfully Yr Obt. Servt.,
Francis N Page, Asst. Adjt. Genl.
Colonel John Drennen, Superintendent W. T.
Inclosure
Choctaw Agency, February 9th 1852
Sir: The enclosed copy of a letter from Colonel George Folsom Chief of Pushmataha District of the Choctaw Nation will put you in possession of the facts and reasons why I address you at this time.
As the position of the free Negros and Indians alluded to in the Chief’s letter seems to be of rather a hostile character, having built themselves a Fort doubtless for the purpose of defending themselves if interupted in their present location, it seems to me necessary that they should be driven away if necessary by Military authority; and, as your post is the most convenient to the place where the Negroes and Indians are Forted I have thought that a command could be sent with less trouble and at less expense to the government by you than any one else. I would therefore most respectfully call upon you to take such steps as you may think most advisable to remove from the Choctaw country the persons complained of by the Chief, and if necessary call upon Chief Folsom to aid you with his light horse, who may be of much service to you in the way of Guides. Very Respectfully Yr. Obt Servt.
(Signed) William Wilson, Choctaw Agent
[Endorsement] A true Copy, Francis N Page, Asst. Adjt. Genl.
Inclosure
Pushmataha District, January 23. 1852.
Dear Sir: I spoke to you about those free negroes upon the head waters of Boggy, when I last saw you, requesting to have something done with them. I have just learned that the negroes and some Indians are banded together and have built themselves a little Fort. There is no doubt but that they will be a great trouble to us. One of our country judges sent for the light-horse-men to go and seize the negroes, but I have forbid them going, and many of our people wish to go and see them. I have forbid any body to go there with intentions to take them. It will no doubt be hard to break them up. You have probably just returned home, and it may seem tresspassing upon you to write you about those negroes and Indians, but you are our agent and we have the right to look to you for help. It seems to me this affair wants an immediate action on it.
I have simply stated to you how these negroes and Indians are Forted up that you may better know how to deal with them. In purforming your duties if I can in any way render you any assistance I shall always be happy to do so. Very respectfully Your friend
(Signed) George Folsom, Chief Push: Dist:
Col: William Wilson, Choctaw Agent [Endorsement] a true Copy, Francis N Page, Asst. Adjt. Genl.
[15] Buchanan’s Works, vol. x, “the Catron letter,” 106; “the Grier letter,” 106-107.
[16] This was as it appeared to N. G. Taylor, Commissioner of Indian Affairs, as he looked back, in 1867, upon events of the past few years. He was then of the opinion that the very existence of slavery among the southern tribes had most probably saved their country from being coveted by emigrants going westward.
[17] One agency under the Southern Superintendency, the Neosho River Agency, was, however, included in the scheme preliminary to the organization of Kansas and Nebraska. See the following letters found in Thomas S. Drew’s Letter Press Book:
(a) Office Supt. Ind. Affairs Fort Smith, Arks., Dec. 21, 1853.
Sir: Inclosed herewith you will receive letters from Agent Dorn, dated the 1st and 2nd instant; the former in relation to the disposition of the Indians within his agency to meet Commissioners on the subject of selling their lands, or having a Territorial form of Government extend over them by the United States: and the latter nominating John Finch as Blacksmith to the Great and Little Osages. Very respectfully Your obt. servt.
A. H. Rutherford, Clerk for Supt.
Hon. Geo. W. Manypenny, Comr Ind. Affairs Washington City.
(b) Office Supt. Indian Affairs Fort Smith, Arks. Dec. 29, 1853.
Sir: ... I have also to acknowledge the receipt of letters from you of the 2nd instant to the Commissioner of Ind. Affrs. upon the subject of the Indians within your Agency being willing to meet Commissioners on the part of the U. S. preparatory to selling their lands, or to take into consideration the propriety of admitting a Territorial form of Government extended over them &. ...
A. H. Rutherford, Clerk for Supt.
A. J. Dorn, U. S. Indian Agt., Crawford Seminary.
[18] In this connection, the following are of interest:
(a) The Choctaws, it is understood, are prepared to receive and assent to the provisions of a bill introduced three years since into the Senate by Senator Johnson of Arkansas, for the creation of the Territories of Chah-la-kee, Chah-ta, and Muscokee, and it is greatly to be hoped that that or some similar bill may be speedily enacted.... Their country, a far finer one than Kansas.... The Choctaws have adopted a new constitution, vesting the supreme executive power in a governor.... It is understood that this change has been made preparatory to the acceptance of the bill already mentioned.
The foregoing is taken from the Annual Report of the southern superintendent for 1857 and in that report, Elias Rector who was then the superintendent, having taken office that very year, argued that all the five great tribes ought to be allowed to have delegates on the floor of Congress and to be made citizens of the United States; for the constitutions of the Cherokees, Choctaws, and Chickasaws would compare favorably, said he, with those of any of the southwestern states [Senate Documents, 35th congress, first session, vol. ii, 485].
(b) The Fort Smith Times of February 3, 1859 printed the following:
Sam Houston and the Presidency
The following we take from a printed slip sent to us by our Doaksville correspondent, who informs us that it was sent to that office just as he sends it. We presume that it is the programme laid down by some of the Texas papers, friendly to the election of Sam Houston to the Presidency....
Re-organization of the Territories
1. The organization of the Aboriginal Territory of Decotah, from that part of the late Territory of Minnesota, lying west of the State of Minnesota.
2. To fix the western boundaries of Kansas and Nebraska, at the Meridian 99 or 100; and to establish in those Territories, Aboriginal counties, for the exclusive and permanent occupation of the Aboriginal tribes now located east of that line and within those Territories; also to provide, that said Territories shall not be admitted into the Union as States unless their several Constitutions provide for the continuation of the Federal regulations adopted for better government and welfare of the Aboriginal tribes inhabiting the same.
3. To organize the Indian territory lying west of Arkansas, as “the Aboriginal Territory of Neosho,” under regulation similar to those proposed by Hon. Robert W. Johnson of Arkansas in 1854 for the organization of the Indian territory of Neosho.
4. To purchase from the State of Texas all that portion of the State lying north of the Red river and include the same in the Aboriginal territory of Comanche or Ouachita.
5. The territory of New Mexico.
6. From the western portion of New Mexico to take the Aboriginal territory of Navajoe.
7. From the western portion of Utah, to take the Aboriginal territory of Shoshone.
Re-organize the eastern part of Utah, (the Mormon country), as an Aboriginal territory.
Organize the western territory of Osage.
From Nebraska, west of the M.100, and south of the 45th parallel take the Aboriginal territory of Mandan.
Organize the eastern half of Oregon, as the Aboriginal territory of Umatilla.
Washington east of the M.118 to be the Aboriginal territory of Okanagan.
Nebraska, north of the 45th parallel to be the Aboriginal territory of Assinneboin. Emigration into these territories to be prohibited by law of Congress, until the same shall have been admitted into the Union as States.
In each territory, a resident Military Police to preserve order....
(c) Henry Wilson, in the Rise and Fall of the Slave Power, vol. ii, 634-635 says,
In the Indian Territory there were four tribes of Indians—Cherokees, Choctaws, Chickasaws, and Creeks. Under the fostering care of their governments slavery had become so firmly established that slaveholders thought them worthy of political fellowship, and articles in favor of their admission began to appear in the southern press. “The progress of civilization,” said the New Orleans “Picayune,” “in several of the Indian tribes west of the States will soon bring up a new question for the decision of Congress.... It cannot fail to give interest to this question that each of the Indian tribes has adopted the social institutions of the South.” To concentrate and give direction to such efforts, a secret organization was formed to encourage Southern emigration, and to discourage and prevent the entrance into the Territory of all who were hostile to slaveholding institutions. It was hoped thus to guard against adverse fortune which had defeated their purposes and plans for Kansas....
[19] With reference to the proposed organization the subjoined documents are of interest:
C. Street, July 2.
Mr. Mix,
Dear Sir, Please have the western boundary of Mis. laid down on this map, and the outline of the Pawnee, Kanzas & Osage purchases, and the reservations, as they now stand within that outline. You need not show each purchase, but the outline of the whole. Yours truly
Thomas H. Benton.
Letter of July 2, 1853, Indian Office Miscellaneous Files, 1851-1854.
Washington City, August 5th, 1854.
Hon. G. W. Manypenny Esq., Com Indian Department, Washington City.
Dear Sir, Many people of Ohio, as well as of the states west of it, have for a long time been most anxious to learn through your Department, the nature of the several treaties made by yourself in behalf of the Government, with the several tribes of Indians occupying the Territories of Nebraska & Kansas: particularly as to the reservation of land made by such Tribes, its extent, where, when, & how to be located, & within what time,—and also what lands in both of said Territories by virtue of said treaties are now subject to location?
I regret to inform you that much censure has attached to your Department, in consequence of the delay which has attended the promulgation of the above information, but which from my long knowledge of you personally, and of the very prompt manner in which you have invariably discharged your public duties, I believe to be most unjust.
I seek the above information, not only for myself (contemplating a removal to Kansas) but also in behalf of many persons in the western states, who have solicited my intervention in that matter on my visit to this City. Very respectfully your friend
S. W. White
Indian Office Miscellaneous Files, 1851-1854.
C. Street, Aug. 19, ’53.
To Geo. W. Manypenny Esq., Com. of Indian Affairs,
Sir, I have the honor to acknowledge the receipt of your note of yesterday with the accompanying copy of a letter to the Hon. Mr. Atchison, and make my thanks to you for this mark of your attention. The reply will be immediately forwarded to Meas Ami, to be published in the same paper in which your note to me covering the map on which the Indian’s cessions & reserves west of Missouri, was published. Very respectfully, Sir, Yr. obt. servant,
Thomas H. Benton.
Indian Office Miscellaneous Files, 1851-1854.
[20] Ray, op. cit., 86; Connelley, in Kansas Historical Society, Collections, vol. vi, 102; Connelley, Provincial Government of Nebraska Territory, pp. 24, 30 et seq.
The Wyandots took an active part in the Kansas election troubles. For some evidence of that, see, House Reports, 34th congress, first session, no. 200, pp. 22, 266.
[21] By the treaty of 1837 [Kappler, op. cit., vol. ii, 486], the Choctaws, for a money consideration as was natural, agreed to let the Chickasaws occupy their country jointly with themselves and form a Chickasaw District within it that should be on a par with the other districts (Moo-sho-le-tubbee, Apucks-hu-nubbe, and Push-ma-ta-ha), or political units, of the Choctaw Nation. The arrangement meant political consolidation, one General Council serving for the two tribes, but each tribe retaining control of its own annuities. The boundaries of the Chickasaw District proved the subject of a contention, constant and bitter. Civil war was almost precipitated more than once. Finally, in 1855, the political connection was brought to an end by the terms of the Treaty of Washington [Kappler, op. cit., vol. ii, 706], negotiated in that year.
[22] See Report of C. C. Copeland to Cooper, August 27, 1855.
[23] A secret society is said to have been formed in Missouri for the express purpose of gaining the Shawnee land for slavery.
[24] Dean wrote to Butler, November 29, 1855 [Letter Press Book] saying that the disturbed state of things in Kansas was having a very serious effect upon the Cherokee Neutral Land. Early in 1857, Butler reported that he had given notice that if intruders had not removed themselves by spring he would have them removed by the military [Butler to Dean, January 9, 1857]. Manypenny approved Butler’s course of action which is quite significant, considering that the federal administration was supposed to be unreservedly committed to the pro-slavery cause and the intruders were pro-slavery men from across the border.
[25] Andrew Dorn took charge of the Neosho Agency, to which these reservations as well as the Quapaw, Seneca, and Seneca and Shawnee belonged, in 1855 and regularly had occasion to complain of intruders. White people seem to have felt that they could with impunity encroach upon the New York Indian lands because they were only sparsely settled and because the Indian title was in dispute.
[26] Apart from any sectional desire to obtain the Indian country, would-be settlers seem to have been attracted thither from a mistaken notion that there were mines of precious metals west of Missouri [Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Report, 1858].
[27] As early as 1857, the Sacs and Foxes of Missouri were reported as looking for a new home to the southward, in a less rigorous climate, and, with that purpose in mind, they visited the Cherokees. When the Delaware treaty of 1860 was being negotiated, the Delawares expressed themselves as very anxious to get away from white interference, to leave Kansas. The Ottawas thought and thought rightly, forsooth, judging from the experience of the past, that removal would do no good. They declared a preference for United States citizenship and tribal allotment [Jotham Meeker, Baptist missionary, to Agent James, September 4, 1854, also Agent James’s Report, 1857]. At this same period, Agent Dorn reported that the Kansas River Shawnees were desirous of joining those of the Neosho Agency. Greenwood replied, January 18, 1860, that the subject of allowing the northern Indians to go south was then under consideration by the department [Letter to Superintendent Rector].
[28] The evidence of this is to be found in a letter from W. G. Coffin to Dole, June 17, 1861 [Neosho Files, 1838-1865, C1223].
[29] For information on this subject, see Carroll’s American Church History, 19, 93, 253-254, 302.
[30] Feeling that, under the treaty of 1854, they were free to choose whatever denomination they pleased to reside among them, the Kickapoos expressed a preference for the Methodist Episcopal Church South, but the Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions was already established among their neighbors of the Otoe and Missouria and Great Nemaha Agencies, their own agent, Mr. Baldwin, was a Presbyterian, and so, before long, in some almost unaccountable way, they found that the Presbyterians (Old School) had obtained an entry upon their reserve and had established a mission school there. The Kickapoos were indignant, as well they had a right to be, and made as much trouble as they possibly could for the Presbyterians. In 1860, the Presbyterian Board vacated the premises and the Methodist Episcopal Church South took possession, Agent Badger favoring the change. The change was of but short duration, however; for, in 1861, the Southern Methodists, finding the sympathy of the Kickapoos was mainly with the federal element, took their departure.
[31] Ray, op. cit., 86, footnote 107.
[32] The most flourishing schools seem to have been the Roman Catholic. The Roman Catholics did not greatly concern themselves, as a church organization, with the slavery agitation, and St. Mary’s Mission and the Osage Manual Labor School were scarcely affected by the war and not at all by the troubles that presaged its approach.
[33] The Baptist school among the Potawatomies closed in 1861. See Appendix.
[34] House Report, 34th congress, first session, no. 200, pp. 14, 18, 94, 425.
[35] See Indian Office, Special File, no. 220.
[36] The work of the American Board among the Cherokees was discontinued just before the war [Missionary Herald, 1861, p. 11; American Board Report, 1860, p. 137].
[37] The four were: “Park hill, five miles south from Tahlequah; Dwight, forty-two miles south-southwest from Tahlequah; Fairfield, twenty-five miles southeast from Tahlequah; Lee’s creek, forty-three miles southeast from Tahlequah”—Commissioner of Indian Affairs [Report, 1859, p. 173]. There had been a fifth, an out station.
[38] The Congregational schools among the Choctaws were: Iyanubbi, near the Arkansas line; Wheelock, eighteen miles east of Doaksville; and Chuahla, one mile from Doaksville.
[39] The Southern Baptist Convention had not been long in the county prior to the Civil War. The Methodist Episcopal Church South had no schools but several missionaries. The American Baptist Missionary Union had a number of meeting-houses.
[40] The Presbyterians (Old School) established Wah-pa-nuc-ka Institute for young women, forty miles north of Red River and one and one-eighth miles west of the Choctaw and Chickasaw line; but differences arose between the Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions and the Chickasaw authorities, neither institutional nor sectional, but purely financial, which caused the Presbyterians to abandon the school in 1860 [C. H. Wilson, attorney for the Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions, to Cooper, April 16, 1860]. The Presbyterian schools among the Choctaws were: Spencer Academy, “located on the old military road leading from Fort Towson to Fort Smith, about ten miles north of Fort Towson,” and Koonsha Female Seminary. Both of them were under the Presbyterian Board. A third institution, Armstrong Academy, belonged to the Cumberland Presbyterians. The Southern Methodists had Bloomfield Academy, Colbert Institute, and the Chickasaw Manual Labor School among the Chickasaws; and the Fort Coffee and New Hope academies, for boys and girls respectively, among the Choctaws.
[41] The Seminoles were late in manifesting an interest in education, and, when interest did arise among them, John Jumper, the chief, declared for boarding-schools and asked that such be established under the Presbyterian Board, the same that had influence among their near neighbors, the Creeks.
[42] The American Board itself was inclined to be non-committal and temporizing [Garrison, op. cit., vol. iii, 30]. The Missionary Herald, so valuable an historical source as it proved itself to be for Indian removals, is strangely silent on the great subject of negro slavery among the Indians. Its references to it are only very occasional and never more than incidental.
[43] Kingsbury was superintendent of the Chuahla Female Seminary.
[44] Worcester died, April, 1859 [Missionary Herald, 1859, p. 187; 1860, p. 12].
[45] Missionary Herald, 1859, pp. 335-336; 1860, p. 12; The American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, Report, 1856, p. 195.
[46] Report of C. C. Copeland, 1860.
[47] Cooper was also Chickasaw agent. On the fifth of October, 1854, some of the principal men of the Chickasaw Nation, Cyrus Harris, James Gamble, Sampson Folsom, Jackson Frazier, and D. Colbert, petitioned President Pierce for the removal of Agent Andrew J. Smith on charges of official irregularity and gross immorality. A year later, Superintendent Dean reiterated the charges. Smith’s commission was revoked, November 9, 1855; and, in March, 1856, Cooper was assigned the Chickasaws as an additional charge. Henceforth, the two tribes had an agent in common.
[48] This note itself bore no date but there is documentary proof that it was received at Fort Smith, November 27, 1854. It is to be found in the Indian Office among the Fort Smith Papers.
[49] The allusion is, of course, to the “higher law” doctrine expressed in Seward’s Senate Speech of March 11, 1850.
[50] Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Report, 1859, pp. 190-191.
The letter of Dr. Treat referred to by Agent Cooper is herewith given. It is accompanied by the letter that covered it and that letter, as it is found among the Fort Smith Papers in the United States Indian Office, bears a record to the effect that the copy of it was transmitted by the southern superintendent to Washington, November 28, 1855.
Fort Towson Nov. 16, 1855
Sir: I have the pleasure to forward a copy of letter, addressed to the Revd S. B. Treat, Corresponding Secretary of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, by C. Kingsbury and others—Missionaries among the Choctaws—and request the same may be transmitted to the Hon Comr of Indian Affairs for the information of the Government of the United States.
The letter as you will perceive refers to an exciting and highly important subject—in which the States adjoining the Indian Territory are deeply & directly interested, as well as the Choctaw People.
I cannot refrain from the expression of my gratification at the position assured in this letter by the old and valued Missionaries among the Choctaws. The copy was handed to me by Revd Cyrus Kingsbury, one of the signers to the original letter. Respectfully
Douglas H. Cooper, U. S. Agent for Choctaws
Hon. C. M. Dean, Supt. Indian Affairs, Ft Smith.
[Inclosure]—Copy
Pine Ridge, Choc. Na. Nov. 15, 1855.
Rev. S. B. Treat, Cor. Secretary of the A.B.C.F.M.
Rev. & Dear Brother, When the Rev. G. W. Wood visited us as a deputation from the Prudential Committee, he treated us, our views, and our practice so kindly, and spoke to us so many encouraging words, that we were constrained to meet him in a similar spirit of concilliation. We were willing to re-examine the difference in views on the subject of slavery, which for a long time had existed between the Committee and ourselves, and to see if there was not common ground on which we could stand together.
At the opening of the meeting at Good Water, Mr. Wood laid aside the letter of June 22nd ’/48. This was a subject we were not to discuss. He then introduced, by way of compromise, as we understood it, certain articles to show that there were principles, or modes of expression, in relation to slavery, in which there was substantial agreement. To these articles, though not expressed in every particular as we could have wished, (and after some of them had been modified by oral explanations,) we gave our assent, for the sake of peace. We hoped it would put an end to agitation on a subject which had so long troubled us, and hindered us in our work. We took it for granted that the Committee had yielded certain important points, insisted on in the letter of June 22nd ’/48. This gladdened our hearts, and disposed us to meet Mr. Wood’s proposal in a spirit of concilliation and confidence. We are not skilled in diplomacy, and had no thought that we were assenting to articles which would be considered as covering the whole ground of the letter of June 22nd. The first intimation that we had been mistaken, was from a statement made by Mr. Wood, in New York, that the result of the meeting at Good Water “involved no change of views or action on the part of the Prudential Committee and Secretaries.”
In Mr. Wood’s report to the Pru. Com. which was read at Utica, the Good Water document was placed in such a relation on to other statements, as to make the impression that we had given our full and willing assent to the entire letter of June 22d. The Com. on that Report, of which Dr. Beman was chairman, say, “The great end aimed at by the Pru. Com. in their correspondence with these missions for several years; and by the Board at their last annual meeting; has been substantially accomplished.”
This is a result we had not anticipated. We can not consent to be thus made to sanction principles and sentiments which are contrary to our known, deliberate, and settled convictions of right, and to what we understand to be the teachings of the word of God. We are fully convinced that we can not go with the Committee and the Board, as to the manner in which as Ministers of the Gospel and Missionaries we are to deal with slavery. We believe the instructions of the Apostles, in relation to this subject, are a sufficient guide, and that if followed the best interests of society, as well as of the Church, will be secured.
We have no wish to give the Com. or the Board farther trouble on this subject. As there is no prospect that our views can be brought to harmonize, we must request that our relations to the A.B.C.F.M. may be dissolved in a way that will do the least harm to the Board, and to our Mission.