Note 108 — Chapter III

This definition, according to which opposed propositions are not necessarily incompatible with one another, is given by Aldrich (p. 53 in Mansel’s edition). Ueberweg (Logic, § 97) defines opposition in such a way as to include only contradiction and contrariety; and Mansel remarks that “subalterns are improperly classed as opposed propositions” (Aldrich, p. 59). Modern logicians, however, usually adopt Aldrich’s definition, and this seems on the whole the best course. Some term is wanted to signify the above general relation between propositions; and though it might be possible to find a more convenient term, no confusion is likely to result from the use of the term opposition if the student is careful to notice that it is here employed in a technical sense.