Note 105 — Chapter XI
Reading edition
A referendum taken on April 13, 1910, defeated the new proposals. See "Report of Premiers' Conference held at Brisbane, May, 1907" (Commonwealth Parliamentary Sessional Paper, No. 13, 1907), and for a clear statement of the whole subject, the "Year-Book (1911) of the Commonwealth of Australia." (The relevant clauses of the Constitutional Act are Nos. 88 to 93.) The reasons for the failure of the system were summarized as follows:
"1. The trouble and expense which the necessary record entails.
"2. The practical impossibility of ensuring that in every case a consuming State will be duly credited with revenue collected on its behalf in a distributing State.
"3. The difficulty involved in equitably determining the amount to be debited to the several States in respect of general Commonwealth expenses.
"4. The uncertainty on the part of the State Governments as to the amount which will become available.
"5. The impossibility of securing independent State and Commonwealth finance."
See also pp. 295-299.