Note 187 — Chapter XXIV · THE RECOGNITION OF CHARACTER OF SOILS FROM THEIR NATIVE VEGETATION; MISSISSIPPI.[183]

R. M. Harper, who has graphically described the vegetative features of the coastal plain of Georgia (Contr. from the Dep. of Bot. Colum. Univ. Nos. 192, 215, 216, 1902-05; also Bull. Torr. Bot. Club 29-32), claims the deciduous cypress of the wet pine-barrens and ponds therein, the vegetation of which greatly resembles that of the pine meadows of the Mississippi sea-coast, to be a distinct species, Taxodium imbricarium, the leaves of which are imbricated, instead of two-ranked and with spreading leaflets. He supports this distinction mainly by the differences in habit from the Louisiana swamp cypress, and the fact that the imbricated form occurs wholly on non-calcareous land, while the other is at home in the calcareous alluvial areas. The imbricated form has been observed and commented on before, as a mere ecological variation, and in the writer’s opinion this is all that can be claimed, in view of the much greater differences in the form of other trees, notably oaks, illustrated below, caused also by lime. There would, à fortiori, be reason for claiming at least three different species of post oak and black-jack (and two of willow oak), which differ not only in tree form but also in the form and number of leaf lobes, and yet can be traced into one another by innumerable transition forms. If new species are to be established on such grounds, it is hard to see where the variations manifestly due to environment are to come in.