Note 521 — Chapter VI · JOHN WILKES, VICTOR BERGER, AND THE FIVE MEMBERS (continued 2)
Reading edition
The fullest discussion of both views is in the minority report in the Roberts case, 1 Hinds’ Prec. 518 (unseated). See also Stark, 1 ibid. 433 (seated); Smith v. Brown, 1 ibid. 441 (unseated); McKee v. Young, 1 ibid. 451 (unseated); Thomas, 1 ibid. 466 (unseated); Maxwell v. Cannon, 1 ibid. 493 (seated); Campbell v. Cannon, 1 ibid. 500 (unseated); Smoot, 1 ibid. 561 (seated); discussion by House Committee, 1 ibid. 591; Berger Hearings and Report (unseated). Among those presenting the first view are Littlefield of Maine, 1 ibid. 537; Senator Knox, 1 ibid. 587; Senator Reverdy Johnson, 1 ibid. 489.