Note f125 — PRACTICAL METHODS OF ZEN INSTRUCTION

Another time when Jōshu was asked about the “first word,” he coughed. The monk remarked, “Is this not it?” “Why, an old man is not even allowed to cough!”—this came quickly from the old master. Jōshu had still another occasion to express his view on the one word. A monk asked, “What is the one word?” Demanded the master, “What do you say?” “What is the one word?”—the question was repeated when Jōshu gave his verdict, “You make it two.” (Ch. N., [6.3].)

Shuzan (Shu-shan) was once asked, “An old master says, ‘There is one word which when understood wipes out the sins of innumerable kalpas:’ what is this one word?” Shuzan answered, “Right under your nose!” “What is the ultimate meaning of it?” “This is all I can say”:—this was the conclusion of the master. (Ch. N., (Ch. N., [6.4].)