Note 5 — Introductory.

The story of the dog “Diamond” having caused the burning of certain papers is laid in London, and in Newton’s later years. In the notes to Maude’s Wenleysdale, a person then living (1780) relates, that Sir Isaac being called out of his study to a contiguous room, a little dog, called Diamond, the constant but incurious attendant of his master’s researches, happened to be left among the papers, and by a fatality not to be retrieved, as it was in the latter part of Sir Isaac’s days, threw down a lighted candle, which consumed the almost finished labour of some years. Sir Isaac returning too late but to behold the dreadful wreck, rebuked the author of it with an exclamation (ad sidera palmas), “O Diamond! Diamond! thou little knowest the mischief done!” without adding a single stripe. M. Biot gives this fiction as a true story, which happened some years after the publication of the Principia; and he characterises the accident as having deprived the sciences forever of the fruit of so much of Newton’s labours.—Brewster’s Life, vol. ii. p. 139, note. Dr. Newton remarks, that Sir Isaac never had any communion with dogs or cats; and Sir David Brewster adds, that the view which M. Biot has taken of the idle story of the dog Diamond, charged with fire-raising among Newton’s manuscripts, and of the influence of this accident upon the mind of their author, is utterly incomprehensible. The fiction, however, was turned to account in giving colour to M. Biot’s misrepresentation.